A New York kitten rescue is facing backlash after posting that MAGA supporters and conservatives are not welcome to adopt its animals.
asserted
supporters → face → animals
‘I’m not political’?
asserted
I → ’m → ?
Still nope,” Itty Bitty City Kitties wrote on Facebook alongside an image of a kitten carrying the message, “NO.
asserted
Kitties → write → message
Itty Bitty City Kitties describes itself as a 501(c)(3) nonprofit kitten rescue, welfare, and adoption organization based in New York’s Rockaway Beach.
asserted
Kitties → describe → Beach
“Our Mission is saving the tiniest of orphan felines, neonatal infant kittens, helping them to grow and thrive,” the organization said on its website.
asserted
organization → save → website
Asked by the Washington Examiner whether a kitten could thrive in the home of a conservative, rescue director Samantha Knox said the organization considers an applicant’s conduct and character.
uncertain
organization → ask → conduct
“When an individual publicly promotes, encourages, or celebrates cruelty toward human beings, it raises legitimate concerns regarding their fundamental capacity for empathy toward any vulnerable living creature,” Knox said.
asserted
Knox → promote → creature
“We evaluate applicants based on individual character and observable conduct.”
asserted
We → evaluate → character
“If your politics involve racism, bigotry, dehumanizing immigrants, or cheering on cruelty toward vulnerable people, please kindly f*** right off,” one post said.
asserted
post → involve → people
In another post, the organization wrote, “Applications are open for people whose values align with ours, and yes, references will be checked to make sure you’re not a racist piece of s***.”
asserted
you → write → *
The kitten featured in the original post is 7-week-old Tamogotchi, who was rescued along with 10 other kittens after they were abandoned without food or water, according to Knox.
uncertain
they → feature → Knox
Knox said the organization does not review private voting records or ask applicants about their political party registration.
asserted
organization → say → registration
However, it does review applicants’ social media activity.
asserted
it → review → activity
If an applicant’s public activity demonstrates “rhetoric or actions that celebrate, promote, or encourage cruelty, discrimination, or harm against human beings or animals,” Knox said, the application will not be considered.
asserted
application → demonstrate → beings
Knox also argued that the organization can consider political affiliation in its adoption decisions because it is not a protected class under federal public accommodation statutes.
asserted
it → argue → statutes
She said the organization establishes eligibility standards based on “applicant conduct, character, and demonstrated empathy to ensure animal safety.”
asserted
organization → say → safety
The Washington Examiner asked Knox whether an applicant with a clean background check and no history of animal abuse or neglect would be considered a safe home, regardless of political affiliation.
asserted
applicant → ask → affiliation
“Where there is clear, documented evidence of public conduct or statements celebrating violence, hostility, or cruelty, that behavior directly factors into our assessment of whether the home is safe and suitable for a fragile animal,” Knox responded.
asserted
Knox → be → animal
People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals disagreed with the rescue’s approach.
asserted
People → disagree → approach
“There is a homeless kitten crisis, and to bar people from providing a loving home because their political views aren’t yours is as outrageous as saying no to someone because they are Jewish or Buddhist or from Lithuania,” PETA founder Ingrid Newkirk told the Washington Examiner.
asserted
Newkirk → be → Examiner
“The only relevant factor is do they have the time, patience, money for veterinary care (which can be expensive) and love in their heart for that kitten (preferably for two so the kittens can keep each other company).”
asserted
kittens → have → company
Knox said any online claims that PETA has the ability to shut the organization down are unfounded.
uncertain
PETA → say → organization
Backlash follows Facebook post
asserted
Backlash → follow → post
The rescue said it has received an onslaught of hostile messages following its posts, including threats, profanity, and racial and anti-LGBT slurs.
asserted
it → say → threats
On Wednesday, Itty Bitty City Kitties posted screenshots of more than a dozen direct messages it said it had received.
asserted
it → post → messages
“MAGA is having an epic crash out over our simple adoption policy: I do not adopt vulnerable kittens to humans who condone cruelty,” the rescue wrote.
asserted
rescue → have → cruelty
Some messages came from people identifying themselves as Trump voters or conservatives who said they loved cats or had previously adopted animals from the rescue.
asserted
they → come → rescue
Other messages contained explicit racial and anti-LGBT slurs.
asserted
messages → contain → slurs
The rescue responded to the messages in another Facebook post Thursday, describing some of the commenters as “unhinged.”
“Imagine having to work alongside someone like that every day,” the organization wrote.
asserted
organization → respond → that
Do these people work with vulnerable humans?
asserted
people → work → humans
I shudder to think.”
asserted
I → shudder → ?
Other commenters objected to the adoption policy and argued that political views should have no bearing on whether someone can provide an appropriate home for an animal.
asserted
someone → object → animal
“I have cared for many animals over the years,” one commenter wrote.
asserted
commenter → care → years
“I have three cats who are well fed, loved and [treated] like part of our family, which they are.
asserted
they → have → family
I’m also conservative, Republican, gun owner, white male, heterosexual and a loving grandfather.
asserted
I → ’m → ?
Rescue has history of political posts
The adoption controversy is not the first time Itty Bitty City Kitties has used its social media accounts to comment on politics.
asserted
Kitties → use → politics
On July 12, the rescue posted a photograph on Facebook stating, “The best way to wake up on a Sunday is finding out Lindsey Graham is dead.
asserted
Graham → post → Sunday
”
“Not the hateful white f***bag I wish was dead, but I’ll take it for now,” the accompanying caption said, apparently referring to President Donald Trump.
asserted
caption → wish → Trump
The rescue has also posted criticism of Immigration and Customs Enforcement and weighed in on the controversy involving Macklemore and Ed Sheeran.
asserted
rescue → post → Macklemore
Despite the backlash, Knox said the rescue has experienced an increase in donations and volunteer sign-ups from people who “align with our commitment to strict safety and care standards.”
asserted
who → say → standards
The Aporia
