A group of six Quebec women who were denied employment insurance (EI) benefits after maternity leave have won their case at the Federal Court of Appeal, with a three-judge panel ruling that this practice is a Charter violation. The court found that withholding EI benefits from these women discriminated against them on the basis of sex and disproportionately affected women, as they are the primary caregivers during maternity and parental leaves. According to the lead attorney for the applicants, Sibel Ataogul, the law currently does not provide an extension for women on parental leave, allowing instead only for those detained in prison to receive benefits. The court has given the federal government 12 months to rewrite the EI Act to address this discriminatory practice.
Written by the local model on 2026-09-04,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
The Federal Court of Appeal has ruled in favour of a group of six Quebec women in a case that could help thousands of women denied employment benefits.
uncertain
that → rule → benefits
The women challenged the fact that they were denied employment insurance (EI) benefits when they lost their jobs shortly before, during or after maternity leave.
asserted
they → challenge → leave
The case was first brought forward in 2018.
asserted
case → bring → 2018
In a decision released Thursday, the three-judge panel said withholding EI benefits from these women was a violation of Section 15 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
asserted
withholding → release → Rights
That provision guarantees everyone equality under the law and equal benefit of the law, without discrimination.
asserted
provision → guarantee → discrimination
“One of the grounds listed in section 15 is sex, and it is well-established that discrimination based on pregnancy and motherhood is sex-based discrimination,” the judges wrote.
asserted
judges → list → pregnancy
Some of the women were denied benefits because they didn’t have enough insurable work hours, or had already reached the 50-week benefit limit.
asserted
they → deny → limit
“You need to have accumulated a certain amount of hours in the last year, but you won’t be able to accumulate those hours if you’re on mat leave,” Sibel Ataogul, the lead attorney for the applicants, explained.
asserted
Ataogul → need → applicants
She said the law allows for an extension for people detained in prison, but no similar extension currently exists for women on parental leave.
asserted
extension → say → leave
“On a more human level, it’s mind-boggling to me that this would still be an issue,” Ataogul said.
asserted
Ataogul → ’ → me
“It’s really a perpetuation of decades and decades of sexism.”
asserted
It → ’ → sexism
The court found that limiting the ability to stack EI benefits with maternal or parental benefits disproportionately affected women.
asserted
limiting → find → women
This is because women are the only ones who can accumulate maternity benefits, and make up a large proportion of parental benefit claims.
uncertain
who → accumulate → claims
“For on average nine years after you’ve had your child, you’re still suffering from the disadvantage in comparison to men who have children,” Ataogul said.
asserted
Ataogul → have → children
“So it was just a no-brainer to say, by denying women this benefit that they have the right to get because they were actually doing the labor of being at home, you’re perpetuating their disadvantageous position in society.
asserted
you → say → society
The women, represented by the advocacy group Mouvement Action Chômage, first won their case at the General Division of the Social Security Tribunal which ruled that excluding women from EI benefits during or following a mat leave resulted in gender-based discrimination.
asserted
excluding → represent → discrimination
That decision was contested by the Employment Insurance Commission and reversed by the Court of Appeal.
asserted
decision → contest → Appeal
The women went back to court in November 2025, at the Federal Court of Appeal, before receiving the news of their victory Wednesday.
asserted
women → go → victory
The judges struck down the discriminatory parts of the EI Act but suspended the declaration for one year.
asserted
judges → strike → year
That means the federal government has 12 months to rewrite the law.
asserted
government → mean → law
“We’re hoping that the Liberals will let this decision stand and not bring us to the Supreme Court and challenge a basic equality right,” Ataogul said.
asserted
Ataogul → hop → right
- Federal Tories launch ‘Conservatives for Canada’ campaign ahead of Alberta referendum
-
asserted
Tories → launch → referendum
Man charged with arson at Liberal MP’s Toronto home, 2nd suspect wanted
-
asserted
suspect → charge → home
N.S. Speaker scraps planned legislature bans just days before fall sitting begins
- 3.75% SGI rate hike approved in Saskatchewan, driven by rising repair costs
Celia Johnston, a mom in the Montreal area, said hearing the news was validating.
asserted
hearing → scrap → news
“It’s very validating for them to have recognized that it is discriminatory,” she told Global News.
asserted
she → ’ → News
“And I think that this can only bring forward some positive change and help address that gap.”
asserted
this → think → gap
Johnston was not a plaintiff in the case but she was also denied EI benefits when her job position dissolved while she was on mat leave in October 2025.
asserted
she → deny → October
“It was never very clear where my case sat,” she said.
asserted
she → sit → ?
“I felt very alone and frustrated because I truly didn’t understand what was happening.”
asserted
what → feel → ?
Johnston said she wasn’t aware of how many women had been impacted until it happened to her.
asserted
it → say → her
Since she’s spoken to many women in the same situation.
asserted
she → speak → situation
“They had shared with me that they were nervous and afraid to get pregnant again and to be put in this situation again.
asserted
they → share → situation
So I think knowing that this could be resolved, it removes that fear and that additional stressor that this could happen again,” she said.
uncertain
she → think → fear
“Nobody plans to have this happen to them, but to know that it could is scary.”
uncertain
it → plan → them
Johnston said she is in a better financial place now and would not expect any retroactive benefits, but continues to share her story to protect other women.
“For me, all I ever wanted was for this to change,” she said.
asserted
she → say → me
