Former Biden White House COVID-19 Response Coordinator Dr. Ashish Jha revealed in a Sunday interview on CNN that he believes COVID-19 was likely caused by a lab leak.
asserted
COVID-19 → reveal → leak
During the interview with CNN's Dana Bash, she highlighted how Jha had retweeted commentator Jamie Metzl’s lengthy social media post saying he believed COVID-19 originated from a lab leak at the Wuhan Institute of Virology.
asserted
COVID-19 → highlight → Virology
While the lab leak theory was widely disputed early in the pandemic and some social media platforms restricted certain related claims under their COVID-19 misinformation policies, Jha responded by declaring in 2026, "I pretty much agree with everything here."
uncertain
I → dispute → everything
After Bash highlighted the tweet, he confirmed he agreed with it — marking a change from the initial beliefs he held upon when first entering the Biden administration.
asserted
he → highlight → administration
"This is going to surprise some people.
asserted
This → go → people
You know, when I went into the White House, my view was, ‘This was almost surely a natural outbreak, maybe a lab leak,’" he said.
asserted
he → know → House
"Based on information I learned and based on information I‘ve seen, I have come to conclude that it is more likely to have been a lab leak."
asserted
it → base → information
"Here‘s the bottom line.
asserted
line → here‘ → ?
No one in the United States knows for sure.
asserted
one → know → States
The only people who know for sure are people — officials in China — and we still need transparency and accountability on that.
asserted
we → know → that
I‘m not suggesting I know for sure, but I‘m saying my best assessment is that it probably was a lab leak
asserted
it → suggest → ?
," he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
"That is definitely news to hear that from you for sure," Bash replied.
asserted
Bash → hear → you
"And shows that we‘re just, we‘re still learning, which is really important."
asserted
which → show → ?
Jha later posted a clip of his conversation with Bash to his X account, with the following message:
asserted
Jha → post → message
"My view on COVID origins isn't new — I've held it since my time at the White House," he wrote.
asserted
he → hold → House
"Here's the truth: no one in America knows for sure.
asserted
one → know → America
Anyone telling you they do is selling you something
asserted
they → tell → something
Based on strong circumstantial evidence I've seen, I think lab leak is much more likely.
asserted
leak → base → evidence
Accidental Reasonable people can look at the same evidence and disagree."
The COVID-19 pandemic caused a crisis of credibility across institutions regarding how they spoke to the public and how much they in turn allowed the public or even fellow members of the media to speak.
asserted
public → look → media
While the lab leak theory is more commonly accepted today as a plausible theory, many initially theorized that the pandemic occurred through natural transmission, such as from a Chinese wet market.
asserted
pandemic → accept → market
Many news organizations, like CNN, MS NOW, The New York Times and The Washington Post, dismissed the lab leak theory as a "debunked" conspiracy theory before uncovering the facts, and watchdogs in the years since have suggested this hurt the media’s already struggling credibility.
uncertain
this → dismiss → credibility
A prominent example of this was taxpayer-funded NPR.
asserted
example → fund → this
In April of 2020, NPR ran pieces on back-to-back days dismissing the lab leak notion, painting it as a debunked conspiracy theory embraced by the right for political purposes.
asserted
NPR → run → purposes
One such story was headlined, "Scientists Debunk Lab Accident Theory of Pandemic Emergence," and misled readers into thinking the lab leak theory was truly discredited.
asserted
theory → headline → readers
CNN was criticized for incidents such as publishing a report that boasted of the country's coronavirus vaccination rates, according to data provided by China.
uncertain
that → criticize → China
Another salient example, however, was a piece released by the network actually touting China’s authoritarian government as ideal for cracking down on a pandemic.
asserted
example → release → pandemic
"For those still reluctant, China has a powerful tool in its arsenal: a top-down, one-party system that is all-encompassing in reach and forceful in action, and a sprawling bureaucracy that can be swiftly mobilized," two CNN journalists based in Hong Kong wrote.
asserted
journalists → have → Kong
"The top-down approach has been touted by officials as a strength of the Chinese system that helped curb the virus – and has again been deployed to accelerate inoculations."
asserted
that → tout → inoculations
The Biden administration was sued in a high profile First Amendment case after it worked around the First Amendment by pressuring social media companies to censor Americans questioning the narratives about the COVID-19 pandemic on its behalf.
asserted
it → sue → behalf
Under the settlement, the Office of the Surgeon General, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency are barred for the next decade from threatening or coercing social media companies to remove or suppress protected speech.
asserted
Office → bar → speech
The agreement also blocks officials from giving directions on or vetoing platforms' content moderation decisions.
asserted
agreement → block → decisions
One memorable moment that showed a rift within the media itself was when Jon Stewart locked horns with his old friend Stephen Colbert, who had formerly been part of "The Daily Show" before hosting his own.
asserted
who → show → own
While Colbert was cautious about questioning experts, Stewart mocked the idea that people were hesitant to consider the theory.
asserted
people → question → theory
What do we do?
asserted
we → do → What
Oh, you know who we could ask, the Wuhan novel respiratory coronavirus lab.
uncertain
we → know → who
That’s just a little too weird, don’t you think?"
asserted
you → ’ → ?
He added further, "Then they ask the scientists, ‘Wait a minute, you work at the Wuhan respiratory coronavirus lab, how did this happen?’
asserted
this → add → lab
And they’re like, 'A penguin kissed a turtle?’
asserted
penguin → ’re → turtle
What do you think happened?’
asserted
you → think → ?
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia
