When ProPublica recently investigated a rape crisis that surged through Syracuse University in the 1980s, we found evidence that the school had taken steps to suppress news coverage of the assaults.
asserted
school → investigate → assaults
The university responded by portraying itself as a changed institution today, “committed to supporting the students who come forward and being there for them at every step of the process,” as a school spokesperson put it.
asserted
spokesperson → respond → it
But the university’s recent actions in a lawsuit filed by a former student who was attacked on campus during that period appear at odds with that commitment.
asserted
who → file → commitment
After the Syracuse Police Department agreed to provide old records to the victim, lawyers for Syracuse University intervened, seeking to block the victim’s access to many of the records.
asserted
lawyers → agree → records
The school argued in legal papers that the subpoena sent to the police department was “overbroad” and suffered “from fatal geographic overreach” that rendered “it unreasonably burdensome and irrelevant.”
asserted
it → argue → overreach
New York state court Judge Joseph Lamendola ruled in the university’s favor in February, dramatically limiting the records the victim could obtain to make her case that the school should have beefed up security in response to escalating crime in the area.
In June, her attorneys appealed that decision, sending the matter to a state appellate court.
uncertain
attorneys → rule → court
“It smacks of the 1980s when SU quashed media coverage of sexual assault.
asserted
SU → smack → assault
It’s that all over again,” said Andrew Stengel, a former Manhattan prosecutor representing the victim.
asserted
Stengel → ’ → victim
He accused the university of “retraumatizing” his client “by pretending sexual assault wasn’t a problem on campus and in the surrounding area.”
asserted
assault → accuse → area
Stengel and his client, referred to as Jane Doe in legal filings, are suing the university under the Adult Survivors Act, a New York law that opened a one-year exemption from the statute of limitations for survivors of long-ago sexual assaults to pursue legal claims against alleged abusers and negligent institutions.
uncertain
survivors → refer → abusers
Sarah Scalese, Syracuse University’s vice president of communications, said in an emailed statement that “we do not comment on active litigation.”
asserted
we → say → litigation
In response to ProPublica’s earlier story, Scalese said the university “has a robust structure in place to support those affected by sexual and relationship violence,” including “confidential counseling, advocacy and investigation and resolution services to students.”
asserted
university → say → students
Doe was attacked by a man with a knife inside a bathroom on the third floor of the university’s music building at about 6:30 p.m. on Feb. 27, 1987.
asserted
Doe → attack → Feb.
Her assailant had entered the building through an unlocked door, according to her lawsuit, which contends that the university administration offered her “zero support” after the assault.
uncertain
administration → enter → assault
The music program director, the complaint alleges, told her, “Men get raped, too,” and advised her to get “back on the horse.”
asserted
Men → allege → horse
Hers was one episode in a brutal saga of sexual violence that unfolded in and around the Syracuse campus throughout the decade.
asserted
that → unfold → decade
The scourge of assaults became so pervasive that it eventually inspired student protests, drew national press attention and contributed to the passage of federal legislation that now requires universities to publicly report crime statistics.
asserted
that → become → statistics
ProPublica’s earlier examination — rooted in the wrongful conviction of Anthony Broadwater for the rape of Alice Sebold, an author who wrote a bestselling memoir about being attacked on the last night of her freshman year at Syracuse University in 1981 — found that more than a dozen women, many of them students, reported being raped or attacked by strangers in a half-square-mile area near the campus over four years.
asserted
many → root → years
Sebold’s was the third such attack in Thornden Park, which runs alongside the campus, in about seven months.
asserted
which → run → months
Some of the police reports from this time period were marked “NO PRESS,” which, according to the testimony of a former Syracuse detective, meant that the university had used its influence in the police department to “put their foot down and said no press for any kind of rape, robbery, burglary that’s anywhere in the area of Syracuse University.”
uncertain
that → mark → University
Last year, Stengel asked the police department for all police calls and reports tied to a variety of crimes from 1982 to 1987 within the ZIP code that contains the university, Thornden Park, various businesses, and a mix of student and nonstudent housing.
asserted
that → ask → housing
Emails filed as an exhibit in Doe’s case show that a lawyer representing the Syracuse Police Department suggested that Stengel focus his search on that ZIP code.
uncertain
Stengel → file → code
The two of them agreed on the terms in August 2025, and the police department began gathering the records shortly thereafter.
asserted
department → agree → records
A month later, the university filed a motion to “partially quash” the subpoena.
asserted
university → file → subpoena
Relying on case law that applies only to central and western New York state, university lawyers argued that it had standing to limit the request, even though it was not the recipient of Stengel’s subpoena.
asserted
it → rely → subpoena
The university asserted that the subpoena would create unnecessary work for the police department, unearth irrelevant documents and waste the time of everyone involved.
asserted
subpoena → assert → everyone
The police department then reversed its earlier position and joined in the motion, estimating in a February brief that it would take 845 hours and $50,000 in staff time to provide the documents Stengel had asked for and the police department lawyer had initially approved.
asserted
lawyer → reverse → documents
(A spokesperson said that “the City of Syracuse does not comment on ongoing litigation.”)
asserted
City → say → litigation
At a hearing, John Powers, an attorney hired by the university, seemed to play to Lamendola’s previous role as a lawyer for the city of Syracuse, reminding the judge that the city is “inundated with [Freedom of Information Law] responses and subpoenas, and it’s incredibly burdensome on the city, I think, as you know in your experience as well.”
asserted
you → hire → experience
The records were too old to be digitized, Powers told the judge, adding that, just as the judge once did, Powers represents the city in other matters.
asserted
Powers → digitize → matters
City employees, he said, would have to find them “the old way, Judge, the way we used to do it, crawling around in the dusty storeroom … trying to determine what ZIP code’s involved, looking at the crime.
asserted
code → say → crime
(Powers declined to comment, citing the litigation.)
asserted
Powers → decline → litigation
Lamendola was persuaded.
asserted
Lamendola → persuade → ?
Under his ruling, none of the rapes that took place in Thornden Park or in the student apartments near it will have to be disclosed.
asserted
that → take → it
The police will have to disclose only reports of crimes that took place on the campus itself, and not reports concerning burglary, larceny and other offenses, which the judge deemed irrelevant.
asserted
judge → have → burglary
He also directed Syracuse University, the defendant in the case, to assist the Police Department in identifying cases that occurred on its campus.
asserted
that → direct → campus
Doe’s team filed a 37-page appellate brief in late June that argues that the court’s decision to limit the disclosure to university buildings is “hard to justify” given that the campus is interwoven with the city.
asserted
campus → file → city
The brief, authored by appellate attorney Michael Steinberg, also takes issue with the decision to allow university personnel to act as “gatekeepers,” authorizing them to review the police files and decide for themselves which meet the judge’s criteria and which don’t.
asserted
which → author → criteria
That, the appeal contends, presents a conflict of interest that would “give the defendant the power to control the evidence it will have to contest at trial.”
asserted
it → contend → trial
The university has until Sept. 23 to respond to the appeal.
asserted
university → have → appeal
…and 25 more, not listed.
The Aporia
