In short:
The Coalition has argued its proposal to slash the tax on tobacco by 80 per cent will not create more smokers.
asserted
proposal → argue → smokers
Opposition Leader Angus Taylor says cheap cigarettes are already available on the black market, and reducing legal cigarette prices will stamp out the illicit trade.
asserted
reducing → say → trade
Mr Taylor has warned the federal government that he will hold it accountable for tobacco-related crime, saying it could be fixed by cutting the excise.
uncertain
it → warn → excise
Opposition Leader Angus Taylor says slashing the tax on a pack of cigarettes by more than 20 dollars will not create more smokers, as the cost of illegal cigarettes is already at that price.
asserted
cost → say → price
The Coalition has not modelled how its proposed 80 per cent cut to the tobacco excise would affect smoking rates, Shadow Home Affairs Minister Jonno Duniam told ABC's Insiders program, though it has looked at the consequences of similar approaches overseas.
asserted
it → model → approaches
Canada had raised tobacco taxes through the 1980s and 1990s to discourage smoking, but after an explosion in organised crime, Canadian federal and provincial governments slashed tobacco taxes in 1994.
asserted
governments → raise → 1994
The cuts led to a spike in smoking, particularly among young people, Senator Duniam said, however smoking rates in Canada have ultimately fallen.
asserted
rates → lead → Canada
"There was a point in time they went up, but over the course of time — as the illicit tobacco trade trailed off — smoking rates went down to where they are now, which is 11 per cent," Senator Duniam said.
asserted
Duniam → be → time
"And their policy settings continued that trajectory over that course of time."
asserted
settings → continue → time
Canada's federal and provincial governments eventually restored pre-1994 tax rates on tobacco, which supporters say allowed a gradual return after the black market had been crushed and law enforcement established.
asserted
enforcement → restore → return
Critics, however, say it failed to provide a permanent fix, with the illicit black market returning, higher youth smoking rates in the meantime, and lost revenue from the tax cut.
asserted
market → say → cut
Coalition says crime groups must be disrupted
The tobacco commissioner has estimated about half of all tobacco sales in Australia are now through the black market — fuelling billions in proceeds for crime groups, leading to increased violence particularly in Sydney and Melbourne, and eating into federal government revenue from the tax on tobacco.
Senator Duniam said modelling by the Parliamentary Budget Office his party commissioned on how deeply to cut the tobacco excise found a "real change" in consumer behaviour if the excise was cut by 80 per cent.
asserted
excise → say → cent
He said combined with law enforcement and education, Australia's illicit tobacco trade could be stamped out.
uncertain
trade → say → enforcement
"We should also focus on disrupting the capacity for the illicit market to provide these products.
asserted
market → focus → products
That also causes issues for their capacity to supply, impacts their capacity to offer cheaper prices and the combined package altogether, not just the cut in excise, is what we believe will cripple the illicit tobacco market," Senator Duniam said.
asserted
Duniam → cause → market
"We want to see the smoking rates in this country go down.
asserted
rates → want → country
In order to do that, a part of the problem is dealing with cheap smokes out there in the community now.
asserted
part → deal → community
Kick off the illegal trade is the only way you can do that."
asserted
you → kick → that
Earlier, Mr Taylor told News24 that to smash organised crime, legal cigarettes needed to be brought to "parity" with illegal tobacco.
asserted
cigarettes → tell → tobacco
"We're confident working with experts, working with the Parliamentary Budget Office, that they can smash that market," Mr Taylor said.
asserted
Taylor → work → market
An excise cut of 80 per cent would amount to about $25 being knocked off the price of a pack of 20 cigarettes, bringing those down to about $16 to $26 if the full tax cut is passed on by cigarette retailers.
asserted
cut → amount → retailers
Asked whether he believed the excise cut would lead to more people picking up smoking, Mr Taylor responded, "No, no I don't [believe that].
asserted
I → ask → that
The horse has already bolted on this.
asserted
horse → bolt → this
The price of cigarettes in this country is already down around $15 a pack or less … anyone can choose to buy that.
"
asserted
anyone → choose → that
That's the price, it's already happened.
asserted
it → happen → ?
So you have got to recognise the reality here."
asserted
you → get → reality
Mr Taylor rejected that the Coalition had landed on an 80 per cent excise cut to outcompete One Nation's proposed 75 per cent excise cut.
asserted
Coalition → reject → cut
"We decided to go one better than organised crime and criminal gangs in this country.
asserted
We → decide → country
That's who we're competing with here — that's what this is about," he said.
asserted
he → compete → what
"It needs to be fixed and it needs to be fixed now.
asserted
it → need → ?
And I'll tell you, every arson attack that we see now we will be saying to the government: 'You can fix this.'"
asserted
You → tell → this
The Aporia