The Trump administration is ratcheting up its fight to get more crude flowing through California and reverse the state's efforts to move away from fossil fuels.
asserted
crude → ratchet → fuels
Its latest salvo is a federal review of California's coastal management program, which is run largely by a state commission that has had a powerful role for decades in shaping development along the coast.
asserted
that → run → coast
Environmental advocates fear federal officials could use the review to strip the California Coastal Commission of its ability to have a say in projects involving federal agencies that affect the state's rugged coastal bluffs, pristine beaches and world-class surfing spots.
uncertain
that → fear → bluffs
The administration, citing a need for energy security and job creation, has already announced plans for new offshore oil leases in California as well as Florida, where the federal government has not allowed drilling since 1995 because of concerns about oil spills in the Gulf of Mexico.
asserted
government → cite → Mexico
Trump officials also helped a Texas firm jump-start an old pipeline system that had been idled since its 2015 rupture caused one of California’s worst oil spills, blackening beaches for 150 miles (240 kilometers) from Santa Barbara to Los Angeles and polluting habitat for endangered whales and sea turtles.
asserted
rupture → help → whales
Federal officials also recently took a step toward authorizing fracking on an old oil platform 9 miles (14 kilometers) off Ventura County — a move opposed by the state’s coastal commission.
asserted
officials → take → commission
“It's just part of that overall belief that they have, that they're going to get rid of renewables and go back to good old-fashioned fossil fuels, and what better place to start than California?” said Deborah A. Sivas, a professor of environmental law at Stanford Law School.
asserted
Sivas → have → School
“We're the feds — we're going to tell the state what to do.”
asserted
we → go → what
California has some working offshore rigs, but there has been no new oil leasing in federal waters since the mid-1980s and no new state leasing for even longer.
asserted
California → have → mid-1980s
The state barred new offshore oil leases after a catastrophic spill in 1969 spewed between 3.5 million and 4.2 million gallons of crude into the Santa Barbara Channel.
asserted
spill → bar → Channel
The disaster killed thousands of seabirds and helped give rise to the modern environmental movement.
asserted
disaster → kill → movement
California now uses so much solar and wind energy that nearly half the state's electricity came from renewable resources in 2024, according to the state's energy commission.
uncertain
electricity → use → commission
Last week, state officials sued the federal government over its buyback of an offshore wind lease aimed at discouraging the expansion of wind energy in favor of fossil fuels.
asserted
officials → sue → fuels
California has also tried to wean residents off gas-powered cars — another push opposed by the Trump administration.
asserted
California → try → administration
California's coastal commission, an independent agency with appointed members, was formed in 1972.
asserted
commission → appoint → 1972
It has often been in the spotlight for taking up high-profile projects on the state's tourism-dependent coast.
asserted
It → take → coast
The panel voted against but later approved a U2 guitarist's plan for mansions on seaside bluffs, though the building proposal was eventually nixed by a court.
asserted
proposal → vote → court
It also rejected a proposed desalination plant to create drinking water in Huntington Beach.
asserted
It → reject → Beach
The commission also has a say in federal projects along California's coast, in line with a 1972 federal coastal management law.
asserted
commission → have → law
More than 30 states have similar programs to protect their coastal resources and all are subject to periodic federal evaluation.
asserted
all → have → evaluation
Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick announced the unexpected review of California’s program in May while denouncing the commission’s opposition to an expanded launch schedule for SpaceX’s Falcon 9 rockets from Vandenberg Space Force Base.
uncertain
Lutnick → announce → Base
Commissioners cited concerns that more launches could harm sensitive species and limit public access to the coast.
uncertain
launches → cite → coast
“Obstructionist policies that delay critical national infrastructure in the name of environmental extremism are unacceptable,” Lutnick said.
asserted
Lutnick → delay → extremism
He said the review will examine how California has addressed federal priorities on spaceport infrastructure, offshore oil production, pipeline maintenance and desalination projects.
asserted
California → say → infrastructure
Targeting California raises a fight that could reverberate nationwide, experts say.
uncertain
experts → target → fight
Until now, no state with a coastal program has been stripped of its authority to review federal projects.
asserted
state → strip → projects
Many Californians who spoke at an hourslong public hearing in Santa Monica in August said they don’t want their state to be the first.
asserted
state → speak → August
This is about power,” said Maureen Ellenberger, a Santa Barbara resident who is upset about the decision to let Houston-based Sable Offshore Corp. resume pumping through the old pipeline.
asserted
Corp. → say → pipeline
“It’s about whether the Trump administration can strip California’s authority because they don’t like the answers the coastal commission gave to oil companies.”
asserted
commission → ’ → companies
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration is carrying out the review.
asserted
Oceanic → carry → review
It isn't known when it will be completed.
asserted
it → know → ?
The commission isn't new to controversy
In the past, California's coastal commission has clashed with elected officials from both political parties.
asserted
commission → clash → parties
Democratic Gov. Gavin Newsom rushed to the commission's defense this year, but in 2025 suspended its permitting requirements for home rebuilding following the devastating Los Angeles area wildfires.
asserted
Newsom → rush → wildfires
Trump's battles with the commission began before his first term when he put up a 70-foot (21-meter) flagpole on his golf club in Rancho Palos Verdes.
asserted
he → begin → Verdes
The commission ultimately allowed for it after a lengthy battle.
asserted
commission → allow → battle
Last month, the commission unanimously voted to oppose the plan for fracking on a 45-year-old platform in federal waters off Ventura County after a lengthy public hearing.
asserted
commission → vote → hearing
The federal Bureau of Ocean Energy Management released an environmental analysis for the proposal, which energy company DCOR said would more than triple daily oil output in 16 wells from 1,100 barrels to 4,000 barrels.
asserted
DCOR → release → barrels
“This is just simply one of those cases where the juice isn’t worth the squeeze,” Coastal Commissioner Ray Jackson said during a hearing on DCOR LLC's plan.
asserted
Jackson → say → plan
“It creates far too many opportunities for something to go wrong.
asserted
something → create → opportunities
When something does go wrong it is our ocean, beaches, wildlife and coastal economy that pay the price.”
asserted
that → go → price
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
