Photo via ABC News (AU)

Neale the common thread in Fremantle and Brisbane's eerie shared history

Read the original at ABC News (AU) ↗
Cite

Silva, C. D. (2026, September 25). Neale the common thread in Fremantle and Brisbane's eerie shared history. ABC News (AU). https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-09-26/afl-grand-final-fremantle-brisbane-lachie-neale-history-analysis/107190640

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

ABC News (AU) · collected 2026-09-25 · by Chris De Silva

Quick Summary

Ross Lyon activated a substitute player named Lachie Neale during Fremantle's 2013 AFL grand final loss to Hawthorn. Thirteen years later, Neale now plays for Brisbane Lions as they face Fremantle again in the grand final. Both teams entered the league in the mid-90s during an expansion phase; Fremantle debuted in 1995 while Brisbane was formed from a merger of the Bears and Fitzroy Lions in 1996. Their histories intertwine with Fremantle's first win coming against Fitzroy, and Fitzroy’s last AFL victory being over Fremantle before their dissolution.
Written by AI on 2026-10-02, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

The 2026 AFL Grand Final between the Brisbane Lions and the Fremantle Dockers was marred by rain, with nearly 100,000 fans braving chilly temperatures around 12-14°C at the MCG in Melbourne. Despite the weather, the Lions managed to overcome the Dockers' early dominance, securing a victory. Fremantle's "Wharfie Time" strategy, activated near the end of the game, backfired, leading to speculation about its future use. The Dockers' loss may also be affected by the injury to Alex Pearce, a key defender.

Written for “AFL Grand Final Fremantle Loss” on 2026-11-18, grounded in this article and the 43 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

3 outlets covered “AFL Grand Final Fremantle Loss”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

ABC News (AU)This outlet25 Sep

Ross Lyon activated a substitute player named Lachie Neale during Fremantle's 2013 AFL grand final loss to Hawthorn. Thirteen years later, Neale now plays for Brisbane Lions as they face Fremantle again in the grand final. Both teams entered the league in the mid-90s during an expansion phase; Fremantle debuted in 1995 while Brisbane was formed from a merger of the Bears and Fitzroy Lions in 1996. Their histories…

Neale the common thread in Fremantle and Brisbane's eerie shared history (this article)24 articles from ABC News (AU) on this story
Sydney Morning Herald27 Sep

The article discusses how a recent AFL grand final gimmick called "Wharfie Time," involving the ringing of bells to signal a critical moment for Fremantle, backfired spectacularly and negatively impacted the team's morale and performance. The author compares this failure to other infamous sports marketing flops like the Adelaide Crows' "Power Stance." The article argues that the timing of the bell ringing coincided…

Wharfie Time must go the way of the power stance, the Batmobile and Meatloaf →16 articles from Sydney Morning Herald on this story
Daily Mail26 Sep

The AFL Grand Final between Fremantle Dockers and Brisbane Lions at the Melbourne Cricket Ground is expected to be affected by rain throughout much of the day. According to meteorologist David Crock, intermittent rainfall is forecasted with a total accumulation of about 2-8 mm, along with temperatures around 12-14°C. Despite the damp conditions, nearly 100,000 fans are expected to attend, and Brisbane’s Lachie Neale…

