Artificial intelligence is stepping into the music industry as artists, producers and songwriters fight to keep the human soul on the airwaves.
asserted
artists → step → airwaves
According to Deezer, a music streaming app, AI-generated music accounts for about 44% of daily music downloads.
uncertain
music → accord → downloads
Last year, after riding the momentum of two popular songs called "Walk My Walk" and "Livin’ On Borrowed Time," the AI-generated band Breaking Rust debuted at number nine on the Emerging Artists chart.
asserted
band → rid → chart
Unlike a real band, Nashville-based country music artist Ben Gallaher said fake AI bands cannot compete with live entertainment.
asserted
bands → base → entertainment
"I'm a live guy, so you can't take an AI band and go see the show because there is no in-person band," Gallaher said.
asserted
Gallaher → take → person
Gallaher has been playing the guitar since he was six years old.
asserted
he → play → guitar
He said there's nothing AI can do to take all those years of experience away.
asserted
AI → say → experience
"AI can't replace the human heart," Gallaher said.
asserted
Gallaher → replace → heart
There's no place like it in the world musically, and it's always been that way.
asserted
it → be → world
AI is not taking that away.
asserted
AI → take → that
"
Writing music with AI is a slippery slope, but using it to streamline business operations and hammer down a tour schedule is something Gallaher supports.
asserted
Gallaher → write → schedule
"If AI writes a line, you can't then use that line and say you wrote it," Gallaher said.
asserted
Gallaher → write → it
"We can use AI to help find certain venues based on the demographics of where people are listening to the music.
asserted
people → use → music
The recording studio is one of the places where AI is used to refine workflow in the early stages of song creation.
asserted
AI → use → creation
Ocean Way Nashville Director of Operations, Joe Baldridge, said using AI is like having another collaborator in the room to bounce ideas off of.
"They're going to want to use it to create an edge in their workflow," Baldridge said.
asserted
Baldridge → say → workflow
You could use it as a collaborator.
uncertain
You → use → collaborator
You could use it as an editor."
uncertain
You → use → editor
Although AI can be used to lay down basic ideas in the song-creating process, Baldridge said nothing can replace the authenticity of human-created music.
asserted
nothing → use → music
He said most people can detect when something is made by a computer.
asserted
something → say → computer
"We've had drum machines for a long time.
asserted
We → have → time
We've had ways to manipulate vocals for a long time.
asserted
We → have → time
We've had ways to grab incredible sounds from many different things and program them together to mock up a track," Baldridge said.
asserted
Baldridge → have → track
"Humanity and that representation of authenticity and art is going to be something that audiences will seek out.
asserted
audiences → go → that
There are no federal laws to protect human artists from AI-generated music topping the charts.
asserted
music → be → charts
Artists like Grimes, David Guetta, Dr. Dre, Jimmy Iovine, Lauv, Kanye "Ye" West and Tyga have shown support for AI in music.
asserted
Artists → show → music
However, the list of artists that openly oppose it is much longer.
asserted
that → oppose → it
In 2024, over 200 artists joined the "Artist Rights Alliance" in signing a letter against the use of AI in music.
asserted
artists → join → music
Lee Miller, board president of the Nashville Songwriters Association International, said more needs to be done to protect songwriters from AI programs that copy human art.
asserted
that → say → art
"Every song comes from a lifetime of experience," Miller said.
asserted
Miller → come → experience
"You will absolutely destroy the art if you take away the human experience."
asserted
you → destroy → experience
When someone prompts AI to write a song, Miller said the robot analyzes and copies the style and words of a real songwriter, adding that it "muddies the waters" of what is art and what is a "spreadsheet."
asserted
what → prompt → waters
"Is that what the public wants?
asserted
public → want → what
Do you want to live in a society where everything is just generated by the robot?" Miller said.
asserted
Miller → want → robot
"I feel like, at the very least, the lawmakers are going to have to step in and put guardrails on what is copyrightable and what isn't, what's protected and what isn't."
asserted
what → feel → guardrails
Entertainment attorney Barry Shrum said the United States' copyright law is "human centric."
asserted
law → say → ?
The U.S. Copyright Office does not grant copyright protection to anything that is created solely by artificial intelligence.
asserted
that → grant → intelligence
"Our copyright law was developed and foreseen as something that would incentivize humans to create things so that we can benefit society and grow our culture," Shrum said.
asserted
Shrum → develop → culture
In July, the Recording Industry Association of America and the International Federation of the Phonographic Industry started preposing guidelines to protect human creators.
asserted
Association → start → creators
"They want the streaming platforms to identify AI-generated and AI-assisted [music]," Shrum said.
asserted
Shrum → want → music
In August, Apple Music announced that it would start labeling AI music by the end of 2026.
asserted
it → announce → 2026
…and 5 more, not listed.
The Aporia
