Reverend Babs Miller, a minister at St Andrew’s Presbyterian Church in Texas where Democratic Senate candidate James Talarico worships, has made controversial statements questioning fundamental Christian beliefs such as the existence of Jesus and the Virgin Birth. In an undercover interview with The Daily Wire, Miller dismissed traditional teachings about Jesus’ death and doubted his historical existence, comparing it to debates over Buddha's existence. Additionally, she questioned the concept of God sacrificing Jesus for humanity’s sins and suggested that Christianity itself might be a human invention.
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-09-24,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Story summary
James Talarico's lesbian minister at St Andrew's Presbyterian Church in Texas has raised significant doubts about core Christian beliefs. Reverend Babs Miller, who knows Talarico from his childhood and served as a reference for him when he entered seminary, has questioned the historical existence of Jesus and the concept of the Virgin Birth. In 2014, she was ordained and now lists herself as 'Minister to the Parish' on the church's site. Miller argues that Jesus' historical presence is "ultimately unimportant" and dismisses traditional teachings about his death for sins, stating he died due to political reasons rather than divine purpose. She also expresses uncertainty about whether Jesus ever existed, suggesting these beliefs may be purely mythical or invented.
Written for “Religious Controversy Over Minister's…” on 2026-10-05,
grounded in this article and the 0 other(s) covering the same event.
- Sign up HERE to our DC Insider newsletter - your guide to what's rocking Washington, rattling the White House and setting tongues wagging on the Hill
James Talarico's lesbian minister at his Texas church has cast doubt on some of Christianity's most fundamental beliefs, including whether Jesus ever existed.
Reverend Babs Miller, a minister at St Andrew's Presbyterian Church, attended by the Texas Democratic Senate candidate, has made a series of provocative comments about core Christian beliefs.
asserted
Miller → sign → beliefs
In undercover footage recorded by the Daily Wire, Miller questioned traditional Christian teachings about Jesus' death and the Virgin Birth.
asserted
Miller → record → death
Miller dismissed the traditional Christian teaching that he died for our sins.
asserted
he → dismiss → sins
Jesus was put on that cross not to save us, they killed him.
asserted
they → put → him
He didn't die to save our sins,' she said matter-of-factly.
asserted
she → die → sins
She likewise rejected the idea that God sacrificed Jesus for mankind, saying she found the traditional explanation difficult to accept.
asserted
explanation → reject → mankind
Miller also questioned the biblical account of the Virgin Birth, suggesting that the story was influenced by ancient pagan traditions.
asserted
story → question → traditions
More strikingly, she expressed uncertainty about whether Jesus even existed at all, comparing the question to debates over the historical existence of Buddha.
asserted
Jesus → express → Buddha
Talarico's minister, Reverend Babs Miller at St. Andrew's Presbyterian Church refers to herself as an 'out chaplain lesbian,' in the church's website bio.
asserted
minister → refer → bio
She was ordained in the church in 2014 and is photographed in an unconventional rainbow pride stole
Talarico has frequently invoked the teachings of Jesus in speeches and sermons, particularly when discussing poverty, immigration, abortion, LGBTQ rights and the separation of church and state
In 2021 while arguing against restrictions on transgender students he said, 'Modern science obviously recognizes that there are many more than two biological sexes; in fact, there are six'
Miller has publicly stated she knows Talarico from his childhood and was influential in his development.
A Texas Tribune report said Miller served as one of Talarico's references for seminary.
Miller argued Jesus's historical existence was 'ultimately unimportant,' calling the vengeful God of parts of the Old Testament pure mythology - and went further, suggesting Christianity itself may have been invented outright.
She was ordained in 2014, lists herself as 'Minister to the Parish' on the church's site, and calls herself an 'out chaplain lesbian,' posing in a rainbow pride stole.
uncertain
She → ordain → stole
The controversy adds to scrutiny of Talarico, a professed Christian studying at Austin Presbyterian Theological Seminary who hopes to become a minister.
asserted
who → add → Seminary
He regularly cites Jesus's teachings on poverty, immigration, abortion, LGBTQ rights and church-state separation, and has drawn conservative fire before, notably declaring 'God is nonbinary' on the House floor in 2021 while opposing restrictions on transgender students.
asserted
God → cite → students
That same year while fighting for transgender students he said, 'Modern science obviously recognizes that there are many more than two biological sexes in fact, there are six.'
asserted
science → fight → fact
Republicans have repeatedly highlighted the shorter quotes while arguing that Talarico rejects traditional Christian doctrine.
asserted
Talarico → highlight → doctrine
Those remarks have now become a central weapon in Republican attacks against him.
asserted
remarks → become → him
Talarico's opponent, Attorney General Ken Paxton and other Republicans have repeatedly focused on Talarico's theology in speeches and campaign advertising, portraying his views as evidence that he is hostile to traditional Christianity.
asserted
he → focus → Christianity
A spokesperson for Paxton's campaign told the Daily Mail, 'His own church has called our Lord and Savior a social justice warrior and can't even declare He existed.
asserted
He → tell → Lord
What else would you expect from the man who bills himself as 'a Christian who hates Christianity'?'
asserted
who → expect → Christianity
One recent Paxton advertisement went so far as to use AI-generated imagery and stitched-together excerpts of Talarico's past comments, including his 'God is nonbinary' remark.
asserted
God → go → remark
Miller discussed Talarico's political evolution in separate footage.
asserted
Miller → discuss → footage
'I can guarantee you that once he gets elected, he'll change his tune back to where he was.'
asserted
he → guarantee → tune
Talarico's campaign did not respond to the Daily Mail's request for comment.
asserted
campaign → respond → comment
The Aporia
