Calling it another in a “sad litany” of wrongful convictions, Ontario’s highest court on Tuesday finally acquitted Jennifer Gaskin of manslaughter in the death of her infant son — a conviction that was based on the “discredited” shaken baby syndrome as the cause of his death.
asserted
that → call → death
“She is a victim of a miscarriage of justice,” brought by, in part, unreliable expert evidence, Justice Peter Lauwers of the Court of Appeal for Ontario said on behalf of a three-judge panel.
asserted
Lauwers → bring → panel
On July 2, 1999, 12-week-old Joeseph Gaskin died in his home in Ignace, Ont.
asserted
Gaskin → die → Ignace
Months later, on March 5, 2000, his mother was charged with second-degree murder.
asserted
mother → charge → murder
She was alleged to have shaken the baby to death.
asserted
She → allege → death
A jury convicted her of manslaughter in 2002 and sentenced her to two years in prison, a sentence she served.
asserted
she → convict → prison
In the meantime, her two other children were taken from her and put up for adoption.
asserted
children → take → adoption
Gaskin always maintained she did nothing wrong to cause her son’s death.
asserted
she → maintain → death
“I never struck Joeseph and I never shook him.
asserted
I → strike → him
I did nothing to cause his death.
asserted
I → do → death
I have never felt able to breathe freely because I feel everyone sees me as a monster,” she wrote in a sworn affidavit.
asserted
she → feel → affidavit
Now 51, Gaskin broke down in tears in the court after Lauwers concluded his remarks.
asserted
Lauwers → break → remarks
Sitting next to her was her mother and her daughter — whom she met for the first time Monday after not seeing her since she was 15 months old.
asserted
she → sit → her
Her son was on his way to the downtown Toronto courtroom but fell ill en route from Dryden, Ont., and had to turn back, “so that reunion hopefully will occur in the near future,” her lawyer, James Lockyer, told the court.
asserted
lawyer → fall → court
He called the case “a tragedy” on many levels.
asserted
He → call → levels
The Crown consented to the admission of fresh evidence, and agreed her conviction should be set aside and an acquittal entered.
The wrongful conviction of Jennifer Gaskin
In 1999, Gaskin was 23 when she delivered Joeseph, nine-and-a-half weeks prematurely.
asserted
she → consent → Joeseph
He had severe medical issues and remained in hospital for two months.
asserted
He → have → months
In the days leading up to his death, Joeseph was unwell.
asserted
Joeseph → lead → death
Gaskin and her partner took the child to a hospital.
asserted
Gaskin → take → hospital
Back at home, he turned blue, stopped breathing and died.
asserted
he → turn → home
In an autopsy, a physician suspected some shaking may have occurred but concluded Joeseph died of a head injury.
uncertain
Joeseph → suspect → injury
Police then called in a second opinion and solicited the opinion of a pathologist.
asserted
Police → call → pathologist
He concluded the baby was shaken and “died from the resultant injuries.”
asserted
baby → conclude → injuries
At her trial in Northern Ontario, the Crown’s theory was that Gaskin had vigorously shaken that infant because he was crying and she was frustrated.
asserted
she → shake → infant
Two medical experts testified in support of the prosecution.
asserted
experts → testify → prosecution
Lockyer told the court a “miscarriage of justice” was lurking, but “shaken baby won the day.”
asserted
baby → tell → day
Lockyer is a veteran of high-profile cases of the wrongly convicted such as David Milgaard, Guy Paul Morin and Steven Truscott.
asserted
Lockyer → convict → Milgaard
After the Court of Appeal granted Gaskin an extension to appeal her conviction based on fresh evidence, Lockyer and his team retained three medical experts to prepare reports.
asserted
Lockyer → grant → reports
One doctor warned that other potential causes of death may have been overlooked.
uncertain
causes → warn → death
A second said shaken baby syndrome remains an unproven hypothesis and that research does not support the notion that shaking alone can generate enough force to injure an infant.
asserted
shaking → say → infant
The third found the cause of death was ultimately undetermined.
asserted
cause → find → death
The appellate court found these reports show that Gaskin’s conviction is “unsustainable.”
asserted
conviction → find → ?
It bears repeating that it is “profoundly regrettable that because … of what has been shown to be flawed pathological evidence, Ms. Gaskin was wrongfully convicted.
asserted
Gaskin → bear → ?
We allow the appeal, set aside the conviction, and enter an acquittal,” Lauwers said.
asserted
Lauwers → allow → acquittal
A total of 129 shaken baby cases were reviewed following revelations that Charles Smith, the head pediatric forensic pathologist at the Hospital for Sick Children, made errors in hundreds of autopsies.
asserted
Smith → shake → autopsies
Thirteen were singled out for re-evaluation by a panel of international doctors.
asserted
Thirteen → single → doctors
The panel found four cases where convictions were based on evidence that was “of concern.”
asserted
that → find → concern
The Aporia
