Roger Cook, the premier of Western Australia, has defended the move by former defense industries minister Paul Papalia to take up a strategic advisory role at Duratec, an engineering and construction firm. Papalia had been involved with Duratec while in office but left politics in July to care for an ill relative. The appointment has drawn criticism from Sophie McNeill of the WA Greens, who called it corrupt and demanded an investigation into Papalia’s move and mandatory exclusion periods for ministers transitioning to private roles after leaving government. Premier Cook dismissed these concerns, stating that Papalia is now a private citizen with the right to seek employment opportunities as he chooses.
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-10-07,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Why this leaning score
The model judged this article politically coded and scored it +0.35, but 1 quote(s) could not be found in the article and the other 1 are attributed speech rather than the article's own narration, so the score is not published.
Written under an earlier scoring contract, which gave a paragraph
rather than checkable quotes. Re-analysing this article replaces it.
Leaning score withheld for article 62206: no verified evidence · logged 2026-10-07
West Australian Premier Roger Cook has rejected calls to investigate former defence industries minister Paul Papalia’s jump from government to a role at engineering and construction firm Duratec, saying Papalia was a private citizen with the right to seek employment after leaving office.
asserted
Papalia → reject → office
Papalia, a former navy clearance diver, retired from politics in July to help care for an ill relative.
asserted
Papalia → retire → relative
On Tuesday, it was revealed had joined Duratec as a strategic adviser.
asserted
it → reveal → adviser
Papalia dealt with Duratec while holding the defence industries portfolio before his retirement, which included leading a trade mission to the UK in September with Duratec as one of the accompanying companies.
asserted
which → deal → companies
In April, a Duratec and Ertech joint venture won a $281 million Commonwealth government contract for infrastructure upgrades at HMAS Stirling as part of the AUKUS program.
asserted
venture → win → program
Duratec also received a $97,000 grant from the state government in 2021.
asserted
Duratec → receive → 2021
There is nothing in the ministerial code of conduct nor any other law in WA that prevents or delays ministers from entering the private sector once they leave cabinet.
asserted
they → be → cabinet
However, Papalia’s appointment incensed WA Greens peace and nonviolence spokeswoman Sophie McNeill, who said it was yet another example of the revolving door of WA Labor MPs into the private sector.
asserted
it → incense → sector
“It’s a disgrace and as I said, if this happened in another country, and when I used to be a journalist and cover these stories in other countries, we called it corruption.
asserted
we → ’ → it
That’s how we described it ... but here in Western Australia because it’s technically legal, it’s meant to be above board,” she said.
asserted
she → ’ → board
“I don’t think the community will think this is above board, and I think Labor should be embarrassed to their core about this position that he’s taken up.”
asserted
he → think → that
McNeill called for an investigation into Papalia’s appointment, and for mandatory exclusion periods to be introduced to prevent ministers from entering private roles.
asserted
periods → call → roles
Several members of the WA Labor government that came to power in 2017 have leapt from cabinet into high-profile roles.
Former McGowan government treasurer Ben Wyatt remains on the Rio Tinto and Woodside boards while ex-premier Mark McGowan himself has taken up several advisory roles in the private sector, including with miners Mineral Resources and BHP, and is on the board of Southern Cross Media, which owns Seven and The West Australian.
asserted
which → come → Seven
On Tuesday, it was announced McGowan had joined the board of construction company Built.
asserted
McGowan → announce → Built
However, Cook rubbished the criticism over Papalia’s appointment.
asserted
Cook → rubbish → appointment
He’s no longer a member of the parliament.
asserted
He → ’ → parliament
He’s no longer a member of the government, and so he can pursue whatever career opportunities he can,” he said on Wednesday.
asserted
he → ’ → Wednesday
“The fact of the matter is that minister Papalia was never responsible for a decision or a contract in relation to the company he’s now working with.
asserted
he → work → company
“It’s a company that obviously wants to benefit from his insights in relation to the defence industries, and minister Papalia has a right to access those sorts of career opportunities while observing the guidelines in relation to ministers who are exiting their duties.
asserted
who → ’ → duties
Cook said he was certain Papalia would have undertaken his ministerial duties with integrity while dealing with Duratec.
asserted
Papalia → say → Duratec
The premier noted it wasn’t long ago that people were complaining about ministers receiving a pension when retiring from government.
asserted
ministers → note → government
Papalia attended a defence industry event on Wednesday morning but declined to speak to media as he was leaving the venue.
asserted
he → attend → venue
When 9News Perth asked about his new job he said it was “part-time” but declined to speak further.
asserted
it → ask → job
He did not respond to further requests for comment.
asserted
He → respond → comment
Duratec chief executive Chris Oates talked up Papalia’s defence credentials.
asserted
Oates → talk → credentials
“As major defence investments continue to develop, Paul’s expertise, leadership and industry knowledge will help us build on this foundation and identify new opportunities for growth,” he said.
asserted
he → continue → growth
The Aporia
