A police charge sheet submitted on September 3 blames the management of Gul Plaza for negligence that led to the deadly fire on January 17, which killed at least 73 people and destroyed over 1,100 shops. The document accuses four individuals, including Huzaifa's father Naimatullah and Gul Plaza Traders Association President Tanveer Pasta, of being responsible for the tragedy. According to the charge sheet, the building management was aware of inadequate fire safety equipment and failed to address the issue, leaving people trapped in the building due to locked gates. The document also notes that the rescue efforts by authorities were hindered due to the negligence of the building management.
Written by the local model on 2026-09-06,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event.
Police on Saturday submitted a charge sheet before the South judicial magistrate on the Gul Plaza fire, blaming the building management’s “negligence”.
asserted
Police → submit → negligence
The deadly inferno, which erupted on the night of January 17 at the mall and took nearly two days to be fully extinguished, had claimed at least 73 lives and left over 1,100 shops in ruins.
asserted
which → erupt → ruins
A previous charge sheet submitted in July had named six people — including 11-year-old Huzaifa — as the accused.
asserted
sheet → submit → accused
However, a judicial magistrate had rejected the document, noting that the investigating officer (IO) had not conducted a thorough and satisfactory probe.
asserted
officer → reject → probe
The fresh charge sheet, dated September 3 and submitted by the Nabi Bux police, names four of those six as the accused sent for trial: Huzaifa’s father Naimatullah who owned an artificial flower shop; Gul Plaza Traders Association President Tanveer Pasta; and association members Ammar Ismail and Muhammad Ramzan.
asserted
who → date → shop
Meanwhile, regarding the role of authorities, the charge sheet said the fire brigade, Rescue 1122, and Karachi Metropolitan Corporation (KMC) “used the resources they had with great efforts to put out the blaze”.
asserted
they → regard → blaze
Listing the faults on the building management’s side, the document stated that the Gul Plaza administration lacked adequate tools to extinguish the fire, considering the scale of the building.
asserted
administration → list → building
It added that there was “no alternative arrangement for emergency lights, due to which people faced difficulties leaving” the building.
asserted
people → add → building
It noted that during the investigation, the complainant in the case said only two of the building’s gates were open at the time of the fire.
asserted
two → note → fire
“People could not leave due to the locks on the iron gates,” the charge sheet read.
uncertain
sheet → leave → gates
It went on to say that during the rescue operation, it was discovered that the iron gates on the third floor were padlocked, which “showed that the Gul Plaza administration had their guards close them”.
asserted
guards → go → them
The document further pointed out that the building management had K-Electric switch off the power supply “despite knowing that they do not have any other alternative arrangement for lighting”.
asserted
they → point → lighting
The charge sheet said Faisal Ibrahim, the owner of Fire Works VIP Service, used to buy the fire safety equipment for the Gul Plaza union.
asserted
Ibrahim → say → union
It added that during the investigation, the quantity of such equipment was found to be inadequate, and that the building management was responsible for repairing and replenishing it.
asserted
management → add → it
This proved the “criminal negligence and carelessness” of the building management, the charge sheet declared.
asserted
sheet → prove → management
It recalled that the findings of the Sindh government’s inquiry commission and the judicial commission also proved the Gul Plaza administration’s negligence.
asserted
findings → recall → negligence
It noted that safety equipment and speakers were not used, while the exits were also found closed.
asserted
exits → note → ?
On the other hand, the charge sheet recalled the rescue operation and the death of a firefighter in the process.
asserted
sheet → recall → process
It added, “Due to these reasons, the hard work of the rescue services cannot be doubted, and no concrete testimony emerged during the investigation that would show criminal negligence of rescue authorities.”
asserted
that → add → authorities
The charge sheet highlighted that neither the government inquiry body nor the judicial commission found rescue authorities at fault for any criminal negligence.
asserted
authorities → highlight → negligence
While departmental action was taken against Civil Defence Director Abdul Majeed Jagirani and Additional Controller Fatima Memon, “no criminal negligence of the institution was found”, the charge sheet said.
asserted
sheet → take → institution
It noted that Memon and technical instructor Mirza Mursalin Baig were dismissed from their jobs.
asserted
Memon → note → jobs
Similarly, the fire brigade’s Station Officer Zaheer Siddiqui was also dismissed from his role, the charge sheet said, adding that no “criminal negligence was found”.
asserted
negligence → dismiss → role
In its report, the Gul Plaza Judicial Commission said the deadly inferno signified a systemic failure across successive provincial and local governments as the legal and administrative mechanisms have existed, but could not be implemented effectively.
uncertain
mechanisms → say → governments
Justice Agha Faisal of the Sindh High Court (SHC), who headed the commission, noted that the tragic incident was a grave indictment of the failure of municipal and provincial systems to translate legal duties concerning urban safety into effective protection on the ground.
asserted
incident → head → ground
It stated that the people not only lost their lives to flames, but also due to delay, darkness, locked exits and windows of the ill-fated building, absence of fire safety systems, unimplemented audits/inspections and fragmented authority.
asserted
people → state → systems
Notably, the commission said KMC, including its fire brigade, Sindh Building Control Authority, Rescue 1122, civil defence department, district administration and others, bore institutional responsibilities for the failure, while material responsibility rested with the people acting as the de facto management of the building together with owners, occupants and commercial operators.
asserted
people → say → owners
The report was handed over to the provincial government months ago but was released last month, apparently against the backdrop of a tragic hospital fire in Islamabad.
asserted
report → hand → Islamabad
