Manjur A. Chowdhury, former Chairman of Bangladesh’s National River Conservation Commission, criticizes the 1996 India-Bangladesh Ganga Water Treaty as flawed due to its lack of a guarantee clause and failure to address climate change impacts. Speaking on October 6, 2026, Chowdhury suggests replacing the expiring treaty with a short-term three-year agreement while initiating negotiations for a more comprehensive trilateral treaty involving Nepal. He argues that future treaties must consider environmental factors and river health beyond mere water division.
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-10-06,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Story summary
Manjur A. Chowdhury, former Chairman of the National River Conservation Commission (NRCC) of Bangladesh, has expressed concerns about the 1996 India-Bangladesh Ganga Water Treaty. Speaking to The Hindu on October 6, 2026, he stated that the treaty is "flawed" due to its lack of a guarantee clause and failure to account for factors like climate change impacts. He noted that the current treaty expires in December 2026 and should be replaced by a short-term agreement lasting three years. This interim period would allow time for further research and negotiations to draft a new, more comprehensive trilateral treaty involving Nepal, as its rivers contribute significant amounts of water from Himalayan snowmelt to the Ganga system. Chowdhury emphasized that a good treaty must consider the "health of the river" to prevent overexploitation and ensure ecological sustainability.
Written for “Ganga Water Treaty” on 2026-10-06,
grounded in this article and the 0 other(s) covering the same event.
Why this leaning score
The model judged this article politically coded and scored it -0.45, but all 3 of its quote(s) are attributed speech - words the article quotes from someone, not the article's own narration, so the score is not published.
Written under an earlier scoring contract, which gave a paragraph
rather than checkable quotes. Re-analysing this article replaces it.
Leaning score withheld for article 60668: attributed speech only · logged 2026-10-06
The 1996 India-Bangladesh Ganga Water Treaty is “flawed” as it lacks a guarantee clause and does not account for factors like climate change impact, a leading Bangladesh river water expert has said.
asserted
expert → lack → impact
Speaking to The Hindu on Tuesday (October 6, 2026), Manjur A. Chowdhury, former Chairman of the National River Conservation Commission (NRCC) of Bangladesh said the Treaty will expire in December and should be replaced by a short-term treaty of three years.
asserted
Treaty → speak → years
This should be followed by a better researched trilateral treaty that also brings in Nepal since that nation’s rivers carry Himalayan snowmelt to the Ganga.
asserted
rivers → follow → Ganga
“The Ganga Water Treaty is three decades old and flawed as it does not include a guarantee clause.
asserted
it → include → clause
It also does not have ecological flow and environmental flow considerations.
asserted
It → have → considerations
In addition, the treaty does not include factors that are related to climate change.
asserted
that → include → change
It simply divides the water of the river.
asserted
It → divide → river
That is not a right approach,” said Mr. Chowdhury who believes that the Ganga Water Treaty should include Nepal.
asserted
Treaty → say → Nepal
A good treaty, he added, should take into account the “health of the river” so that the Ganga is not overexploited.
asserted
Ganga → add → river
“Before the treaty’s expiry in December this year, ideally, we should opt for a short-term treaty of three years during which time we will conduct further research and negotiations to draft a new and lasting Ganga Water Treaty that will incorporate technological and environmental developments,” said Mr. Chowdhury, speaking exclusively to The Hindu.
asserted
Chowdhury → opt → Hindu
Treaty expires in December
“India always looks at the Ganga treaty as a bilateral treaty but in the lean months it receives a lot of snowmelt from Nepal’s Ghaghara, Gandaki, and Koshi rivers; they also need to be monitored if we have to care for the Ganga,” Mr. Chowdhury said.
asserted
Chowdhury → expire → Ganga
He argued that the Ganga water treaty requires a fresh approach as environmental factors of the twenty-first century will have to be considered while drafting the text of the treaty.
asserted
factors → argue → treaty
His comments came a day after he made similar remarks at a conclave in Dhaka calling for a fresh treaty.
asserted
he → come → treaty
The Ganga Water Treaty will expire in December this year unless the two sides agree to renew the treaty for another three decades.
asserted
sides → expire → decades
Earlier, former Foreign Secretary Farooq Sobhan, who had negotiated the treaty during the first prime ministerial tenure of Sheikh Hasina in 1996 said that the absence of an arbitration clause is a problem for the treaty.
asserted
absence → negotiate → treaty
Speaking with The Hindu, Mr. Sobhan further said that there are unfulfilled Indian promises related to the Ganga Water Treaty that will have to be revisited.
asserted
that → speak → Treaty
“India had promised to build a barrage for Padma (Ganga) in Bangladeshi territory at that time, but it was not followed up.
asserted
it → promise → time
That was the quid pro quo for not including the arbitration clause.
asserted
That → include → clause
But that barrage was not built,” said Mr. Sobhan.
asserted
Sobhan → build → ?
He added that Bangladesh carried out surveys in the 1990s regarding the building of a barrage but did not receive the help it needed.
asserted
it → add → help
Discussions on the renewal of the Ganga Water Treaty have been ongoing in both India and Bangladesh though important technical consultations are yet to be held ahead of the expiry in December this year.
asserted
consultations → hold → December
Earlier JD(U) MP Sanjay Jha had called on the Government of India not to renew the Ganga Water Treaty saying that the treaty with Bangladesh had “negatively impacted” Bihar.
asserted
treaty → call → Bihar
Subsequently, External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar had written to Mr. Jha on August 28, “We fully understand your concerns regarding the Ganga Water Treaty.
asserted
We → write → Treaty
I would like to bring to your attention that under the leadership of the Jal Shakti Ministry, inter-ministerial consultation involving relevant stakeholders have taken place to ensure broad-based consultation on the future of the treaty.”
asserted
consultation → like → treaty
(The Correspondent was in Dhaka as the guest of Centre for Governance Studies (CGS) to participate in the Bay of Bengal Conversation.)
Published - October 06, 2026 10:49 pm IST
asserted
Correspondent → participate → Conversation
The Aporia
