Andy Burnham had barely got his feet under his No10 desk when he telephoned Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, president of the United Arab Emirates.
asserted
he → get → Emirates
According to the official record of their conversation, the Prime Minister, just days into his new job, ‘began by thanking His Highness for his country’s investment into Manchester and the incredible impact it has had on the city’.
uncertain
it → accord → city
Yet knowing the obliging former Manchester mayor as we do, it is possible to imagine he was more effusive in his gratitude than Downing Street’s pedestrian account of the call suggests.
uncertain
account → know → call
After all it was the Emirati ruler’s brother, Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan, the owner of Manchester City, who transformed not only the football club but the city centre itself, his millions helping to deliver the ‘Manchester miracle’ growth story that propelled Mr Burnham to the summit of British politics.
asserted
that → transform → politics
So perhaps we shouldn’t be too surprised that he made that call to Sheikh Mohamed.
asserted
he → make → Mohamed
Or that, as the Daily Mail has discovered, the UAE’s ambassador to the UK, Mansoor Abulhoul, visited Mr Burnham a fortnight ago, accompanied by none other than the man at the centre of what is fast becoming the biggest football scandal in history – Manchester City’s chairman, Khaldoon Al Mubarak.
asserted
what → discover → history
Before stepping through the door of No10, for what was apparently a meeting with Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, Mr Mubarak was seen sauntering nonchalantly along Downing Street.
asserted
Mubarak → step → Street
Coming just days before the club’s guilty verdicts were made public, the meeting reportedly discussed current and future UAE investments in Britain.
uncertain
meeting → come → Britain
It wasn’t the PM’s first meeting with Abu Dhabi’s most powerful non-royal: they were pictured together at Manchester City’s Etihad Stadium in 2019.
asserted
they → picture → 2019
With these links to the Emiratis in mind, it is perhaps little wonder that while football fans reacted with a mix of anger and disbelief at the scale of Manchester City’s cheating shame last week, our Prime Minister was supportive of the club’s owners.
asserted
Minister → react → owners
To widespread dismay, Mr Burnham said he would be ‘really concerned’ if they now decided to sell up, noting that it was ‘frustrating when people rush to judgment’.
asserted
people → say → judgment
Yet he wasn’t responding to a mere allegation.
asserted
he → respond → allegation
Following a lengthy investigation, three judges on an independent commission had found Manchester City’s owners guilty of systematically flouting Premier League rules for nearly a decade – a verdict the club is appealing.
asserted
club → follow → decade
What on earth, asked an incredulous nation, was Mr Burnham thinking?
asserted
Burnham → ask → earth
Reform Treasury spokesman Robert Jenrick said: ‘He seems more interested in Middle Eastern money than protecting the integrity of the game.’
asserted
He → say → game
Downing Street rowed back on his remarks, saying that ‘wherever wrongdoing is established, those responsible should face the appropriate consequences’.
But there is a growing feeling that his good relations with the Emiratis make him susceptible to pressure.
asserted
him → row → pressure
Nick McGeehan, director of FairSquare, a sports and human rights research group, told the Daily Mail there was serious concern that the UAE ‘will use the relationship they have obviously developed with Andy Burnham’ to try to escape sanction.
asserted
they → tell → sanction
He said: ‘I suspect they will go very hard on the UK Government, using a huge amount of political pressure in the hope that it will lean on the Premier League.’
asserted
it → say → League
Football fans have been making clear their views in online forums.
asserted
views → make → forums
If only a gutsy politician had stood up to all these dodgy foreign investors, is a common refrain.
asserted
refrain → stand → investors
As sports minister in 2008, the lifelong Everton fan said he thought big-money takeovers risked the future of our national game.
asserted
takeovers → say → game
He added that tougher tests needed to be placed on new owners of teams to ensure they have the best interests of the club and community in their plans.
asserted
they → add → plans
City's owners have invested hundreds of millions on the site and surrounding areas in east Manchester
Nearly two decades on, he now appears to be on the side of super-rich investors.
asserted
he → invest → investors
Last week was not the first time Mr Burnham has defended Manchester City’s owners.
asserted
Burnham → defend → owners
In a podcast interview in 2023, he was asked about Manchester council ‘selling swathes of land to the club’s owners’.
asserted
council → ask → owners
Was this something that concerned him?
asserted
that → concern → him
‘Go to east Manchester now and look at photographs of it 30 years ago,’ Mr Burnham told Pod Save The UK.
asserted
Burnham → go → UK
‘A large amount of the investment has come in from the owners of Manchester City.’
asserted
amount → come → City
It is certainly true the club’s owners spent a lot of money on Manchester.
asserted
owners → spend → Manchester
The club itself had been bought for £200million in 2008 by Abu Dhabi United Group (ADUG), a private equity group owned by Sheikh Mansour.
asserted
club → buy → Mansour
The sale was timely for Manchester city council, which owns the Etihad, and which had its own money problems.
asserted
which → own → problems
Six years later the council collaborated with ADUG in a £1billion investment deal to build Manchester Life – a 6,000-home project in east Manchester.
asserted
council → collaborate → Manchester
The terms of this arrangement were later found by academics at the University of Sheffield to be startlingly favourable for ADUG.
asserted
terms → find → ADUG
The leaseholds for land, property assets, rental and sales income rights, and ultimate control of the joint ventures, were all held by entities owned by ADUG, often via companies based in Jersey, which allowed the firms to benefit from negligible tax.
asserted
firms → hold → tax
A council spokesman said: ‘Claims that some land was sold too cheaply to Manchester Life ignore the fact that there was zero market interest at the time of the sale, that the land is worth more now precisely because of Manchester Life’s investment.’
uncertain
land → say → investment
Nevertheless, others believe that the UAE’s investment in Manchester was part of a pattern.
asserted
investment → believe → pattern
‘The Premier League provides an incredible international advertising platform for Abu Dhabi’s state-owned entities,’ said Christopher Davidson, an expert on the UAE at Durham University.
asserted
Davidson → provide → University
‘And by investing in football, museums and hospitals, or even east Manchester, Abu Dhabi is winning hearts and minds.’
asserted
Dhabi → invest → hearts
Others take an even more jaundiced view.
asserted
Others → take → view
Amnesty, the human rights group, once said the UAE’s ‘enormous investment’ in the club was ‘one of football’s most brazen attempts to “sportswash” a country’s deeply tarnished image’, adding that City’s success involved a ‘close relationship with a country that relies on exploited migrant labour and locks up peaceful critics’.
asserted
that → say → critics
…and 5 more, not listed.
The Aporia
