In the frenzied, finger-pointing days following Charlie Kirk’s assassination last year, institutions across the country rushed to appease online mobs and vitriolic politicians who demanded takedowns of anyone critical of the right-wing influencer.
asserted
who → point → influencer
In the year since, courts and arbitrators have forced a growing number of institutions to answer to something much more enduring than right-wing pressure: the law.
asserted
courts → force → pressure
The latest is the Washington Post, which was ordered this week to reinstate Karen Attiah, the opinion columnist it fired last year for her social media posts in the wake of Kirk’s assassination.
asserted
it → order → assassination
The decision from an independent arbitrator is a major win for Attiah, who, alongside the union that represents Post employees, spent the past year fighting her termination through a union grievance process.
asserted
that → represent → process
“I started squealing,” Attiah said in an interview, recalling her union representative calling with the news of her win.
asserted
representative → start → win
Post management fired Attiah on September 11, one day after she posted a series of comments on Bluesky about the public’s response to the Turning Point USA founder’s assassination in Utah earlier that day.
asserted
she → fire → Utah
“Part of what keeps America so violent is the insistence that people perform care, empty goodness and absolution for white men who espouse hatred and violence,” she wrote in one post.
asserted
she → keep → post
“Refusing to tear my clothes and smear ashes on my face in performative mourning for a white man that espoused violence is … not the same as violence,” another read.
asserted
another → refuse → violence
The Post argued Attiah’s comments had “harmed the paper’s reputation and integrity” and “created safety risks” for its staff.
asserted
comments → argue → staff
It also accused her of violating its social media policy by disparaging white men — a claim the arbitrator said was “unsupported” and “unpersuasive.”
uncertain
arbitrator → accuse → men
“The Post, this world-renowned newspaper that’s known for standing up to presidents, authoritarians, and speaking truth to power, was saying, ‘well, we got scared,’” Attiah said.
asserted
Attiah → renowne → power
Firing Attiah, an 11-year veteran of the paper, was an “absolutely disproportional” penalty, arbitrator Sarah Miller Espinosa wrote in her decision, which the Washington-Baltimore News Guild shared with Mother Jones.
asserted
Guild → fire → Jones
Under Jeff Bezos’ ownership, and in particular since Donald Trump’s return to office, the Post’s opinion section has lurched rightward.
asserted
section → lurch → office
In February 2025, Bezos announced that the section would shift its focus to “personal liberties and free markets.”
asserted
section → announce → liberties
Two months before Attiah was fired, opinion editor Adam O’Neill told Attiah during a meeting that he didn’t think her body of work was consistent with that vision.
asserted
body → fire → vision
Her firing ignited concerns about a chilling effect on the press and outrage toward the Post’s leadership.
asserted
firing → ignite → leadership
“She was paid, and she was trained, and she was hired to express opinions,” said Amos Laor, general counsel at the Washington-Baltimore News Guild, who represented Attiah in the arbitration process.
asserted
who → pay → process
“Obviously, not everyone will agree with a columnist on every issue, but her role is to create lively debate on issues of public concern.
asserted
role → agree → concern
The Post respects the arbitration process, a spokesperson for the newspaper wrote in an email, but declined to comment further.
asserted
spokesperson → respect → email
Attiah says she’s open to returning to her role on the Opinion desk but hasn’t heard from the paper.
asserted
she → say → paper
“The Post has created quite an awkward situation for themselves,” she said.
asserted
she → create → themselves
Her case adds to a growing number of firings in the wake of Kirk’s assassination that have proven legally unsound.
asserted
that → add → assassination
“The Charlie Kirk situation caused … institutions to completely have this meltdown of cowardice, fear, temporary insanity,” Attiah said.
asserted
Attiah → cause → cowardice
“Now, they’re facing the year-long Charlie Kirk hangover from their moment of drunkenness — the hangover of having to pay people, of having to reinstate people, of having the negative publicity.
asserted
they → face → publicity
In the aftermath of Kirk’s killing, “we saw a coordinated effort to chill any speech critical of his legacy,” Viktoya Vilk, senior director for digital safety and free expression at PEN America, wrote in a statement to Mother Jones.
asserted
Vilk → see → Jones
In the year since, dozens have challenged their firings.
asserted
dozens → challenge → firings
The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression has tracked 28 lawsuits filed in federal court by public employees who were terminated over their Kirk-related posts.
asserted
who → track → posts
Fifteen cases are active, and 13 have been settled, six of those for at least six figures, according to FIRE.
uncertain
13 → settle → FIRE
- Darren Michael, a theater professor at Austin Peay State University in Tennessee, was reinstated and awarded a $500,000 settlement from the university in January.
asserted
Michael → reinstate → January
Austin Peay State’s president also apologized to Michael, who was terminated after he reshared a 2023 article that quoted Kirk saying, “I think it’s worth to have a cost of, unfortunately, some gun deaths every single year so that we can have the Second Amendment to protect our other God-given rights.”
asserted
we → apologize → rights
- An administrative hearing judge ruled Mariah Roller, a Florida public middle school teacher, should be reinstated and receive back pay in August.
asserted
Roller → rule → August
Roller was suspended after posting criticism of Kirk’s support of the Second Amendment and writing “Bye Charlie,” with a waving emoji and fire emojis.
asserted
Roller → suspend → emoji
- Maria Ruhtenberg, a public defender in Iowa, returned to work in November 2025 after appealing her termination and received $125,000 in damages.
asserted
Ruhtenberg → return → damages
Ruhtenberg had posted on her private Facebook account “you reap what you sow” and “live by the sword, die by the sword” after Kirk’s death.
asserted
you → post → death
Several other employees at public institutions received payouts from their employer, though they didn’t return to work.
asserted
they → receive → work
The University of Tennessee agreed to pay an assistant professor $1.9 million earlier this summer.
asserted
University → agree → million
It had fired the professor, Tamar Shirinian, after she commented on a friend’s Facebook that the “world is better off without [Kirk] in it.”
asserted
world → fire → it
An administrator at Ball State University in Indiana received a $225,000 payout in May.
uncertain
administrator → receive → May
In total, colleges have paid nearly $3 million to employees they fired for their comments about Kirk.
asserted
they → pay → Kirk
As a private employee, Attiah’s case relied not on the First Amendment but on her contract as a member of the Post’s union, the Washington-Baltimore News Guild, whose collective bargaining agreement requires “good and sufficient cause for termination.”
asserted
agreement → rely → termination
…and 7 more, not listed.
The Aporia
