In short:
Sharangan Maheswaran has been questioned about a $5 million demand at the centre of an alleged "extortion attempt" against Jean Nassif.
asserted
Maheswaran → question → Nassif
The former Toplace executive was presented alleged extortion texts between Mr Nassif and contractor Navid Ardestani.
asserted
executive → present → Nassif
Peggy Dwyer SC put to Mr Maheswaran that the exchange appeared to show Mr Ardestani was genuinely trying to get paid.
asserted
Ardestani → put → Maheswaran
A $5 million demand at the centre of an alleged "extortion attempt" against fugitive property developer Jean Nassif has been labelled a "lie" amid a NSW corruption watchdog probe.
asserted
demand → allege → probe
The NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) heard Mr Nassif claimed he was being extorted by former Toplace contractor Navid Ardestani, who was pursuing him for money he believed he was owed and communicating with other staff about outstanding payments.
asserted
he → hear → payments
Mr Nassif forwarded some of the messages with Mr Ardestani to his associate and former Toplace executive Sharangan Maheswaran as evidence of an alleged "extortion attempt".
asserted
Nassif → forward → attempt
During Mr Maheswaran's third day at ICAC, counsel assisting the commission Peggy Dwyer SC suggested the full exchange instead showed Mr Ardestani trying to secure payment for contractors and organise remediation work at Mr Nassif's defected developments.
uncertain
Ardestani → assist → developments
"What I'm putting to you puts a lie to your claim that this was an extortion.
uncertain
this → put → claim
This is clearly a request for payment so that remediation works can take place on Jean Nassif's building,"Dr Dwyer said.
asserted
Dwyer → take → Nassif
Mr Maheswaran maintained there was a possible extortion attempt, although it was not reported to police at the time.
asserted
it → maintain → time
Mr Ardestani is not accused of any wrongdoing.
asserted
Ardestani → accuse → wrongdoing
In a message read to the commission, Mr Ardestani told Mr Nassif a meeting was intended to arrange for a builder to carry out remediation work requested by then-NSW building commissioner David Chandler.
asserted
builder → read → Chandler
The commission heard that Mr Ardestani later told Mr Nassif to have a $5 million bank cheque ready for the remedial construction company, as well as $250,000 for painting and rendering work.
asserted
cheque → hear → work
He said the construction company's lawyer would attend the meeting and warned that if the money was not ready, the builders would not sit down with them.
asserted
builders → say → them
When the messages turned to payment for work already completed, Mr Nassif accused Mr Ardestani of playing "illegal games".
asserted
Nassif → turn → games
Mr Ardestani rejected the accusation and asked Mr Nassif to pay the workers so the dispute could be resolved.
uncertain
dispute → reject → workers
"We don't make threats, and we never did…
asserted
we → make → threats
and also, we don't do anything illegal," Mr Ardestani said.
asserted
Ardestani → do → anything
Dr Dwyer put it to Mr Maheswaran that the exchange appeared to show Mr Ardestani was genuinely trying to get paid.
asserted
Ardestani → put → Maheswaran
Dr Dwyer: "Mr Maheswaran, you're a lawyer … you have ethical duties to properly assess the evidence before you.
"
asserted
you → assess → you
Surely you could see that Mr Navid was genuinely pleading with Mr Nassif to be paid and was refuting any suggestion of corruption?"
uncertain
Navid → see → corruption
Mr Maheswaran: "In writing, he appears to be.
asserted
he → appear → writing
Yes, and people very rarely put those things in writing."
In a separate exchange between the pair, Mr Nassif said he did not want to work with the contractors and claimed they were already paid.
asserted
they → put → contractors
He accused them of threatening him with the union and the then-building commissioner Mr Chandler.
asserted
He → accuse → union
Mr Ardestani denied doing so.
asserted
Ardestani → deny → ?
"I really don't understand your text Jean …
asserted
I → understand → text
Get us paid please and we can finalise friendly," Mr Ardestani said.
asserted
Ardestani → get → friendly
Mr Maheswaran maintained that Mr Nassif's messages were evidence that some form of threat had been made, even if that threat was not contained in the messages.
asserted
threat → maintain → messages
'I'm told you control the government'
asserted
you → tell → government
ICAC is examining whether prohibited political donations linked to Mr Nassif were exchanged for political favours, including removing Mr Chandler as building commissioner and stopping him from investigating Mr Nassif's developments.
asserted
donations → examine → developments
Phone taps were heard at the inquiry.
asserted
taps → hear → inquiry
In a recorded call between Mr Nassif and Mr Ardestani, Mr Nassif repeatedly accused the contractor of passing a report about his developments to Mr Chandler.
"
asserted
Nassif → record → Chandler
I didn't know you were so f***ing powerful mate …
asserted
you → know → ?
I'm told you control the government, the commissioner, and the ministers," Mr Nassif said.
asserted
Nassif → tell → government
"Why you sent this report to the commission …
asserted
you → send → commission
Can you tell me why?"
asserted
you → tell → me
Mr Ardestani did not accept the accusation and pushed for a face-to-face meeting, later denying he knew the building commissioner.
asserted
he → accept → commissioner
When asked if the recording supported the allegation of extortion, Mr Maheswaran said Mr Ardestani's voice was "slightly menacing".
asserted
voice → ask → extortion
Extortion allegation potentially fabricated
The commission previously heard an allegation of an "extortion attempt" being raised during a 2021 meeting involving Toplace representatives, including Mr Maraswaran, as Mr Chandler was scrutinising serious defects at Skyview.
asserted
Chandler → hear → Skyview
Mr Chandler told the inquiry that he was informed of an alleged demand for $5 million and offered to accompany a Toplace representative to police to report it.
asserted
he → tell → it
…and 5 more, not listed.
The Aporia
