Claims extracted
30
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
13%
4 of 30 hedged
("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans right
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
61/100
The Sydney Morning Herald's corrections and
hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
1
Health
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Queensland Ambulance Services have said it is inaccurate to describe this week’s incident as a system failure, as politicians continue to clash over its impacts.
asserted
politicians → say → impacts
The QAS’ computer-aided dispatch (CAD) system was upgraded on Thursday, but resulted in staff having to manually relay important information to ambulances by radio.
asserted
staff → aid → radio
Triple Zero calls were not impacted and QAS said it has not received any reports of adverse impacts to patients from the transition.
asserted
it → impact → transition
A QAS spokesperson said Queenslanders can be confident they will receive ambulance services if they call Triple Zero.
asserted
they → say → Zero
“Our systems are working as intended following the transition to our new CAD system,” they said.
asserted
they → work → system
“All Triple Zero calls are being answered and resources are being dispatched in a timely manner, with the most urgent cases prioritised.
asserted
cases → answer → manner
The possible impact on the system during the transition was anticipated and accounted for, the QAS spokesperson said.
asserted
spokesperson → anticipate → transition
“Business continuity processes were enacted during the transition … this included rostering additional staff and validating all incidents to ensure they received an appropriate response,” they said.
asserted
they → enact → response
While there have been reports in the media of ambulances arriving significantly late or not arriving at all, health minister Tim Nicholls said this was completely untrue.
asserted
this → arrive → media
“There was an alternative system in the event that the changeover didn’t go exactly according to plan,” Nicholls said.
uncertain
Nicholls → be → plan
Nicholls said it was “absolutely disingenuous and really quite despicable” for the state opposition to claim services were impacted.
uncertain
services → say → ?
“We’re not aware of any reports that anyone has made that they’ve had to drive themselves because they were unable to get through to Triple Zero,” he said.
asserted
he → ’re → Zero
“Now, there might be people who called through and weren’t either a category one, two, or three.
uncertain
who → call → ?
That might be the normal course of events, but certainly nothing as a result of the changeover in the system has led to that delay that I’m aware of.”
uncertain
I → lead → that
Nicholls said QAS staff are used to the manual system and it was regularly used during updates to the old system.
asserted
it → say → system
“It’s precisely because that old system was reaching end of life that the new system was brought in,” he said.
asserted
he → reach → life
“Is it unfortunate that it didn’t go as smoothly as the QAS would have hoped?
asserted
QAS → go → ?
Did the contingency work as it’s expected to?
asserted
it → work → ?
I’m advised not.
asserted
I → advise → ?
Were any Triple Zero calls not answered?
asserted
calls → answer → ?
I’m advised not.
asserted
I → advise → ?
“All records have been checked, and any outstanding records from yesterday continue to be reviewed.
asserted
records → check → yesterday
But there are no instances of missed care being provided in the community that I’m aware of.”
asserted
I → be → that
However, the state opposition has maintained that the incident was more serious than is being communicated.
asserted
incident → maintain → ?
Opposition leader Steven Miles once again slammed the state government for the system failure on Saturday.
asserted
Miles → slam → Saturday
“We’re calling for a full investigation, a full review of what went wrong with the systems upgrade, why they weren’t able to roll back to the legacy system that was stable and working, and what they will put in place to ensure that this never happens again,” Miles said.
asserted
Miles → call → place
“The people talking to us say that they have never experienced a shutdown of the dispatch system like what occurred this week.
asserted
what → talk → system
“[Premier] David Crisafulli once said that ambulances not arriving on time was incomprehensible in a modern Queensland, but it is precisely what we’ve seen this week under this.
asserted
we → say → this
“And yet the government and the ambulance service seems determined to not tell Queenslanders how many people waited for an ambulance, how many people never had, how many people were so sick and in such pain that they drove themselves to hospital rather than wait for an ambulance that.
asserted
they → seem → ambulance
“It’s about time the health minister came clean with Queenslanders about what really happened during the week with ambulance dispatches.”
asserted
what → ’ → dispatches
The Aporia
