When the pop singer Pink took to social media to decry rapper Macklemore’s comments on Israel’s genocide of Palestinians — a slaughter that has taken the lives of more than 20,000 kids — she brought up her decadelong role as a UNICEF ambassador to show that she cares about children.
asserted
she → take → children
Now, a new petition signed by more than 160,000 people, including the backing of actor Javier Bardem, is calling for Pink’s removal from her UNICEF USA role.
asserted
petition → sign → role
The petition organizers, Swifties Against Genocide, named for fans of the pop singer Taylor Swift, said that Pink’s remarks sidelined concern for Palestinian children and “fueled ongoing conflict and struggles for visibility and empathy.”
asserted
remarks → name → visibility
“As individuals who care deeply about the welfare of children around the world, we must hold UNICEF Ambassadors to the highest standards of neutrality and compassion,” the organizers wrote.
asserted
organizers → care → neutrality
“Palestinian children, like all children affected by genocide, deserve ambassadors who unequivocally extend support and empathy towards their plight.
asserted
who → affect → plight
The petition is the latest example of the type of public pressure supporters of Palestine are seeking to exert amid a tidal shift of sentiment in the U.S. on Palestine and Israel over the past three years.
asserted
supporters → seek → years
Israel’s genocide in Gaza has dramatically soured U.S. opinion on Israel, with a majority viewing Israel unfavorably and more Americans taking a sympathetic view of Palestinians.
asserted
Americans → sour → Palestinians
The transformations have played out in the current midterm election cycle, with candidates pushing to sever military ties with Israel winning in primaries across the country.
asserted
candidates → play → country
In the past several weeks, the subject has upended mainstream popular culture, with battle lines being drawn over a stadium concert tour by pop icon Ed Sheeran.
asserted
lines → upend → Sheeran
The pressure on UNICEF to part ways with Pink is tied up with a strategy among Palestine solidarity activists to extract a price from Israel for its continued occupation and genocide of Palestinians.
asserted
pressure → part → Palestinians
For Tariq Kenney-Shawa, a policy fellow with Al-Shabaka U.S., the petition is “a clear attempt to draw a new line in the sand and make the point that choosing to take the moderate lane is unacceptable.”
asserted
choosing → draw → lane
“These past couple days have proven that being shamelessly pro-Israel, or even refusing to take sides in the face of a genocide, is no longer the safe route,” he said, citing a shift of the “cultural hegemony” in the West.
asserted
he → prove → West
Though Sheeran himself — who said at his latest concert that he was listening to both sides — is not a target of Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions against Israel, the cultural backlash to his move to take Macklemore off the tour reinforced the logic of the growing movement, Natasha Lennard recently wrote in The Intercept.
asserted
Lennard → say → Intercept
Representatives for Pink, UNICEF, and Change.org did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
asserted
Representatives → respond → comment
Other advocates for Palestinian rights reaffirmed the petitioners’ aims.
asserted
advocates → reaffirm → aims
“Pink should step down.
asserted
Pink → step → ?
UNICEF itself has called Gaza a graveyard for children.
asserted
UNICEF → call → children
Its ambassadors are supposed to speak for those children, not attack the people who do,” said Raed Jarrar, the advocacy director of Democracy for the Arab World Now.
asserted
Jarrar → suppose → World
“Whether UNICEF removes her or not, it’s time for her to step down.”
asserted
her → remove → her
The controversy involving Pink kicked off during Sheeran’s show at MetLife Stadium in New Jersey on September 4.
asserted
controversy → involve → September
Macklemore, one of the opening acts, spoke out against Israeli apartheid and the genocide of Palestinians, addressing Jewish people in the crowd to say that criticism of genocide and the Israeli government “is in no way a criticism of you.”
asserted
criticism → speak → you
After backlash from pro-Israel groups like the Anti-Defamation League — and perhaps more critically, pressure from billionaire Robert Kraft, the deeply pro-Israel owner of the New England Patriots and Massachusetts’s Gillette Stadium — Sheeran dropped Macklemore from his tour.
asserted
Sheeran → drop → tour
Then came the backlash to the backlash, with other opening acts on the tour and even Sheeran’s backing band dropping out in solidarity with Macklemore.
asserted
band → come → Macklemore
Pink, the pop star who rose to fame with a string of hits in the early 2000s, waded into the controversy early on.
asserted
who → rise → controversy
After attending the September 4 show, Pink reshared a social media post from the group Stop Antisemitism that said Macklemore’s claims of a genocide were “false” and that concertgoers were owed apologies and refunds.
uncertain
concertgoers → attend → apologies
“I don’t need anyone fired, and I don’t need a refund,” she later wrote on Instagram, explaining why she reshared the post.
asserted
she → need → post
“What I need is to be able to say, as a Jewish mom, ‘That scared me, and it scared people I love’ — without being told our fear is just propaganda, and without being told I’m somehow cool with genocide because I noticed?”
asserted
I → need → genocide
She added that the protest slogan “From river to the sea” and the use of the term “Zionist” have become “a slur.”
asserted
slogan → add → term
Pink said that “nobody should ever celebrate the death of a child.”
asserted
nobody → say → child
She mentioned her experience as a UNICEF ambassador visiting children born in war zones.
asserted
She → mention → zones
She “grieved every one of them, on both sides of that fence,” she wrote.
asserted
she → grieve → fence
Yet Pink’s grief, or any celebrity’s, has done little to change conditions on the ground for Palestinian children.
asserted
celebrity → do → children
Just on Monday, an 11-year-old boy was shot to death by the Israeli military in one of Gaza’s apparent “safe zones.”
asserted
boy → shoot → zones
UNICEF, which operates in Gaza, itself reported that Israeli attacks have killed at least 300 children in Gaza since the so-called ceasefire agreement last October.
asserted
attacks → operate → agreement
Food insecurity and lack of access to clean water also remain issues due to Israel’s blockade on humanitarian aid from entering the Strip.
asserted
insecurity → remain → Strip
In her social media post, Pink said she does not speak for Israel but reiterated her stance that “Hamas is a terrorist organization.
asserted
Hamas → say → stance
Palestinians deserve a future that honors their humanity and their aspirations.”
asserted
that → deserve → humanity
She said she was not “going to litigate a complex war in an Instagram caption, and I’m not going to recite anybody’s slogan to earn back a follower.”
asserted
I → say → follower
Over the weekend, the petition calling out Pink also drew the support from Javier Bardem, an outspoken advocate for Palestine and major funder of the Palestinian film “All That’s Left of You,” who shared the petition on his Instagram profile.
asserted
who → call → profile
“She can not defend children’s rights,” Bardem said, “while not condemning the genocide in Gaza.”
asserted
Bardem → defend → Gaza
…and 34 more, not listed.
The Aporia
