The grieving parents of a teenage girl killed by an illegal migrant put New York’s sanctuary law on blast during a fiery congressional debate Monday night between Republican Rep. Mike Lawler and Democratic opponent Cait Conley for the House seat representing the lower Hudson Valley.
asserted
parents → grieve → Valley
Tom and Jessica Gorman were among residents in the 17th House district to call into the televised debate on News 12 to ask the candidates a question.
asserted
Gorman → call → question
Their daughter, Sheridan, an 18-year-old freshman Loyola University student in Chicago, was gunned down in cold blood by an undocumented Venezuelan migrant on March 19 while walking with friends along Lake Michigan.
asserted
daughter → gun → Michigan
The defendant, Jose Medina, had previous run-ins with law enforcement but was set free before the deadly shooting.
asserted
defendant → have → shooting
As his wife Jessica choked back tears during the video call, Tom Gorman asked whether the candidates would support federal legislation that would undo so-called state sanctuary laws, such as the protections that Gov. Kathy Hochul and Albany Democrats enacted earlier this year.
asserted
Hochul → choke → that
That law bars local law enforcement agencies from cooperating with US Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers regarding the detention of migrants living in New York illegally.
asserted
law → bar → York
Conley told the Gormans that Sheridan’s murder was “inexcusable” but refused to say whether or not she would be willing to scrap the Empire State’s new sanctuary law.
asserted
she → tell → law
“Government failed her and for that we have to make sure that that doesn’t happen again,” said Conley, who noted, as an Army veteran, she had served as a military police officer.
asserted
she → fail → officer
“The safety and security of our families is something I will be unwavering in,” she added.
asserted
she → add → families
On her campaign website, Conley said she supports revoking so-called 287g agreements that allow local cops to assist ICE with immigration enforcement — in sum, backing New York’s sanctuary law.
asserted
cops → say → law
Conley said she believes “border security is national security” and that immigration enforcement is essential to combat violent crime, terrorism, trafficking and gang violence, but condemned the Trump administration’s approach.
asserted
enforcement → say → approach
She complained that ICE under Trump is rounding up “people like grandmas and nurses and people in our communities” rather than focusing on criminal aliens.
asserted
ICE → complain → aliens
Lawler pounced on Conley’s non-answer.
asserted
Lawler → pounce → answer
“Well, Jess and Tom, what you didn’t hear from Cait was an answer to your question.
asserted
hear → hear → question
She does support Kathy Hochul’s new law,” Lawler said, reiterating his support for a federal law against states’ sanctuary laws.
asserted
Lawler → support → laws
“She would not support federal legislation to end sanctuary policies.
asserted
She → support → policies
Let me be very clear, I stand with you.
asserted
I → let → you
I am against Kathy Hochul’s disastrous new law and I support any legislation that will end sanctuary jurisdictions in this country.”
asserted
that → support → country
But both pledged to support helping Haitian migrants whose temporary protected status was revoked by Trump in July.
asserted
status → pledge → July
Conley blamed Lawler for not stopping the president’s action.
asserted
Conley → blame → action
During the one-hour-long debate, Lawler and Conley fielded questions on numerous issues including the economy and tariffs, energy and utility costs, Israel and the Middle East, artificial intelligence and data centers, the solvency of Social Security and Medicaid, congestion pricing and even New York’s policy that legalized the sale of marijuana.
asserted
that → field → marijuana
They agreed on a few issues — particularly in scrapping the $9 congestion toll to enter Manhattan’s business district.
asserted
They → agree → district
Conley broke with fellow Democrat Hochul, who has championed congestion pricing.
asserted
who → break → pricing
Conley said the cannabis law has been helpful to New York.
asserted
law → say → York
Lawler said it’s hurt the state.
asserted
it → say → state
Lawler touted his advocacy for the law that lifted the cap on state and local tax deductions on federal tax (SALT) returns, which he claimed saved taxpayers thousands of dollars.
asserted
he → tout → dollars
Start your day with all you need to know
Morning Report delivers the latest news, videos, photos and more.
asserted
Report → start → news
Conley rapped Lawler’s support of the Trump-Republican budget bills that trimmed spending on Medicaid and social services and said Trump’s tariffs were “reckless” and raised costs for constituents.
asserted
tariffs → rap → constituents
She said she would raise payroll taxes on Americans making more than $400,000 to preserve Social Security benefits.
asserted
she → say → benefits
Both candidates expressed strong support for Israel, including continuing military funding.
But Lawler asked Conley, “do you denounce [Mayor] Zohran Mamdani?” when complaining about the “antisemitic base” of the Democratic Party.
asserted
you → express → Party
Conley shot back, “Do you denounce Donald Trump for the harm he’s caused to families in the Hudson Valley?”
asserted
he → shoot → Valley
The candidates repeated positions they had already laid out during the campaign.
asserted
they → repeat → campaign
Conley pushed renewable solar and wind power scaled back by the Trump administration to increase the energy supply.
asserted
Conley → push → supply
Lawler championed reviving the Indian Point nuclear power plant and allowing gas extraction outlawed in New York to boost energy and help lower utility costs.
asserted
extraction → champion → costs
Conley endorsed Hochul’s one-year moratorium on construction of AI data centers in New York, while Lawler opposed it.
asserted
Lawler → endorse → it
They both called each other liars for distorting their positions and Conley several times called Lawler a “lifelong political operative.”
asserted
Conley → call → Lawler
Lawler and Conley are locked in a reported neck-and-neck race in a swing district that has become one of the most closely watched in the country — and could determine which party controls the House of Representatives next year.
uncertain
party → lock → Representatives
The 17th Congressional District, which encompasses Rockland, Putnam and parts of Westchester and Dutchess counties, where a large portion of households have family members who are police officers, firefighters or veterans.
asserted
who → encompass → members
Lawler, a former state assemblyman long active in GOP politics, is seeking a third term.
asserted
Lawler → seek → term
Conley is a US Army veteran and West Point graduate who worked in the Department of Homeland Security during the Biden administration.
asserted
who → work → administration
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
