Montreal city council adopts bylaw banning insults against police, municipal employees
Residents who insult city staff would face fines between $300 and $1,000 for a 1st offence
Montreal city council has adopted a bylaw to ban people from insulting police officers and other municipal employees.
asserted
council → adopt → officers
The debate over the rule lasted over half an hour, with the Official Opposition saying the proposed bylaw was "half-baked."
asserted
bylaw → last → hour
It was adopted with 35 voting in favour and 25 opposed.
asserted
25 → adopt → favour
"We are being asked to vote now and consult later," said Marie Plourde, leader of the Official Opposition.
asserted
Plourde → ask → Opposition
Under the bylaw, residents who insult city staff would face fines between $300 and $1,000 for a first offence.
asserted
who → insult → offence
Subsequent offences could result in fines up to $2,000.
uncertain
offences → result → fines
City officials have not said when they will implement the bylaw.
asserted
they → say → bylaw
Yves Francœur, head of the police brotherhood, has said his union's members have been pushing for such a bylaw for years.
asserted
members → say → years
But lawyers and civil rights groups worry the bylaw could infringe on the constitutional right to freedom of expression.
uncertain
bylaw → worry → expression
Other municipalities in the province, including Quebec City, Laval, Longueuil and Sherbrooke, already have similar bylaws.
asserted
municipalities → include → bylaws
The Canadian Press reported in June that some of these municipalities have issued thousands of fines over the past six years.
asserted
some → report → years
"Giving the middle finger, it's not what will give you a ticket," Montreal Mayor Soraya Martinez Ferrada said before the council meeting.
asserted
Ferrada → give → meeting
"Let's just be honest.
asserted
's → let → ?
City employees could refuse service
uncertain
employees → refuse → service
The new Montreal bylaw would ban insults, harassment, threats, abuse and intimidation, as well as offensive and aggressive behaviour.
asserted
bylaw → ban → insults
It also includes provisions saying city employees could refuse to provide services to someone who misbehaves.
uncertain
who → include → someone
However, the bylaw doesn't define what could be construed as an insult.
uncertain
what → define → insult
City councillor Carla Beauvais heavily criticized the administration for not providing clear definitions.
asserted
Beauvais → criticize → definitions
She also questioned the lack of public consultations.
asserted
She → question → consultations
"A threat can be proven.
asserted
threat → prove → ?
An offensive word is felt.
asserted
word → feel → ?
And how a person feels can vary from one person to another.
asserted
feels → feel → another
So where does the offence begin?
asserted
offence → begin → ?
Where does permissible anger end?
asserted
anger → end → ?
The text doesn't say," said Beauvais.
asserted
Beauvais → say → ?
She cited various decisions from the Quebec City municipal court in which judges could not agree on what constitutes an insult, raising concerns that the rule will cause a backlog at the courthouse.
uncertain
rule → cite → courthouse
Citizens are concerned, councillor says
asserted
councillor → say → ?
Opposition councillor Martine Musau Muele added that council was asked to vote on the rule without adequate information.
asserted
council → add → information
She said the documents councillors received did not provide statistics and reports to support the need for the bylaw.
asserted
councillors → say → bylaw
She also said the city did not conduct any risk assessment or prove that the measures under the Criminal Code are insufficient to deal with belligerent residents.
asserted
measures → say → residents
People do not understand the reasoning of the administration.
asserted
People → understand → administration
What led you to decide that today, with everything going on, that this is the most optimal move?" Muele said.
asserted
Muele → lead → you
Man who filmed himself insulting SPVM officer facing criminal defamation charges
Suspension of 4th Montreal officer in racism scandal renews calls for independent probe
The two councillors also raised concerns around giving police more powers while public trust is fragile.
asserted
trust → film → powers
In June, Montreal police disbanded a night patrol unit in the multicultural neighbourhood of Montréal-Nord over allegations of racism and misconduct.
asserted
police → disband → racism
Mayor acknowledges concerns
asserted
Mayor → acknowledge → concerns
During council, Martinez Ferrada acknowledged that "there will be more questions around this bylaw in the coming months" but insisted the administration "needed to act."
asserted
administration → acknowledge → months
She said the administration would make reports publicly available.
asserted
reports → say → ?
She said she "understands the concerns," and "shares some of them."
asserted
she → say → them
However, she said incidents of inappropriate behaviour have increased dramatically and are harming city employees, and making it more difficult to recruit new employees.
asserted
it → say → employees
"We are simply saying that there is a line between challenging an institution and engaging in behaviour that is inappropriate toward the people who work for it," said the mayor.
asserted
mayor → say → it
…and 10 more, not listed.
The Aporia
