When SpaceX’s giant Starship rocket exploded over the Caribbean last year, the internet lit up with videos from airline passengers, island tourists and locals showing flaming debris shooting across the sky.
asserted
debris → explode → sky
Even some airline pilots recorded the fiery aftermath as planes scrambled to move out of its path.
asserted
planes → record → path
Some of those videos of Starship’s seventh test flight — including ones taken from Disney and Royal Caribbean cruise ships and a Club Med resort — went on to play a role in the company’s efforts to count and track pieces of debris after the explosion, a report obtained by ProPublica says.
asserted
report → include → ProPublica
The report — obtained by ProPublica from the Federal Aviation Administration through a freedom of information request — shows video captured a fireball, then a shower of sparkling debris in the sky moments after the explosion.
asserted
video → obtain → explosion
It includes maps pinpointing where the images were shot, which helped the company understand how debris tumbled to earth after the blast.
asserted
debris → include → blast
“At 1 minute 42 seconds, the debris cloud is observed transiting behind the cruise ship,” says the report, which SpaceX provided the FAA two weeks after the so-called mishap.
asserted
SpaceX → observe → mishap
Such reports are required by federal rules in the days after a rocket failure and are supposed to describe what happened and where hazardous debris landed.
asserted
debris → require → failure
The information is key for the FAA’s efforts to keep busy air traffic corridors safe at a time of rapid growth in the commercial space industry as companies like SpaceX develop and test rockets that they hope will eventually reach the moon and Mars.
asserted
they → keep → moon
During launches, the FAA preventively closes airspace.
asserted
FAA → close → airspace
It has also been forced to clear areas quickly after test flights of massive spacecraft went wrong.
asserted
flights → force → spacecraft
Starship flights 7 and 8 broke apart last year and scattered debris above airline traffic over the Caribbean.
asserted
flights → break → Caribbean
Before Flight 9, the FAA moved to greatly increase the size of the airspace it walled off pre-launch.
asserted
it → move → airspace
The agency defined its no-fly zones, which are closed to airplane traffic during a launch, and its so-called debris response areas, which are closed after a mishap, using information from SpaceX and modeling from Space Force, the branch of the military that deals with the nation’s space interests, to predict where debris might fall.
Nearly doubling those pre-launch no-fly zones “only makes sense if the prior margin was judged inadequate rather than just unlucky,” said Moriba Jah, a professor of aerospace engineering at the University of Texas at Austin.
uncertain
Jah → define → Austin
Earlier this year, the FAA issued a warning that rocket launches could “significantly reduce safety” for airplanes, after ProPublica reported that 21 planes appeared to make sudden turns to exit or avoid an FAA-designated emergency no-fly zone in the minutes after the Flight 7 explosion.
uncertain
planes → issue → explosion
Such disruptions are likely to become more frequent.
asserted
disruptions → become → ?
SpaceX is seeking to launch Starship up to 76 times a year from Cape Canaveral, Florida.
asserted
SpaceX → seek → Canaveral
The FAA provided ProPublica the reports on Starship flights 7, 8 and 9 — all of which involved mishaps — after we requested them under the Freedom of Information Act.
asserted
we → provide → Act
The FAA redacted the vast majority of all three reports, citing, among other things, exemptions in the law that protect confidential business information from disclosure.
asserted
that → redact → disclosure
The blackouts were, in part, a reflection of SpaceX’s objections; FAA allowed the company to challenge the release of information it deemed proprietary.
asserted
it → allow → information
The FAA refused to release information that would show SpaceX’s estimates of where debris fell during the three rocket failures.
asserted
debris → refuse → failures
It’s unclear what the agency or the company knows about how close any airplanes came to falling debris.
uncertain
airplanes → ’ → debris
“Withholding the underlying debris estimates makes it impossible for anyone outside SpaceX and FAA to check whether that pattern is improving or repeating,” Jah said.
asserted
Jah → withhold → SpaceX
“Given a regulator already revised its own safety margins once, the public has a real interest in seeing the data behind both the old margin and the new one.”
asserted
public → give → margin
The unredacted part of the report did not show whether the debris from the Flight 7 explosion fell where SpaceX and the FAA expected it to.
asserted
it → show → explosion
But the references to Disney and Club Med guests’ video suggest SpaceX did not have a full picture of where the debris landed without them.
asserted
debris → suggest → them
“I would read it as evidence their own tracking did not carry cleanly through the debris cloud phase, so they used the public to fill the gap,” Jah said.
asserted
Jah → read → gap
SpaceX did not respond to requests for comment.
asserted
SpaceX → respond → comment
The company has said that it learns from its mistakes and that each test improves Starship’s reliability.
asserted
test → say → reliability
Last December, it said on X that “SpaceX is committed to responsibly using airspace during launches and reentries, prioritizing public safety to protect people on the ground, at sea, and in the air.”
asserted
SpaceX → say → air
The FAA did not respond to a request for comment, nor did Disney, Royal Caribbean or Club Med.
asserted
Disney → respond → comment
Ron Madler, a professor of aerospace engineering at Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University, said the videos could help SpaceX “either confirm their breakup models or possibly to improve them.”
uncertain
SpaceX → say → them
The mishap report for Flight 8, which rained debris near the Bahamas, said before that flight’s explosive failure, SpaceX did not have the proper “test stand” that was capable of testing the rocket’s engines “for a full Starship mission.”
asserted
that → rain → mission
The remainder of the page was blacked out, so it was unclear from the report whether the company had found another way to fully test the engines before launch.
uncertain
company → black → launch
Flights 7 and 8 both involved the same model.
asserted
Flights → involve → model
Both ended in engine-related failures.
asserted
Both → end → failures
Text in the report around the statement about the test stand was redacted.
asserted
Text → redact → stand
But Jah said it “means some part of the engine’s actual flight behavior was being verified for the first time in flight rather than on the ground.”
asserted
part → say → ground
John Crassidis, an aerospace engineering professor at the University at Buffalo, said launching before having a fully capable test stand was likely “a cost-saving decision.”
asserted
launching → say → stand
In building rockets, he said, SpaceX CEO Elon Musk has used both the old approach of launching and then fixing any issues that arise, and the newer approach of running simulations and ground tests first to head off problems.
asserted
that → build → problems
“Doing too much of the old school can lead to too many mishaps and cost overruns,” he said.
asserted
he → do → mishaps
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
