Chris Philp, the Conservative Shadow Home Secretary, pledged during his party's conference in Birmingham to scrap Labour’s new asylum routes for Afghans and Palestinians immediately if Conservatives win the next election. He criticized Shabana Mahmood, the current Home Secretary, for proposing these "safe routes" amid high illegal immigration rates. Additionally, Philp announced plans to deport 150,000 individuals annually who are failed asylum seekers, foreign criminals, or visa overstayers over the course of a Parliament.
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-10-06,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Story summary
The Labour government recently introduced new asylum routes for Afghans and Palestinians, focusing particularly on Afghan women and girls. Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp of the Conservative Party pledged to scrap these routes immediately if his party wins the next General Election, citing concerns over illegal immigration. Meanwhile, Shabana Mahmood, Labour's Home Secretary, defended the scheme as a way to unlock Britain’s inherent generosity towards refugees. In contrast, Philp also proposed forming a removals force to deport 150,000 failed asylum seekers, foreign criminals, and visa overstayers annually, aiming to remove three-quarters of a million foreign nationals without right to be in the UK over the next Parliament.
Written for “UK Asylum Policy Debate” on 2026-10-06,
grounded in this article and the 0 other(s) covering the same event.
Why this leaning score
The model judged this article politically coded and scored it +0.65, but 2 quote(s) could not be found in the article and the other 1 are attributed speech rather than the article's own narration, so the score is not published.
Written under an earlier scoring contract, which gave a paragraph
rather than checkable quotes. Re-analysing this article replaces it.
Leaning score withheld for article 61186: no verified evidence · logged 2026-10-06
New asylum routes being set up by Labour for Afghans and Palestinians will be ‘immediately’ shut down if the Conservatives win the next General Election.
asserted
Conservatives → set → Election
Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp said the scheme should not be contemplated amid ‘rife’ illegal immigration.
asserted
scheme → say → immigration
Shabana Mahmood, the Home Secretary, announced the plan last week, saying the ‘safe routes’ would be largely focussed on Palestinians and Afghan women and girls.
asserted
routes → announce → Palestinians
She insisted the scheme would help ‘unlock the inherent generosity of this country’.
asserted
scheme → insist → country
But Mr Philp will say in his speech to Conservative Party conference on Wednesday: ‘While illegal migration is rife, the government should not be opening our borders even more – and we would close this scheme down immediately.’
asserted
we → say → scheme
He has also announced plans for a removals force to deport 150,000 failed asylum seekers, foreign criminals and visa overstayers a year.
asserted
He → announce → seekers
Mr Philp said that over the course of the next Parliament a new Home Office unit would use broader removal powers to kick out three-quarters of a million foreign nationals with no right to be in the UK.
asserted
unit → say → UK
‘We would aim to have 150,000 people a year removed by a removals force,’ said Mr Philp.
asserted
Philp → aim → force
Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp will address Conservative delegates at the party's annual conference in Birmingham
‘
asserted
Philp → address → Birmingham
‘So the priority would be those people arriving illegally by small boat.
asserted
priority → arrive → boat
‘They would have to go straight away and that would have a deterrent effect.’
asserted
that → have → effect
In his speech, the Shadow Home Secretary will warn that Labour’s plan to make migrants wait longer before winning permanent status in the UK is set to be ‘emasculated’ as the Government panders to its ‘open borders MPs’.
asserted
Government → warn → MPs
Ms Mahmood published proposals last November to double foreign nationals’ waiting period for ‘indefinite leave to remain’ (ILR).
asserted
Mahmood → publish → leave
Mr Philp will say: ‘As Home Secretary I would put the rights of our citizens first.
asserted
I → say → citizens
‘Shabana Mahmood won’t do that.
asserted
Mahmood → do → that
‘She spent the last year claiming to be tough.
asserted
She → spend → year
But under pressure from Angela Rayner and open borders Labour MPs she now plans to emasculate her own ILR reforms.
asserted
she → plan → reforms
‘This will mean hundreds of thousands of low-wage or no wage migrants will stay forever – costing taxpayers billions.
asserted
thousands → mean → billions
‘Shabana has surrendered.’
asserted
Shabana → surrender → ?
Ms Mahmood insisted last year that the measures were essential to head off the immense cost to the Treasury when migrants who arrived in the post-Covid immigration surge become eligible for ILR.
asserted
who → insist → ILR
From next year two million migrants will be able to claim a wider range of benefits hand-outs if they successfully apply for ILR.
uncertain
they → claim → ILR
But MPs from the Labour Left complained it was unfair to change the rules for migrants already in the UK, with dozens signing an open letter in February opposing the proposals.
asserted
dozens → complain → proposals
And in June PM Andy Burnham’s housing and communities secretary Angela Rayner, who was then a backbencher, described Ms Mahmood’s scheme as ‘un-British’ and ‘wrong’.
asserted
who → describe → scheme
On law and order, Mr Philp’s speech will condemn a police ‘anti-racism commitment’ that says people should be treated differently according to the colour of their skin.
uncertain
people → condemn → skin
A document published last year by the National Police Chiefs’ Council (NPCC) said 'racial equity' should not mean 'treating everyone the same or being colour blind'.
asserted
equity → publish → everyone
Mr Philp will say the NPCC policy ‘expressly says police should treat different ethnic groups differently to artificially engineer the same arrest rates’.
asserted
police → say → rates
‘That is literally racist,’ he will tell delegates, pledging to have the document scrapped under a Tory government.
asserted
document → tell → government
The Shadow Home Secretary is also expected to mock Reform UK.
asserted
Secretary → expect → UK
‘They offer the financial probity of Nigel Farage, the calm geniality of Zia Yusuf and the selfless loyalty of Robert Jenrick,’ he will tell delegates.
asserted
he → offer → delegates
The Aporia
