A historian and museum professional accused the Smithsonian of abandoning its educational mission in favor of activism following his visit to the National Museum of American History (NMAH) for the first time in more than a decade amid mounting criticism from the Trump administration and conservatives over how the museum presents American history.
asserted
museum → accuse → history
"It's a completely different place than when I was there in 2012," Dr. Jody Edward Ginn told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Ginn → tell → Digital
"Its mission is clearly exactly what they changed it to be.
asserted
they → change → it
They use history, but that's kind of the problem.
asserted
that → use → history
You know, scholars of history, and I don't consider these folks scholars anymore.
asserted
folks → know → history
After reading the administration's Domestic Policy Council report accusing the Smithsonian and the NMAH of failing to present history "in a way that is inspiring, unifying, and worthy of our great republic," Ginn said he traveled all the way from Texas to see it for himself.
asserted
he → read → himself
"From the moment I walked in, it's a very different experience," Ginn said.
asserted
Ginn → walk → moment
"Now, I wasn't totally shocked by this because I've been watching this evolution in my field for over a decade."
asserted
I → shock → decade
As he made his way through the exhibits, Ginn said the institution seeks to "specifically direct" visitors "to action" rather than give them the information to "make their own decisions."
asserted
institution → make → decisions
"It became this goal, their own stated goal, to turn museums from institutions of education, of public education, into institutions to encourage activism, which could also be said to indoctrinate."
uncertain
which → become → activism
Ginn said he found "factually incorrect information" in some exhibits but argued what they don't tell visitors is just as misleading.
asserted
tell → say → visitors
"The biggest problem is in what they leave out," he said.
asserted
he → leave → what
Ginn argued the museum's "graphic" and sexually explicit exhibits have no place in a museum frequented by children and families, saying they're "out of sync with what museums were just a few years ago."
"These are geared towards all ages," he said.
asserted
he → argue → ages
"Why would you do that?
asserted
you → do → that
In a House hearing last month, lawmakers raised similar concerns during a House hearing, pressing Smithsonian National Museum of American History Director Anthea Hartig about the museum's exhibits.
asserted
lawmakers → raise → exhibits
Rep. Tim Burchett, R-Tenn., asked Hartig about the exhibit titled "Illegal to Be You: Gay History Beyond Stonewall," which featured a bondage harness, saying "You have pictures of bondage, you have some overtly sexual things up there, you have transgender folks."
asserted
you → ask → folks
Lawmakers also questioned Hartig about the 2017 MASS Action Toolkit, a guide for museum professionals that references the 2014 Ferguson, Missouri, police shooting and subsequent Black Lives Matter protests while describing "objectivity" as a characteristic of "white supremacy culture," which Ginn said was part of its effort to lean towards activism.
asserted
Ginn → question → activism
Reflecting on the testimony, Ginn said it was "very disappointing" and did not represent "a scholarly presentation whatsoever."
"If that's the kind of museum you've been approved to run, then just own it," he said.
asserted
he → reflect → it
"Don't say you're being unbiased when it's really evident."
asserted
it → say → ?
Ginn also criticized Hartig for maintaining that the museum has not taken a side, adding its revised mission statement "changed the purpose of that museum."
asserted
statement → criticize → museum
During a 2024 presentation to undergraduate and graduate history students, Hartig explained the museum removed the mention of "American history" from its mission statement because it was "hard to get out of the 'America First' mentality."
asserted
it → explain → mentality
For Ginn, his visit confirmed what he described as a "massive shift" in the museum profession, with the Smithsonian serving as "the highest-profile symptom of a process that's been going on for some time."
asserted
that → confirm → time
"It is my opinion as a public historian that the mission we've always had is to educate the public and provide scholarly information," he said.
asserted
he → have → information
However, Ginn said he is "not hopeful" the institution can change without a "massive effort" to replace current staff with people he believes would prioritize history over politics.
asserted
he → say → politics
"You're going to have to put in new people who are committed to scholarly standards and non-politicized educational programming," he said.
asserted
he → go → standards
"These people have bought into it, hook, line and sinker."
asserted
people → buy → it
Fox News Digital reached out to the Smithsonian for comment.
asserted
Digital → reach → comment
The Aporia
