Karen Bevan, from Full Stop Australia, criticized the Sydney Swans' decision to allow players involved in sexual assault allegations to remain eligible for the best and fairest award. Isaac Heeney won the Bob Skilton Medal despite being one of four players who are persons of interest in an ongoing investigation by Victoria Police. The club's chief executive Andrew Pridhman defended this decision, arguing that player conduct is separate from performance. Bevan emphasized the importance of setting standards for young fans and victims of sexual violence.
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-10-02,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Story summary
Isaac Heeney, despite winning his third consecutive Bob Skilton Medal (renamed "Most Valuable Player"), did not attend the Sydney Swans' awards night at Sydney Town Hall due to a club-imposed suspension. The incident arose from allegations that he and four teammates—Chad Warner, Nick Blakey, James Jordan, and Riley Bice—had breached the club's standards during an event involving exotic dancers in Melbourne on August 17. Three women involved have alleged sexual assault but no charges were filed; they are now pursuing civil action. The Swans' decision to allow these players to remain eligible for awards has drawn criticism from sexual assault advocates like Karen Bevan of Full Stop Australia, who argues that such actions undermine the club's standards and send a harmful message to young fans and players.
Written for “Heeney Controversy Sydney Swans” on 2026-10-05,
grounded in this article and the 1 other(s) covering the same event.
A sexual assault advocate has criticised the Sydney Swans’ decision to allow players at the centre of sexual assault allegations to remain eligible for the club’s best and fairest award, after star midfielder Isaac Heeney took home the top honour on Thursday night.
asserted
Heeney → criticise → night
Heeney and teammates Chad Warner, Nick Blakey and James Jordon all featured in the top 10 of polling for the Bob Skilton Medal, which the club earlier this week recast as an award for the Swans’ “most valuable player”.
asserted
club → feature → player
The four players remain persons of interest in an unfolding investigation by Victoria Police into allegations of sexual assault made by three exotic dancers in a suite of the Pullman Hotel in the pre-dawn hours of August 17.
asserted
players → remain → August
All of the men deny any wrongdoing and maintain their innocence.
asserted
All → deny → innocence
No charges have been laid, and the police investigation is ongoing.
asserted
investigation → lay → ?
“In August the club took action on standards,” chief executive of sexual assault advocacy organisation Full Stop Australia Karen Bevan said.
asserted
Bevan → take → Australia
“[The awards] were a chance to show those standards are still being upheld.
asserted
standards → show → ?
“Young fans, junior players and the club’s own AFLW players will take their cues from what they see celebrated.”
asserted
they → take → cues
The four players – plus Riley Bice, who was cleared by police but is considered a witness to what happened in the hotel room – were suspended by the club for breaching the Swans’ behavioural standards but were still eligible for the award.
asserted
what → clear → award
At the gala ceremony, millionaire businessman and Swans chair Andrew Pridhman, who has been a club director for 24 years and led the board for 13 years, said “player conduct and performance are very separate matters”.
asserted
conduct → lead → years
At the Sydney Town Hall event Warner polled fourth in the best and fairest voting, Blakey came seventh, while Jordon was 10th.
asserted
Jordon → poll → voting
“[On Thursday], a room full of people applauded, and somewhere in the audience, at home and in the club membership, there were people who have experienced sexual violence – that’s who we think about,” Bevan said of the awards.
“Victim survivors pay close attention to who gets listened to, who gets celebrated and who gets forgotten.”
asserted
who → applaud → attention
Recently retired Swan Taylor Adams and a third mystery man were also in the hotel room as chaotic events unfolded, but they are considered by police to be witnesses.
asserted
they → retire → police
None of the five players attended the Thursday night event.
asserted
None → attend → event
The three exotic dancers were engaged by the Sydney players to perform in one of the players’ hotel rooms after a night of wild partying.
asserted
dancers → engage → partying
The team, coaches and club officials were staying at the Pullman following its round 23 win against Essendon on August 16, with the cost of the Swans’ accommodation paid for by the AFL.
asserted
cost → stay → AFL
All three women have made separate statements to Victoria Police about the events that unfolded in the hotel room.
asserted
that → make → room
Police have said a further update on the matter is not expected until the end of October.
asserted
update → say → October
Pridham told Thursday’s awards ceremony that making the players ineligible for the season’s club honours would be “inappropriate and in excess of the sanction” they had received for breaching the club’s behavioural standards.
asserted
they → tell → standards
Earlier this week, this masthead reported that two of the women at the centre of the allegations have been medically assessed and found to be suffering severe trauma-related disorders following events at the hotel in the pre-dawn hours of August 17.
asserted
two → report → August
A source close to the women, but not authorised to speak publicly, said details of the women’s fragile mental health had been documented in numerous official medical reports, one of which extended to more than 40 pages of clinical detail, they said.
asserted
they → authorise → detail
They said the women had been medically assessed, including extensive psychological evaluations, following the incident and that the pair had been found to be variously struggling with post-traumatic stress disorder and adjustment disorder.
asserted
pair → say → disorder
The source said the women were now undergoing treatment.
asserted
women → say → treatment
The next key milestone for the club in managing the fallout from the Pullman scandal is the unfolding trade period, with Blakey said to be unhappy with the Swans’ handling of the Pullman affair and wanting to leave the club.
asserted
Blakey → manage → club
AFL chief executive Andrew Dillon has said it is a matter for clubs to decide whether they wish to trade for any of the five suspended Sydney Swans players, but that any decision involves risk as the police investigation remains incomplete.
asserted
investigation → say → risk
The Aporia
