In a Friday interview with CBS News, former ICE official Tom Homan clashed with correspondent Camilo Montoya-Galvez over migrant deaths in ICE custody. When asked about deaths under the Biden administration, Homan repeatedly pressed for data on those incidents while highlighting higher detention standards and medical care quality at ICE facilities compared to state or federal prisons. He emphasized that despite an increase in detainee numbers, ICE maintains some of the lowest death rates among custodial institutions.
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-10-06,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Why this leaning score
The model judged this article politically coded and scored it +0.35, but none of the 3 quote(s) it offered could be found in the article text, so the score is not published.
Written under an earlier scoring contract, which gave a paragraph
rather than checkable quotes. Re-analysing this article replaces it.
Leaning score withheld for article 58801: no verified evidence · logged 2026-10-06
Border czar Tom Homan accused a CBS journalist of asking a "loaded question" in a Friday interview about how ICE treats detained illegal migrants, asking him whether he gathered statistics about migrant deaths under the Biden administration.
asserted
he → accuse → administration
CBS News' immigration correspondent Camilo Montoya-Galvez asked Homan about deaths in ICE custody under the Trump administration, noting that this year could set a "new record high."
"We looked at official ICE data, sir, and found that 57 people have died in the agency's custody so far under this administration," Montoya-Galvez said.
uncertain
Galvez → ask → administration
"In fact, somebody was just reported to have died in ICE custody today by the agency.
asserted
somebody → report → agency
2026 could set a new record high in the number of detainees dying.
uncertain
2026 → set → detainees
What is being done to prevent that?
asserted
What → do → that
And I know one partial explanation is that more people are being detained and, so tragically, more people are dying.
asserted
people → know → ?
"
"How many people died during the Biden administration?" Homan immediately replied, followed by a long pause.
asserted
Homan → die → pause
"How many people died in custody during the Biden administration?
asserted
people → die → administration
Do you know?
asserted
you → know → ?
"A significant number," Montoya-Galvez replied.
asserted
Galvez → reply → ?
"Do you know?" Homan pressed further.
asserted
Homan → know → ?
"But this is going to be the highest year in 2026," Montoya-Galvez continued.
asserted
Galvez → go → 2026
"I'm just asking if the pace continues —"
"Do you know how many died during the Biden administration?" Homan pressed again.
asserted
Homan → ask → administration
"I don't have the data here," the CBS interviewer admitted.
asserted
interviewer → have → data
"Of course you don't," Homan said.
asserted
Homan → do → ?
Homan said that ICE maintains the highest standards for detention centers.
asserted
ICE → say → centers
"We have the highest detention standards in industry, higher than any state or federal institution.
asserted
We → have → institution
Numbers are up because our population has doubled in custody.
asserted
population → double → custody
We got over 70 — I think the other day we had like 74,000 in custody," he said.
asserted
he → get → custody
Homan went on to argue that the quality of ICE medical care is so high to the point detainees are helped with medical issues they didn’t even know they had.
asserted
they → go → issues
"So we have more people in custody, and we're dealing with people from third-world nations," he said.
asserted
he → have → nations
"Some of the first doctors they see are our doctors.
asserted
they → see → doctors
And matter of fact, no one ever talks about how many lives that ICE saves in detention when they found a serious medical issue that the alien didn't even know about and we treat.
asserted
we → talk → that
When I was ICE director, I think we spent almost a billion dollars on medical care."
asserted
we → think → care
He compared ICE detention to federal or state prisons.
asserted
He → compare → prisons
"Again, it's unfortunate, and it's sad when anybody dies.
asserted
anybody → die → ?
I don't want to see anybody die, but we do everything we can to give them the best medical care that we can provide.
asserted
we → want → that
And again, highest detention standards," Homan said.
asserted
Homan → say → ?
"I think if you look at deaths in custody compared to state prisons or federal penitentiaries, I think we're one of the lowest.
asserted
we → think → lowest
At least the last time I looked at the data — it was probably a couple years ago — we're the lowest."
asserted
we → look → data
Theo Wold, a former acting assistant attorney general and deputy assistant to the president for domestic policy during President Donald Trump's first administration, criticized Montoya-Galvez's questions in comments to Fox News Digital.
asserted
Wold → act → Digital
"This is what passes for journalism in modern America — a reporter comes prepared with gotcha questions but no backup data," he said.
asserted
he → pass → questions
"The purpose isn’t to inform the public (which ought to be the goal of journalism), it’s to manufacture ideological sound bites for the nightly news."
asserted
it → inform → news
"No one wants in-custody deaths, but no administration can avoid them," Wold added.
asserted
Wold → want → them
"The Trump Administration has more than doubled Biden-era enforcement, which means more individuals detained and more in-custody deaths, most often through no fault of ICE or its enforcement officers."
asserted
which → double → ICE
The Aporia
