Amy Fischer writes that Amnesty International has concluded ICE must be abolished due to documented human rights violations over two decades, with abuses intensifying under the Trump administration. The article details instances of racial profiling, arbitrary detentions, use of excessive force, and unlawful surveillance tactics against Black and brown communities during enforcement operations in multiple cities. Fischer also describes harsh conditions within detention centers, including unsanitary environments, lack of food and medical care, and restricted access to legal counsel, which she argues amount to cruel treatment and possibly torture.
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-10-05,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
ICE must be abolished.
asserted
ICE → abolish → ?
That’s the conclusion we at Amnesty International have reached after documenting the chilling pattern of human rights violations across the US during immigration enforcement operations.
asserted
we → ’ → operations
ICE’s record of violating human rights has been documented for more than two decades, but our latest findings show that the abuses go well beyond a series of incidents.
asserted
abuses → violate → incidents
Instead, under the Trump administration, there is a clear pattern that has reached a new and dangerous scale.
asserted
that → be → scale
In large-scale immigration enforcement operations in Chicago, Minneapolis-St Paul, New Orleans and Washington DC, we documented federal agents repeatedly racially profiling and arbitrarily detaining people based on their perceived race.
asserted
agents → document → race
Agents also targeted workplaces and neighborhoods that they associated with Black and brown immigrant communities.
asserted
they → target → communities
I spoke with dozens of people – including Indigenous people, Black and brown US citizens, and people with legal immigration status who were also racially profiled, stopped and arbitrarily detained.
asserted
who → speak → status
In all of the cities, people told me about federal officers using intimidation and unlawful force, including lethal force, against people they were attempting to detain, as well as community members observing or defending their neighbors.
asserted
they → tell → neighbors
Agents broke down doors with guns drawn, smashed vehicle windows without justification and threw people to the ground.
asserted
guns → break → ground
They used teargas and pepper spray against protesters and observers in public places, often impacting children and the surrounding neighborhoods.
asserted
They → use → children
They also used facial recognition technology, drones and helicopters to unlawfully surveil people and intimidate them at the same time.
asserted
They → use → time
As a Washington DC resident, I remember the helicopters shaking the windows of my home.
asserted
helicopters → remember → home
We documented abuses inside detention facilities as well.
asserted
We → document → facilities
I heard harrowing stories from people who were held for prolonged periods in overcrowded and unsanitary facilities not designed for long-term detention, with minimal food, no access to healthcare, and severely restricted access to lawyers.
asserted
who → hear → lawyers
We have concluded that these conditions constitute cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment and, in some circumstances, may amount to torture.
uncertain
conditions → conclude → torture
We also documented unlawful incommunicado detention and possible acts of enforced disappearance, including cases in which families and lawyers could not locate people in ICE custody.
uncertain
families → document → custody
I listened to panicked family members desperately seeking their loved ones who had been snatched by masked men in their communities, without a trace and no way to locate them.
asserted
who → listen → them
These violations were committed across four cities, involving different communities, operations and agents, yet they were strikingly similar.
asserted
they → commit → communities
They are characteristic of the Trump administration’s cruel mass detention and deportation machine, including an immigration enforcement system in which safeguards have been weakened, oversight dismantled and accountability having become nothing more than a buzzword.
asserted
accountability → include → buzzword
When a pattern of human rights violations is so undeniably occurring and completely embedded within an institution, for decades, and with pervasive impunity, the only solution is to start over.
asserted
solution → occur → impunity
That’s why we are calling for ICE to be abolished.
asserted
ICE → ’ → ?
The Trump administration’s deliberately cruel and racist practices have left entire communities across the US living in fear.
asserted
practices → leave → fear
Families are being torn apart.
asserted
Families → tear → ?
My friends are being deported.
asserted
friends → deport → ?
People are afraid to leave home to go to work, take their children to school or seek medical care.
asserted
People → leave → care
The United States has an obligation to respect and protect the human rights of all of us.
asserted
States → have → us
Immigration enforcement does not exempt any government from that responsibility.
asserted
enforcement → exempt → responsibility
Yet the Trump administration has turned the country’s immigration enforcement system into a monster which repeatedly violates people’s rights.
asserted
which → turn → rights
It was created in the aftermath of 9/11 to turn immigration into a national security issue, and has been problematic since.
asserted
It → create → issue
However, the scale and horror that we have witnessed since January 2025, fueled by billions of new dollars and persistent impunity, has reached new levels.
asserted
that → witness → levels
It has become clear that no amount of defunding, training or disciplinary measures will be enough.
asserted
amount → become → defunding
The extent and scale of the abuses and failures we documented lead to only one possible road to justice: ICE must be abolished.
asserted
ICE → document → justice
But we can’t stop there.
asserted
we → stop → ?
It’s a threshold step toward building an immigration system that complies with international human rights law and standards, centers family unity and compassion, and does not rely on cruelty and fear.
asserted
that → ’ → cruelty
In fact, across the four cities we investigated, communities have refused to accept cruelty and fear as inevitable.
asserted
communities → investigate → cruelty
People have built rapid-response networks and hotlines.
asserted
People → build → networks
They walk neighbors to school and work.
asserted
They → walk → school
They provide food, financial assistance, legal support and medical care.
asserted
They → provide → food
They document abuses.
asserted
They → document → abuses
They support families who have been torn apart.
asserted
who → support → families
…and 5 more, not listed.
The Aporia
