Claims extracted
16
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
6%
1 of 16 hedged
("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
70/100
Daily Mail's corrections and
hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
2
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
- See more Daily Mail on Google - save us as a Preferred Source
An MSP who was ridiculed last week for asking whether government agency Transport Scotland was a charity has blamed her blunder on a chest infection.
asserted
Scotland → see → infection
Collette Stevenson’s gaffe was embarrassingly exposed during a televised meeting of Holyrood’s Transport Committee, of which she is a member.
asserted
she → expose → which
But now the SNP politician claims it was due to being ‘in the early stages’ of a chest infection which affected her concentration.
uncertain
which → claim → concentration
In a social media post on Thursday, she said she had followed medical advice to stay away from Parliament for a week to recover and branded some of the criticism of her as ‘misogynistic bullying’.
asserted
she → say → bullying
Ms Stevenson – who has been an MSP for five years – faced mockery following her exchange with Transport Scotland director Graeme Cook as he gave evidence to the committee.
asserted
he → face → committee
She asked him: ‘I take it Transport Scotland is a registered charity?’
asserted
Scotland → ask → it
Collette Stevenson has broken her silence on the backlash to her Transport Scotland blunder
Leaving her looking confused, Mr Cook responded: ‘Transport Scotland is a non-departmental government body.
asserted
Scotland → break → her
Ms Stevenson’s discomfort sparked a rash of online barbs, imagining her believing that the Kingston Bridge linked Scotland with Jamaica and that the Glasgow Subway is a sandwich shop.
asserted
Subway → spark → Jamaica
But on Thursday she broke her silence.
asserted
she → break → silence
Writing on Facebook, she said: ‘During a recent committee evidence session, I experienced a momentary lapse in my questioning regarding the status of Transport Scotland.
asserted
I → write → Scotland
I was in the early stages of a severe chest infection, which affected my sleep and, in turn, my concentration.
asserted
which → affect → turn
‘On medical advice, and following a flare-up of asthma, I have taken this week off from Parliament to recuperate and allow the various medications to work.’
asserted
medications → follow → Parliament
She added: ‘As MSP for East Kilbride, I of course engage regularly and constructively with Transport Scotland – most notably and recently on the vital East Kilbride rail enhancement and electrification project.
asserted
I → add → project
‘Whilst robust scrutiny is a necessary part of public life, the disproportionate abuse, mockery, and misogynistic bullying directed at me online following an honest mistake demonstrates the toxic culture women in politics still have to endure far too often.’
asserted
women → direct → politics
Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn told MSPs he didn’t know about a leak of flammable gas from a CalMac ferry because he missed the news as he was ‘FaceTiming my kids’.
asserted
he → tell → kids
And Rural Affairs Secretary Gillian Martin didn’t realise that the government owns 10 per cent of crofting land.
asserted
government → realise → land