AFL Grand Final dealt bleak weather twist as rain looms over MCG showdown →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 3% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
The Sydney Morning Herald
Hedges 1 of 8 claims Outlet record 61/100
The Sydney Morning Herald
Hedges 3 of 40 claims Outlet record 61/100
ABC News (AU)
Hedges 0 of 3 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Both articles discuss multiple AFL match results involving various teams over several dates but do not focus on a single specific incident or game outcome. They provide lists of different matches and their scores, covering a range of events rather than one particular event.”
ABC News (AU)
Hedges 0 of 3 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Both articles discuss AFL game scores and Lachie Neale but cover different aspects of the season, not a single specific incident.”
The Sydney Morning Herald
Hedges 0 of 16 claims Outlet record 61/100
“Article A discusses Neale's suspension and Brisbane Lions' appeal plans for an upcoming grand final, while Article B is a historical recap of AFL matches involving Fremantle and Brisbane without mentioning the specific incident from Article A.”
ABC News (AU)
Hedges 0 of 2 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Both articles list match scores and dates but focus on different aspects (one on Neale's father's reaction to a ban, one on historical patterns involving Dockers and Lions), indicating they are not describing the same specific incident.”
ABC News (AU)
Hedges 0 of 3 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Both articles list AFL game scores and events but describe different aspects of the overall season rather than a single specific incident.”
ABC News (AU)
Hedges 0 of 41 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Article A describes live updates for Lachie Neale's appeal hearing, while Article B provides a summary of AFL match results and mentions Neale in a historical context.”
ABC News (AU)
Leans left Hedges 4 of 24 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Both articles list AFL match results and scores but cover different aspects and focus on distinct narratives, not a single incident.”
ABC News (AU)
Hedges 5 of 35 claims Outlet record 67/100
“Both articles list AFL game scores but focus on different aspects (one on a player's aspirations, the other on coaching connections), indicating they are not reporting the same specific incident.”

Story

AFL Grand Final Fremantle Loss
Sports · 44 article(s) covering the same event. See how they differ ↑
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
39
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
3%
1 of 39 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
67/100
ABC News (AU)'s corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
44
Sports
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-09-25 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

