Retired Army Gen. Jack Keane questioned whether Pakistan, Qatar and Saudi Arabia can be trusted to help shape negotiations with Iran, accusing the regional partners of steering President Donald Trump away from military pressure while leaving the United States and Israel to bear the risks of confronting Tehran.
asserted
Pakistan → question → Tehran
Keane, a Fox News senior strategic analyst and former Army vice chief of staff, said during a Monday appearance on Fox News’ "America’s Newsroom" that Pakistan and Qatar were "compromised" as mediators because, in his view, they favor Iran over the United States.
asserted
they → say → States
"It is well known in the Middle East region, by our intelligence services, by all the players, that the Pakistanis and the Qataris are compromised because they favor Iran at the expense of the United States," Keane said.
asserted
Keane → know → States
Keane’s criticism contrasts with Trump’s public praise for Islamabad.
asserted
criticism → contrast → Islamabad
Trump said April 26 during a phone interview with Fox News that he had "great respect for Pakistan" because its officials had "been terrific" and "really tried" to advance negotiations with Iran.
asserted
officials → say → Iran
He added that Pakistan would remain involved in the process.
asserted
Pakistan → add → process
While speaking to reporters after the G7 summit in France June 18, Trump also credited Pakistan and Qatar with helping advance the negotiations that produced the U.S.–Iran memorandum of understanding.
asserted
that → speak → understanding
White House spokesperson Anna Kelly also defended the administration’s regional partners, telling Fox News Digital that, "President Trump has great relationships with leaders from Pakistan, Qatar and Saudi Arabia, and he appreciates the involvement of all of our regional partners who are assisting with negotiations.
asserted
who → defend → negotiations
"
"If Iran cannot agree to a good deal with the United States, the fault will lie squarely with the regime, who will suffer the consequences," Kelly added.
asserted
Kelly → agree → consequences
Mediators were preparing a second memorandum focused exclusively on the Strait of Hormuz, Wednesday reports indicated, potentially separating the immediate maritime crisis from the broader dispute over Iran’s nuclear activities.
asserted
reports → prepare → activities
Keane, a former four-star general, argued that their involvement may have contributed to Washington misunderstanding Iran’s intentions.
uncertain
Washington → argue → intentions
"And yet they’re mediators," Keane said.
asserted
Keane → ’re → ?
"So their influence here, I think, had played a part in misleading the United States in terms of Iran’s real intentions."
asserted
I → think → intentions
Pakistan and Qatar have played formal roles in the diplomatic process.
asserted
Pakistan → play → process
A June 22 joint statement from the two countries said they were mediating talks between the United States and Iran under the Islamabad Memorandum of Understanding.
asserted
they → say → Understanding
The framework established working groups on nuclear issues, sanctions, monitoring and dispute resolution, as well as a mechanism intended to prevent incidents involving commercial vessels in the Strait of Hormuz.
asserted
framework → establish → Hormuz
Pakistan declined to comment on Keane’s criticism.
asserted
Pakistan → decline → criticism
The Saudi and Qatari embassies in Washington did not respond by the time of publication.
asserted
embassies → respond → publication
Raza Rumi, editor-at-large of Pakistan’s The Friday Times, disputed Keane’s characterization, arguing that Islamabad’s working relationship with Tehran does not make it a compromised mediator.
asserted
it → dispute → Tehran
"Successful mediators are often those that enjoy channels of communication with all sides," Rumi told Fox News Digital, saying Pakistan’s approach is shaped more by geography, security and economic concerns than ideological alignment with Iran.
asserted
approach → enjoy → Iran
He noted that Pakistan shares a long border with Iran and wants to prevent further instability, while also maintaining longstanding ties with the United States and close partnerships with Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates.
asserted
Pakistan → note → Arabia
Rumi also pointed to the exchange of strikes between Pakistan and Iran in January 2024 as evidence that relations between the neighbors are not uniformly close.
asserted
relations → point → neighbors
"The suggestion that Pakistan somehow caused Washington to misunderstand Tehran’s intentions is difficult to substantiate," Rumi said.
asserted
Rumi → cause → intentions
"It would be a considerable stretch to attribute any American misreading of Iran’s intentions to Pakistani mediation."
asserted
It → attribute → mediation
Keane directed even sharper criticism at Saudi Arabia, saying that Riyadh denied the United States access to Saudi airspace and a U.S. air base during preparations for a possible operation to forcibly reopen the Strait of Hormuz.
asserted
Riyadh → direct → Hormuz
He also claimed Saudi officials had repeatedly persuaded Trump not to resume major military operations against Iran.
asserted
officials → claim → Iran
"The fact of the matter is, the Saudis are not willing to sacrifice to rid the Middle East region of Iran’s aggression," Keane said, describing the potential costs as casualties and damage to Saudi oil infrastructure.
asserted
Keane → sacrifice → infrastructure
"They’re willing for us to make that sacrifice, for sure," he added.
asserted
he → ’re → sacrifice
"They’re willing for Israel to make that sacrifice, for sure."
asserted
Israel → ’re → sacrifice
His remarks highlighted a broader debate over whether Saudi caution represents an unwillingness to confront Tehran or a strategic effort to prevent an open-ended regional war.
asserted
caution → highlight → war
Salman Al-Ansari, a Saudi geopolitical analyst, rejected the suggestion that Riyadh is unwilling to confront Iran, saying the Kingdom distinguishes between credible deterrence and military action without clear objectives.
asserted
Kingdom → reject → objectives
"Saudi Arabia supports confronting Iranian aggression, but not an open-ended regional war without clear objectives or an endgame," Al-Ansari told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Ansari → support → Digital
"Riyadh favors diplomacy backed by credible deterrence, but any agreement must be enforceable and verifiable, addressing Iran’s nuclear program, its proxies, and freedom of navigation in the Strait of Hormuz," he added.
asserted
he → favor → Hormuz
A Gulf affairs analyst who requested anonymity because of the sensitivity of the issue offered a different assessment, saying Saudi leaders fear that a wider confrontation would expose the Kingdom’s critical infrastructure to Iranian retaliation.
asserted
confrontation → request → retaliation
"Saudi Arabia believes it should appease Iran because it is deeply concerned about the consequences of a broader confrontation," the analyst said.
asserted
analyst → believe → confrontation
"Riyadh fears the damage Iran could inflict on the Kingdom’s infrastructure and has therefore favored restraint and negotiations over a decisive military campaign."
uncertain
Iran → fear → campaign
The analyst described a widening divide among Gulf states, arguing that Saudi Arabia and Qatar favor accommodation while the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain and Kuwait support stronger pressure on Iran.
asserted
Emirates → describe → Iran
Richard Goldberg, a senior adviser at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies think tank and former National Security Council official, said during a separate Fox News appearance Wednesday, that Washington continues to depend on Saudi infrastructure even as disagreements persist over military strategy.
"When we talk about the Gulf states, we talk about Saudi Arabia and General Keane’s comments, remember, we also are relying on Saudi Arabia with their overland pipelines to keep us in the game here," Goldberg said.
asserted
Goldberg → say → game
"The fact that they’re at maximum capacity moving through the Red Sea also allows us to continue the strangulation strategy."
asserted
us → ’re → strategy
The debate comes as the United States and Iran continue negotiations over the Strait of Hormuz.
asserted
States → come → Hormuz
…and 8 more, not listed.
The Aporia
