Military satellite deal could set stage for new battle over cabinet secrecy
Conservatives flag Carney's ties to Telesat CEO, government says precautions taken
uncertain
precautions → set → CEO
Federal Conservatives have demanded the Carney government open the books on the recent $2.3-billion military satellite deal with Telesat — a call that lays the groundwork for a bruising political battle this fall depending upon how far they want to take it.
asserted
they → demand → it
The Official Opposition wants to see public disclosure of the contract and what sort of safeguards were put in place to prevent a conflict of interest for Prime Minister Mark Carney.
asserted
sort → want → Carney
The plan to deliver state-of-the-art, secure communications for the Canadian military in the Arctic languished for decades before it was formally set in motion last week.
asserted
it → deliver → motion
Carney and the CEO of Telesat, Dan Goldberg, are longtime friends and conservative pundits lit up social media last week with comments and concerns about the program.
James Bezan, the Conservative defence critic, said it's important to get the satellite capability into the hands of the military as quickly as possible, but the public needs an extra level of reassurance, given that the contract award was expedited over a matter of several months.
"This is about a matter of trust and transparency," Bezan said.
asserted
Bezan → light → trust
"We're calling for a release of the contract, the terms of the contract and the decision-making process that was used by the government right up to the prime minister and cabinet.
asserted
that → call → minister
The confidentiality of corporate contracts and cabinet discussions is deeply institutionalized within the federal government and protected by legislation.
asserted
confidentiality → institutionalize → legislation
Specifically, cabinet confidentiality hides why a project was selected, and commercial exemptions keep the exact terms of the deal under wraps.
asserted
exemptions → hide → wraps
The public and opposition MPs often rely on independent watchdogs, such as the auditor general or parliamentary budget officer (PBO), to retroactively investigate whether Canadians received good value for taxpayer money.
asserted
Canadians → rely → money
Ottawa to expand defence buying powers when national, economic security at stake
- Analysis
Rearming the military: Should Canada buy it or build it?
asserted
Canada → expand → it
The last major battle over cabinet confidentiality and document access in Parliament took place two years ago in a historic fight over Sustainable Development Technology Canada — or the "green slush fund" as the opposition referred to it.
asserted
opposition → take → it
The Conservative-led opposition passed a binding House of Commons order demanding the Liberal government turn over all internal files regarding that foundation to Parliament's law clerk.
asserted
government → lead → clerk
The fight ended when House Speaker Greg Fergus delivered a landmark ruling that sided with the opposition, stating that the House's constitutional power to order documents is absolute and supersedes cabinet confidentiality and privacy laws.
asserted
power → end → confidentiality
Bezan said the Telesat deal needs to be closely examined because of the prime minister's friendship with Goldberg:
asserted
deal → say → Goldberg
"Was the ethics screens used?
asserted
screens → use → ?
Was Prime Minister Carney involved in the decision-making process?
asserted
Carney → involve → process
Did he recuse himself when these discussions were taking place at the cabinet table?"
asserted
discussions → recuse → table
In a written statement, the Privy Council Office (PCO) said the awarding of the contract by the Defence Investment Agency followed the proper process.
asserted
awarding → write → process
Carney, upon assuming office, agreed to a conflict-of-interest screen that applies to any decision that could improperly benefit a private interest.
uncertain
that → assume → interest
"This screen is respected at all times," said Pierre Cuguen, a spokesperson for PCO.
asserted
Cuguen → respect → PCO
"This conflict-of-interest screen is administered by the prime minister's chief of staff and the clerk of the Privy Council to ensure that the prime minister is neither informed of official matters or decision-making processes involving the interests of the companies concerned, nor called upon to participate in them."
asserted
minister → administer → them
Goldberg said Carney had nothing to do with the contract award and he expressed frustration with the Opposition's claims.
uncertain
he → say → claims
He pointed to a Conservative government first proposing the Arctic satellite network in 2008.
asserted
government → point → 2008
"This was a Harper government initiative," Goldberg said.
asserted
Goldberg → say → ?
"We went through an absolutely rigorous process, identifying, I think it was at one point, something like 20 to 24 different kinds of alternative, kind of network configurations that could meet the [military] requirements."
Feds to spend almost $700M on new RADARSAT Constellation Mission satellite
Ottawa puts $200M into space launch pad in Nova Scotia
French-U.K. Starlink rival pitches Canada on 'sovereign' satellite service for Arctic military operations
uncertain
rival → go → operations
Conservatives also expressed concern about the $600-million contract that Telesat was given to bring broadband connectivity to the Far North under the federal Universal Broadband Fund.
asserted
Telesat → express → Fund
The program was hit with a series of delays, including supply chain issues related to the COVID-19 pandemic.
asserted
program → hit → pandemic
Originally, Telesat had contracted with France's Thales Alenia Space to build the satellite fleet.
asserted
Telesat → contract → fleet
But supply bottlenecks and severe post-pandemic inflation forced Thales to raise prices beyond the scope of the project's budget.
asserted
bottlenecks → force → budget
Telesat restructured the entire program and pivoted to Canada's MDA Space as the new prime contractor.
asserted
Telesat → restructure → contractor
In 2024, the company renegotiated federal and provincial loan guarantees to ensure delivery of the satellite system by 2028.
asserted
company → renegotiate → 2028
Goldberg said they're on track to meet that target.
asserted
they → say → target
"My colleagues and I at Telesat are overwhelmingly proud to be a part of delivering this much-needed capability, delivering it early, delivering at a phenomenal value proposition to the Canadian taxpayer," said Goldberg.
asserted
Goldberg → deliver → taxpayer
"It was procured in an absolutely rigorous arm's-length manner."
asserted
It → procure → manner
The Aporia
