The fact that remembrance on October 7 is being devoted to the perpetrators of murder and rape, rather than their victims, is a sign of how far universities have allowed a Marxian secular worship of “the oppressed” to justify bullying, intimidation and harassment of Jews in Canada.
asserted
worship → devote → Canada
Recommended Videos
(A vigil at the University of Toronto was cancelled by the administration over “safety and operational concerns,” but as of press time, similar events remain planned at McGill University and the University of British Columbia).
asserted
events → cancel → Columbia
It seems that the universities have belatedly realized that the time for talking about taking action has passed and they had better address the epidemic of antisemitism that has broken out on campuses across the country.
asserted
that → seem → country
A meeting to that end was attended by representatives of 70 institutions on Monday, with the goal of creating a national strategy that might turn the tide.
Gabriel Miller, president of Universities Canada, said universities have done work at ground level to improve policies to protect Jews and fight antisemitism by beefing up campus security, improving training in diversity offices, and so on.
uncertain
universities → attend → offices
“The one thing I’ve heard most consistently from Jewish students is that they want the same protections under the same policies that every student is entitled to on campus and that’s something that universities have taken to heart,” Miller said.
asserted
Miller → hear → heart
But he said the real decision from Monday’s forum was to take stronger action at a national level.
asserted
decision → say → level
The forum agreed on the need to co-ordinate government, law enforcement and the thicket of human rights regulations across the country.
asserted
forum → agree → country
In December 2023, the presidents of Harvard, MIT and the University of Pennsylvania were unable to answer a simple question: Does calling for the genocide of Jews violate your university’s code of conduct, regarding bullying and harassment?
asserted
calling → answer → bullying
Most Canadian university presidents would be able to answer in the affirmative.
asserted
presidents → answer → affirmative
But, as a review of antisemitic incidents at Toronto Metropolitan University last year by Justice Mary Lou Benotto found, the absence of clear enforcement, combined with ambiguity around free expression, has contributed to the perception that disruption and discrimination carry few consequences.
asserted
disruption → find → consequences
It is possible that individual students were sanctioned after the TMU review, which followed on from the violent disruption of two Jewish-linked events.
asserted
which → sanction → events
Pages of the report were redacted on privacy grounds.
asserted
Pages → redact → grounds
But the Benotto review concluded that the deteriorating campus climate was the result of the absence of decisive action by the university.
asserted
climate → conclude → university
It found 84 per cent of the 900 Jewish students interviewed said antisemitism on campus is a serious problem; 95.7 per cent said they had experienced or witnessed it; 70 per cent said their university does not take antisemitism seriously; and 68 per cent said their campus is not a safe or inclusive place.
More than half of those students avoid wearing or displaying Jewish symbols — a damning statistic in a country that trumpets its diversity credentials.
Universities Canada president Miller said that point resonated with him. “Nothing could be more contrary to the spirit of Canada, let alone our universities, than that,” he said.
uncertain
he → find → that
“(But) in addition to continuing to strengthen the response on campus, and giving this a national effort on behalf of universities, it’s going to require a much closer partnership between all the institutional players because antisemitism does not stop or start at the edge of campus.
asserted
antisemitism → continue → campus
Maybe not, but the other players seem to be ahead of our universities in addressing the problem.
In a statement on the third anniversary of October 7, he said every Jewish Canadian has the right to be “visibly, fully, joyfully Jewish in public life, at school, at work, in the street, in synagogue, in every place that is theirs because Canada is theirs.”
New laws strengthen protections against anti-hate and criminalize wilful promotion of hatred by publicly displaying certain symbols.
asserted
laws → seem → symbols
After the attack last month on a synagogue in Belleville, Ont., the government issued a statement recognizing antisemitism as a matter of national security and “a core compound of many violent extremist ideologies.
asserted
government → issue → ideologies
Law enforcement is stepping up, with some setting up hate-crimes units and laying charges related to wilful promotion of antisemitism (the first successful prosecution was made last year, when Kenneth Paulin of North Bay, Ont. was sent to jail for online posts that denied the Holocaust and called Jews cockroaches and demons).
asserted
that → step → Jews
The Ontario government’s Ministry of Training, Colleges and Universities has pledged to reduce the operational funding of universities that fail to comply with its directive to apply their own standards and policies.
asserted
that → pledge → standards
Interestingly, the ministry directive is clear that the institutions retain authority over (and responsibility for) student associations and groups operating on campus, when it comes to anti-hate and discrimination conduct.
asserted
it → retain → conduct
Jewish advocates such as Noah Shack, the CEO of the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs, would like to see Ontario’s harder line adopted across the country.
asserted
line → like → country
“I think it provides some of the clarity for universities that have failed to find clarity.
asserted
that → think → clarity
It requires standardized reporting, resolution timelines for complaints, transparency, anti-hate training and security protocols to deal with intimidation …
asserted
It → require → intimidation
And where a university fails to follow the directive, it gives the minister the ability to withhold operational funding.
asserted
it → fail → funding
Now, the ball is in the court of the universities, which have at best shrugged at and at worst been complicit in the adoption of a cancel culture that rejects nuance, the benefit of the doubt and true diversity, in favour of one, increasingly narrow path of self-defined righteousness.
asserted
that → shrug → righteousness
The idea of national standards is not terrible, as long as they adopt the tougher options.
asserted
they → adopt → options
For example, York University removed an anti-Israel encampment almost immediately, while other campuses, such as McGill, tolerated them.
asserted
campuses → remove → them
They quickly became the focal points for antisemitism.
asserted
They → become → antisemitism
Yet, as Justice Benotto concluded, while universities cannot resolve the conflict in the Middle East, or forge a consensus over competing historical narratives, they can establish clear behavioural recommendations and protect the rights of all members of the student and academic community.
asserted
they → conclude → community
“What the university can do is ensure that it has clear policies that are consistently enforced to ensure that people are behaving towards one another in the university environment in a way that’s conducive to higher education,” agreed Shack.
asserted
Shack → ensure → education
“Ultimately, Jewish people in this country are going to be driven out of public institutions, and out of society, in a very scary way that we’ve seen in other countries throughout history and that no one would ever think possible in Canada.
asserted
one → go → Canada
The right to free speech is always subject to boundaries
The argument against tighter rules against intimidation on campus is that it will stifle free expression.
asserted
it → stifle → expression
Cary Kogan, a professor of psychology at the University of Ottawa who heads the Network of Engaged Canadian Academics, said that there is a sense in some faculties that academic freedom is a kind of “white magic that protects you from anything and everything.”
asserted
that → head → anything
“But the right to experience and participate in an educational setting as a full member of a democratic society has to be balanced with the rights of academic freedom,” he said.
asserted
he → experience → freedom
Expressly prohibit intimidation, harassment, discrimination and conduct that interferes with the rights of others, and impose disciplinary sanctions on those who broach those rules.
asserted
who → prohibit → rules
Criticism of Israel’s government is protected expression.
asserted
Criticism → protect → government
And it is the normalization of anti-Zionism that is driving antisemitism in Canada.
asserted
that → drive → Canada
The Aporia