ABC News (AU) · 6016 article(s) · 11 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 11 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Chris De Silva
22 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
Publisher confirms 'adjustments' to Usman Khawaja's book tour after fiery TV interview In short: Usman Khawaja's publisher Penguin has confirmed that "adjustments" have been made to his book tour. Khawaja will continue to do interviews regarding his new book, Sabr, despite reports suggesting he had cancelled his book tour altogether. Cricket Australia is refusing to reopen its investigation into the 2018 ball-tampering incident despite the claims made in Khawaja's book.
Game not started, SLW versus AUW Sun, 20 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, PER versus HOB Mon, 21 Dec, 10:30 am, Game not started, TAW versus VIW Mon, 21 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, MES versus BRI Tue, 22 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, SYS versus MER Wed, 23 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, ADE versus SYT Thu, 24 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, MER versus HOB Sat, 26 Dec, 10:30 am, Game not started, AUS versus NZL Sat, 26 Dec, 6:05 pm, Game not started, SYS versus BRI Sat, 26 Dec, 9:15 pm, Game not started, PER versus MES Sun, 27 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, SYT versus MER Mon, 28 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, BRI versus ADE Tue, 29 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, HOB versus MES Wed, 30 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, PER versus SYT Thu, 31 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, ADE versus MES Fri, 1 Jan 2027, 4:00 pm, Game not started, MER versus SYS Fri, 1 Jan 2027, 7:15 pm, Game not started, BRI versus HOB Sat, 2 Jan 2027, 7:15 pm, Game not started, SYT versus PER Sun, 3 Jan 2027, 7:15 pm, Game not started, SYS versus ADE Mon, 4 Jan 2027, 10:30 am, Game not started, AUS versus NZL Mon, 4 Jan 2027, 10:30 am, Game not started, QUW versus ACM Mon, 4 Jan 2027, 6:05 pm, Game not started, MES versus MER Mon, 4 Jan 2027, 9:15 pm, Game not started, PER versus BRI Tue, 5 Jan 2027, 7:15 pm, Game not started, HOB versus SYT Wed, 6 Jan 2027, 10:30 am, Game not started, QUW versus ACM Wed, 6 Jan 2027, 7:15 pm, Game not started, ADE versus MER Thu, 7 Jan 2027, 7:15 pm, Game not started, MES versus SYS Fri, 8 Jan 2027, 5:00 pm, Game not started, WAW versus VIW Fri, 8 Jan 2027, 7:15 pm, Game not started, BRI versus PER Sat, 9 Jan 2027, 10:30 am, Game not started, TAW versus SYW Sat, 9 Jan 2027, 7:15 pm, Game not started, HOB versus ADE Cricket Australia chief Todd Greenberg says there be no new Sandpapergate investigation In short: Cricket Australia chief Todd Greenberg says there will not be another investigation into the 2018 Sandpapergate scandal. Usman Khawaja has claimed in his book, Sabr, which is released today, that the entire team knew about the ball-tampering. In his book, Khawaja says the team started using sandpaper on the ball in the Test prior to the match in Cape Town, where Bancroft was caught on camera tampering with the ball.
AUS versus ENG Thu, 3 Dec, 10:30 am, Game not started, NSW versus WAU Thu, 3 Dec, 10:30 am, Game not started, VIC versus QUE Thu, 3 Dec, 11:00 am, Game not started, SAM versus TAS Thu, 3 Dec, 7:10 pm, Game not started, versus Sat, 5 Dec, 7:10 pm, Game not started, versus Wed, 9 Dec, 1:20 pm, Game not started, AUS versus NZL Sat, 12 Dec, 8:10 pm, Game not started, MER versus PER Mon, 14 Dec, 11:00 am, Game not started, SAS versus WAW Tue, 15 Dec, 10:00 am, Game not started, ACM versus SYW Tue, 15 Dec, 3:00 pm, Game not started, SLW versus AUW Tue, 15 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, BRI versus SYS Wed, 16 Dec, 11:00 am, Game not started, SAS versus WAW Wed, 16 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, SYT versus ADE Thu, 17 Dec, 10:00 am, Game not started, ACM versus SYW Thu, 17 Dec, 11:30 am, Game not started, AUS versus NZL Thu, 17 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, HOB versus BRI Fri, 18 Dec, 3:00 pm, Game not started, SLW versus AUW Fri, 18 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, MES versus ADE Sat, 19 Dec, 10:30 am, Game not started, TAW versus VIW Sat, 19 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, SYT versus SYS Sun, 20 Dec, 3:00 pm, Game not started, SLW versus AUW Sun, 20 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, PER versus HOB Mon, 21 Dec, 10:30 am, Game not started, TAW versus VIW Mon, 21 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, MES versus BRI Tue, 22 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, SYS versus MER Wed, 23 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, ADE versus SYT Thu, 24 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, MER versus HOB Sat, 26 Dec, 10:30 am, Game not started, AUS versus NZL Sat, 26 Dec, 6:05 pm, Game not started, SYS versus BRI Sat, 26 Dec, 9:15 pm, Game not started, PER versus MES Sun, 27 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, SYT versus MER Mon, 28 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, BRI versus ADE Tue, 29 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, HOB versus MES Wed, 30 Dec, 7:15 pm, Game not started, PER versus SYT live Live updates: South Africa vs Australia, third Test, day five from Newlands, Cape Town Australia looks to chase down 288 runs to win the third Test against South Africa in Cape Town, with series honours on the line. Follow all the action in our live blog, check out the stats in our match Scorecard and ScoreCentre, and tune in to our live radio coverage. Submit a comment or question Live updates What happened yesterday? There were plenty around the traps who thought that, perhaps, the Test would be finished yesterday.
If Kez [Carey] and I could have added another 50, that would have been really nice.
New: Filters Choose what information you see below by using filters Some advice for Head and Renshaw Hi Chris, it would be an understatement to say I'm a bit fidgety waiting for the Aussies start batting.
Key Event Richmond secures trade for Port Adelaide's pick five The Tigers have been considered the front-runner for this pick for the past few days, and the deal will go through this afternoon.
New: Filters Choose what information you see below by using filters Who could Sydney use to replace Blakey?
The latest from AFL.com.au's Cal Twomey is the Suns will meet with Nick Blakey this morning as both parties investigate a potential trade.
The reporting around this suggested Marshall didn't feel comfortable being there considering his desire to leave the club, but you could also read this as him making a statement to the Saints and trying to force their hand a little.
, some clutching their jerseys in disbelief, others simply looking into any space possible that meant they could avoid eye contact.
Also by Chris De Silva
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 22 articles by Chris De Silva →

