A Melbourne magistrate has cleared two Victoria Police officers of manslaughter charges in connection with the death of Luke Briggs, a 35-year-old man who died eight days after being arrested in July 2024. Magistrate Patrick Southey ruled that there was insufficient evidence to convict Constable Alexander Papanastassis and Sergeant James Fitzgerald, citing the weak nature of the case. The officers were charged with negligent manslaughter over Briggs' death, which occurred while they were arresting him at a convenience store car park in Hoppers Crossing, Melbourne's south west. In his ruling, Southey contrasted the case to that of George Floyd, saying the parallels between the two cases "end there" and that the police officers were doing their best under the circumstances.
Written by the local model on 2026-08-25,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Why this leaning score
The model judged this article politically coded and scored it -0.35, but none of the 2 quote(s) it offered could be found in the article text, so the score is not published.
Written under an earlier scoring contract, which gave a paragraph
rather than checkable quotes. Re-analysing this article replaces it.
Leaning score withheld for article 2392: no verified evidence · logged 2026-08-27
In short:
A magistrate has ruled there was insufficient evidence to convict two Victoria Police officers over the death of Luke Briggs, following his arrest in 2024.
asserted
magistrate → rule → 2024
Constable Alexander Papanastassis and Sergeant James Fitzgerald were charged with negligent manslaughter but fought the charges.
What's next?
asserted
What → charge → charges
Mr Briggs's family is separately suing the state, accusing the officers of breaching their duty of care.
asserted
family → sue → care
Manslaughter charges against two Victoria Police officers have been thrown out by a magistrate who contrasted the case with the death of George Floyd.
asserted
who → throw → Floyd
Luke Briggs, 35, died eight days after he was arrested in a convenience store car park at Hoppers Crossing, in Melbourne's south west, in July 2024.
asserted
he → die → July
Constable Alexander Papanastassis, 30, and Sergeant James Fitzgerald, 46, were each charged with negligent manslaughter over his death, but they fought the charges at a committal hearing.
asserted
they → charge → hearing
Melbourne magistrate Patrick Southey on Tuesday determined there was insufficient evidence for the case to go to trial and dismissed the charges.
asserted
case → determine → charges
"The evidence is so weak that the prospect of a conviction is minimal," Mr Southey said.
asserted
Southey → say → conviction
"It may be the manner in which Mr Briggs was restrained was the substantial and operative cause of death, but we'll never know."
uncertain
we → restrain → death
Mr Briggs allegedly became unresponsive during the arrest, and the officers performed CPR before calling for medical assistance.
uncertain
officers → become → assistance
The 35-year-old died in a Melbourne hospital intensive care unit on July 23, surrounded by family.
asserted
old → die → family
Photos at the time showed bruising on his arms as he lay in a hospital bed.
asserted
he → show → bed
Mr Briggs's family suing the state
asserted
family → sue → state
In delivering his ruling, Mr Southey referred to the high-profile case of African American man George Floyd in the United States.
asserted
Southey → deliver → States
Mr Floyd was murdered by a white police officer who was arresting him in May 2020.
uncertain
who → murder → May
His dying words of "I can't breathe" were also said by Mr Briggs, the magistrate noted.
asserted
magistrate → die → Briggs
"It seems to me the parallels end there," Mr Southey said.
"
asserted
Southey → seem → me
There is no comparison to this case where … the police were doing the best they could.
uncertain
they → be → best
"It was not a perfect job but the best they could do in all the circumstances."
uncertain
they → do → circumstances
The magistrate noted Mr Briggs was a large, powerful man whose behaviour had been irrational due to methamphetamine use.
asserted
behaviour → note → use
"It was an unfortunate, tragic chain of events but in my view, it does not amount to criminal negligence," Mr Southey said.
asserted
Southey → amount → negligence
He awarded costs to Constable Papanastassis and Sergeant Fitzgerald, who have both been suspended from duties since the incident.
asserted
who → award → incident
Members of Mr Briggs's family were visibly upset as the decision was handed down on Tuesday afternoon.
asserted
decision → hand → afternoon
The family is separately suing the state, accusing the officers of breaching their duty of care and Victoria Police of failing to "properly supervise, control or train their employees, officers and/or agents".
asserted
family → sue → employees
Mr Southey indicated his ruling had no basis on any civil proceedings and the prosecution could still choose to directly indict the two officers on fresh criminal charges.
uncertain
prosecution → indicate → charges
The Police Association Victoria said it stood by its members throughout the whole process and would continue to support them.
asserted
it → say → them
"That night they did what any of their colleagues would have done," secretary Wayne Gatt said.
"
asserted
Gatt → do → colleagues
They pulled over a suspicious vehicle and attempted to speak to the driver.
"
asserted
They → pull → driver
When the situation escalated into a physical confrontation, they tried to manage it peacefully, but they were not afforded that opportunity."
asserted
they → escalate → opportunity
Mr Gatt said the officers' actions "did not amount to criminal negligence, nor did their conduct warrant the intervention of the criminal law" and acknowledged the sometimes dangerous work officers did in the field.
AAP/ABC
asserted
officers → say → AAP