Carney says Canada was involved 'from the start' in NATO spy investigation
'Lessons' should be learned from situations like this, prime minister says
Canadian officials were involved in the investigation of an intern accused of spying at NATO's military headquarters from the outset, Prime Minister Mark Carney said on Wednesday.
asserted
Carney → say → Wednesday
He said "lessons" should be taken from situations like this, but stopped short of saying that the country's security screening process was being reviewed in light of the allegations.
asserted
process → say → allegations
A Canadian woman was recently arrested by Belgian authorities on suspicion of espionage.
asserted
woman → arrest → espionage
The European country did not release her name as part of the judicial process and only stated that she was a "Canadian national of Chinese origin."
asserted
she → release → origin
A CBC News investigation, however, has identified the woman as Biwei Zhang, a systems engineer with a background in economics.
asserted
investigation → identify → economics
Her online resumé suggests she previously worked for the Canadian Space Agency and Statistics Canada.
uncertain
she → suggest → Agency
Her public and professional profiles match the information Belgian prosecutors provided.
asserted
prosecutors → match → information
The agency refused to comment on the CBC investigation.
asserted
agency → refuse → investigation
In his first public comments since the arrest, Carney said the matter is before the courts, but suggested Canadian security officials were not caught flat-footed.
"It's an active investigation, so I'm limited in what I can say," the prime minister said.
uncertain
minister → say → what
"The only thing I would add cryptically is that the Canadian officials have been involved from the start.
asserted
officials → add → start
Carney didn't elaborate, but the RCMP is on the public record as saying it is co-operating with Belgian authorities.
asserted
it → elaborate → authorities
The allegations have not been proven in court.
asserted
allegations → prove → court
Zhang is currently being held in custody with a further closed-door hearing to be held in Brussels next week.
asserted
Zhang → hold → Brussels
Security sources, speaking to media in Europe, including the Reuters news agency, have said the intern allegedly exhibited suspicious behaviour that drew the attention of NATO's internal security services.
uncertain
that → speak → services
She was, according to the publication Le Soir, excessively curious about her colleagues, had a tendency to enter areas where she was not authorized and apparently accessed files outside her professional remit in SHAPE's IT Department.
uncertain
she → accord → Department
Someone working in that section would normally have broad access to the systems that support NATO's strategic military headquarters, including network operations, cybersecurity and data centre servers.
asserted
that → work → operations
However, interns do not have as much freedom as full-time staff members and would be subject to closer supervision and face restricted access permissions.
asserted
interns → have → permissions
Ottawa vows to 'get to the bottom' of spying allegations against Canadian NATO intern
Canadian intern at NATO military headquarters in Belgium faces spying charges
- CBC Investigates
CBC identifies Canadian woman accused of spying at NATO military HQ
While significant spying cases involving NATO are not uncommon, the arrest of someone working inside Western alliance's own institutional structure is exceedingly rare, said Keir Giles, an associate fellow at U.K.-based Chatham House.
asserted
Giles → vow → House
The last publicly acknowledged one was in 2012 where a man identified only as Manfred K. by German authorities attempted to sell classified information to Russian intelligence.
asserted
man → acknowledge → intelligence
He was a civilian IT specialist and was stopped before anything was handed over.
asserted
anything → stop → ?
You'd have to go back to Cold War to find other comparable examples, including the landmark case of Rainer Rupp, a West German economist employed at NATO headquarters who through the 1970s, '80s and '90s passed highly classified alliance documents to East Germany's foreign intelligence service, which shared them with Russia's KGB.
asserted
which → have → KGB
There was also the case of George Pâques, a French national who over several years leaked hundreds of classified NATO documents to Moscow before being arrested in 1963.
asserted
who → be → 1963
The so-called Pâques Affair forced NATO to overhaul many of its security procedures and remains one of the alliance's foundational counter-intelligence cases.
asserted
Affair → call → cases
Giles said it's not clear whether NATO's spy catchers and security procedures are air-tight — or whether suspected cases were handled quietly by removing the access of suspects before anything happens.
asserted
anything → say → suspects
"There's no doubt that NATO headquarters will be a priority target for a lot of unpleasant people around the world," Giles said.
asserted
Giles → be → world
"It is striking how rarely this is actually intercepted and announced publicly
asserted
this → intercept → ?
The Aporia