Topics

AFL Brisbane Dockers Fremantle Lions

Subjects

Fremantle GPE · 17× AFL ORG · 8× Brisbane GPE · 8× Dockers ORG · 7× Lions ORG · 7× Neale PERSON · 5× Hawthorn GPE · 3× Cats ORG · 2× Hawks ORG · 2× Swans ORG · 2×

Narrative

Leigh Matthews's arrival as Brisbane's coach at the end of 1999 immediately turned the Lions into a force to be reckoned with. Matthews masterminded Brisbane to three straight premierships and four straight grand final appearances between 2001 and 2004 before his departure and the aging of that era of Brisbane players left the club in AFL purgatory for the best part of 15 years. Fremantle had to wait until its ninth season in the AFL to make a finals appearance, and then had to wait another three seasons before it won a final.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-09-25
→ When Fremantle coach Ross Lyon activated his sub in the fourth quarter of the 2013 grand final against Hawthorn, he scarcely could have believed the impact that player was going to have.
2026-09-25 · ABC News (AU)
Neale the common thread in Fremantle and Brisbane's eerie shared history · assertive framing

Claims (39 extracted, 1 hedged)

→ When Fremantle coach Ross Lyon activated his sub in the fourth quarter of the 2013 grand final against Hawthorn, he scarcely could have believed the impact that player was going to have. uncertain
player → activate → impact
On the odd occasion, the sub would come in and make a serious impact, acting as a spark plug, while on other days, their impact would be negligible. asserted
impact → come → days
Fremantle's sub that day came on to replace ruckman Zac Clarke and picked up seven disposals, but it was ultimately in vain as an experienced Hawthorn side held the Dockers at bay. asserted
side → come → bay
Neale, then 20, would not have believed that he would have to wait 13 years to see the Dockers in another grand final. He also would not have believed he'd be playing against them in Brisbane colours, looking for a third straight premiership. asserted
he → believe → premiership
It is funny how time works. asserted
time → work → ?
Fremantle and the Brisbane Lions both entered the AFL in the mid 90s as the league was undergoing an expansion boom into states outside of Victoria. asserted
league → enter → Victoria
Brisbane's entry occurred as the Bears back in 1987 alongside Fremantle's WA rivals West Coast, and while the Eagles found themselves in a grand final within four years and holding the premiership cup within five, the Bears struggled. asserted
Bears → occur → five
The Lions were eventually formed in 1996 when the Bears merged with the Fitzroy Lions, another club that had been haemorrhaging money for years. asserted
that → form → years
West Coast's success saw the AFL expand further into WA with Fremantle chosen as the state's second team with its inaugural season played in 1995. asserted
season → see → 1995
It is somewhat poetic that the Dockers and Lions are playing against each other in this year's grand final when you consider how closely they are tied together right at the inception of both clubs. asserted
they → play → clubs
Fremantle's first ever win in the AFL came against the Fitzroy Lions in round 3, 1995, while Fitzroy's last ever AFL win came against Fremantle in round 8, 1996. asserted
win → come → round
Fitzroy's last ever AFL game? You guessed it, against Fremantle in Perth in round 22 of the 1996 season. asserted
You → guess → season
Over the three decades that have followed, both Fremantle and Brisbane have had periods of dominance, but never really at the same time until recent years. asserted
Fremantle → follow → years
Leigh Matthews's arrival as Brisbane's coach at the end of 1999 immediately turned the Lions into a force to be reckoned with. Matthews masterminded Brisbane to three straight premierships and four straight grand final appearances between 2001 and 2004 before his departure and the aging of that era of Brisbane players left the club in AFL purgatory for the best part of 15 years. Fremantle had to wait until its ninth season in the AFL to make a finals appearance, and then had to wait another three seasons before it won a final. asserted
it → turn → final
Since 2000, Brisbane has made the finals on 14 occasions, while Fremantle has registered 10 post-season trips, yet Brisbane has five premierships to Fremantle's zero. asserted
