NDP leader Avi Lewis denied holding all Jews accountable for Israel’s actions in Gaza during a Yom Kippur social media post that sparked criticism from Liberal MPs Anthony Housefather and Ben Carr. Lewis posted on X, reflecting on the failure to stop what he called an ongoing genocide committed "in our name." The controversy followed a shooting near a synagogue in Belleville, Ontario, which occurred shortly after Lewis’s post. Liberal MP Ben Carr warned that such narratives can fuel anti-Jewish hate, while Housefather labeled Lewis's comments as “despicable.”
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-09-22,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Story summary
NDP Leader Avi Lewis faced criticism after posting on X during Yom Kippur, reflecting on the failure of Jewish people to stop what he called "an ongoing genocide" committed in their name. The post did not directly mention the war that began in October 2023 when Hamas killed 1,200 people and took about 250 hostages in a surprise attack on Israel, but it sparked debate over collective responsibility for Israeli actions. Since then, tens of thousands of Palestinians have been killed by Israeli strikes hitting civilian areas, leading to an international declaration of famine. Liberal MPs Anthony Housefather and Ben Carr, both Jewish, criticized Lewis’s comments as irresponsible and wrong to hold all Jews accountable for Israel's policies in Gaza. Lewis later clarified that he was "absolutely not" holding all Jews responsible for the actions of Israel.
Written for “NDP Leader Controversy Over Israel Re…” on 2026-10-05,
grounded in this article and the 1 other(s) covering the same event.
NDP leader says he was 'absolutely not' holding all Jews responsible for Israel's actions in Yom Kippur post
'We failed to do our part to stop an ongoing genocide committed in our name,' Lewis said on social media
NDP Leader Avi Lewis said he is not holding all Jews accountable for Israel's policies in Gaza, after some Liberal MPs called comments he made in a social media post irresponsible and "despicable."
asserted
he → say → post
Lewis posted late Sunday that he would be marking the holiest day on the Jewish calendar, Yom Kippur, by reflecting on geopolitics.
asserted
he → post → geopolitics
This year I'm reflecting on the fact that we failed to do our part to stop an ongoing genocide committed in our name," Lewis posted Sunday evening on the platform X.
Lewis's post did not directly mention the war in Gaza, which started in October 2023, when Hamas killed 1,200 people and took about 250 hostages in a surprise attack on Israel.
Since then, tens of thousands of Palestinians have been killed in nearly three years of Israeli strikes that frequently hit civilian areas, and by Israeli policies that led to an international declaration of famine.
asserted
that → reflect → famine
Liberal MPs Anthony Housefather and Ben Carr both pushed back on Lewis's comments, saying it's wrong to collectively hold Jews responsible for the actions of Israel.
When asked whether Lewis's post was antisemitic, Carr called it "naive."
"That's an irresponsible thing for a leader to say," the Winnipeg MP said.
asserted
MP → push → it
"It's dangerous and it's the type of narrative that is actually contributing to the type of threats that we're seeing levied against the Jewish community."
asserted
we → contribute → community
Housefather wrote on X that Lewis's post was "despicable."
asserted
post → write → X
The federal government's official definition of antisemitism cautions against holding Jews collectively accountable for Israel's actions because it can fuel anti-Jewish hate.
asserted
it → caution → hate
Advocates have linked that notion of collective responsibility to multiple attacks on Jewish institutions, including a shooting Sunday outside a synagogue in Belleville, Ont., while worshippers were inside marking the start of Yom Kippur.
asserted
worshippers → link → Kippur
Suspect in shooting outside Belleville synagogue ID'd
This is not going to stop us,' synagogue president vows after shooting
Lewis made the post shortly before that event, which the Special Investigations Unit says involved a 29-year-old man allegedly firing a gun at a police officer stationed outside the synagogue for security.
uncertain
Unit → go → security
Lewis condemned that attack on Monday, first in a post on X just before question period, and later when asked about it by a reporter in a scrum on Parliament Hill.
asserted
Lewis → condemn → Hill
"It's terrifying," he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
"Obviously, I can picture what it's like to be in synagogue and to have shots ring out in an environment so familiar to me.
asserted
shots → picture → me
In that same scrum he said criticisms of his remarks about Israel were partisan.
asserted
criticisms → say → Israel
"It's pretty ugly to see these partisan points being — this occasion, being used to score partisan points," he said.
asserted
he → see → points
"Holding Jews collectively responsible for the actions of the state of Israel is antisemitic.
asserted
Jews → hold → Israel
I've never done it.
asserted
I → do → it
I think it's dangerous and that's absolutely not what I did.
asserted
I → think → what
I spoke as a Jewish Canadian from a place of profound sadness.…
asserted
I → speak → sadness
Many Jews have said that we have not done enough as Jewish people, among a family of faiths and communities around the world."
asserted
we → say → world
Some — including former Canadian ambassador to Israel Jon Allen — argue that major Jewish groups in Canada are creating the false impression that they support Israel's actions against Palestinians by not calling out the Israeli government.
asserted
they → include → government
"By not calling out what's happening in the West Bank and Gaza, there is a complicity of silence," Allen told a Senate committee this past June, adding that he himself is Jewish.
asserted
he → call → silence
"The failure sometimes, frankly, of the Jewish community" to speak out against Israeli government actions "makes people in Canada say, 'Well, do they support everything Israel does?
asserted
Israel → speak → everything
Do they support what happened in Gaza?"' he testified.
asserted
he → support → Gaza
The Aporia