Brisbane → make → zero
And tying them together through the last 13 years has been Neale, once the best midfielder for both clubs asserted
Neale → tie → clubs
Neale was drafted 58th overall by Fremantle in the 2011 draft. asserted
Neale → draft → draft
The three players selected before him — Tom Sheridan, Hayden Crozier and Alex Forster — played a combined 226 games. asserted
players → select → games
His arrival coincided with Fremantle's first real period of contention under Lyon in the early 2010s. asserted
arrival → coincide → 2010s
In Neale's first four seasons, Fremantle won the third-most home and away games in the AFL behind Hawthorn and Sydney. asserted
Fremantle → win → Hawthorn
In that period, the Hawks won three premierships and played in four grand finals, while the Swans played in two grand finals and won one. asserted
Swans → win → one
Fremantle came away with the one unsuccessful grand final appearance. asserted
Fremantle → come → appearance
While Fremantle was knocking on the door of its first premiership, Brisbane was going through one of the worst periods of its existence. asserted
Brisbane → knock → existence
By 2012, Neale's debut season, just two of Brisbane's triple premiership-winning players — Simon Black and Jonathan Brown — remained on its list. asserted
two → win → list
Memories of Brisbane being one of the AFL's most feared sides were disappearing fast and players on the list originally from outside Queensland wanted to be anywhere but at the club. asserted
players → fear → club
Even Brisbane's logo on its jumper had changed, going from the traditional Fitzroy passant lion to a lion with a front-facing head, infamously nicknamed 'The Paddle Pop Lion'. asserted
logo → change → head
Fremantle won the first minor premiership in club history in 2015, with Neale becoming one of its most indispensable players, but the Dockers were again denied by Hawthorn, this time in a home preliminary final. asserted
Dockers → win → final
The Dockers cratered spectacularly the following season, dropping from first to third-last, and would not make it back to the finals for another seven seasons. asserted
Dockers → cratere → seasons
In dire need of some stability, Brisbane turned to one of the figureheads behind Hawthorn's triple premiership dynasty, Chris Fagan, to be its head coach. asserted
Brisbane → turn → dynasty
The Lions struggled in Fagan's first two seasons in charge, but Neale had seen the vision and requested a trade to the then-cellar dwellers. asserted
Neale → struggle → dwellers
Had Fremantle known what he was about to become, they'd have asked for double what they received in return for him from Brisbane. asserted
they → know → Brisbane
Neale's move to Brisbane put him up in lights on Broadway. asserted
move → put → Broadway
The All-Australian jackets, the Brownlow Medal wins and eventually premierships all arrived, leaving him with a resume that undoubtedly has him in the conversation as one of the best players of his generation. asserted
him → arrive → generation
His departure from Fremantle, which looked like someone getting the last life raft out of a sinking ship, proved to be a pivotal moment in the Dockers' trajectory to the grand final as well. asserted
someone → look → final
The following year's draft proved to be a watershed moment for Fremantle, as it supercharged its rebuild with the selections of Hayden Young and Caleb Serong. asserted
it → prove → Young
Having seen Brisbane supplement its young core with shrewd recruitment of seasoned players such as Neale, Charlie Cameron, Josh Dunkley and others, Fremantle has done the same, adding Luke Jackson and Shai Bolton. asserted
Fremantle → see → Jackson
For both clubs, the addition of star talent from rival clubs has resulted in an immediate uptick in on-field fortunes. asserted
addition → result → fortunes
All of it leads us here, to two teams inextricably linked from their inceptions and still connected by one man. asserted
All → lead → man
Now that he has been freed to play, don't be surprised if that one man, Lachie Neale, has a big say in who holds the premiership cup. asserted
who → free → cup
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support