When Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh chief Dr. Mohan Bhagwat addressed roughly 5,000 people at Madison Square Garden on Aug. 29, his opponents had already mobilized against his appearance.
asserted
opponents → address → appearance
The Raksha Bandhan-inspired Universal Oneness Celebration brought together leaders from 16 faith and wisdom traditions.
asserted
Celebration → inspire → traditions
Bhagwat described diversity as the decoration of unity and urged Hindu Americans to remain loyal to the United States (their karma bhumi) — while exuding the values of their matru bhumi, or motherland.
asserted
Bhagwat → describe → bhumi
Bhagwat urged Hindu Americans to remain loyal to the U.S. while living the values of their motherland.
asserted
Bhagwat → urge → motherland
Whatever one thinks of the RSS, that was the gathering’s stated message.
asserted
that → think → RSS
Outside the hall, however, Bhagwat was denounced as “far-right,” “supremacist,” and “paramilitary.”
asserted
Bhagwat → denounce → hall
Prism Reports portrayed his appearance as an RSS “influence operation,” relying heavily on Savera, a coalition organized to combat what it calls “Hindu supremacy.”
asserted
it → portray → what
Yet the organizations demanding transparency from Bhagwat’s hosts receive remarkably little scrutiny of their own affiliations, funders, and coordinated campaigns.
asserted
organizations → demand → affiliations
Among the organizations campaigning against the appearance was Hindus for Human Rights, which describes its mission as opposing Hindu nationalism and caste, while focusing heavily on the RSS, Narendra Modi, the Ram temple, and India’s government — cofounded by Sunita Viswanath.
asserted
which → campaign → Viswanath
Ahead of the event, HfHR urged supporters to call and email Madison Square Garden to demand its cancellation, providing a script describing Bhagwat’s politics as hateful and exclusionary.
asserted
HfHR → urge → politics
HfHR’s development was closely tied to Jewish Voice for Peace.
asserted
development → tie → Peace
Jewish Currents reported that former JVP Deputy Director Alissa Wise trained HfHR’s staff and board, coached its leadership, and facilitated retreats.
asserted
Wise → report → retreats
Shaw called it a “JVP for Hindus.”
asserted
Shaw → call → Hindus
HfHR has also repeatedly worked alongside the Islamic Circle of North America’s Council for Social Justice.
asserted
HfHR → work → Justice
In September 2019, ICNA-CSJ said it “took the lead” in coordinating a massive anti-Modi demonstration outside the United Nations.
asserted
it → say → Nations
ICNA organized volunteers and buses for the demonstration.
asserted
ICNA → organize → demonstration
HfHR cosponsored it, and Viswanath addressed the crowd.
asserted
Viswanath → cosponsor → crowd
In December 2021, HfHR and ICNA-CSJ joined other organizations in urging then-Secretary of State Antony Blinken to designate India a “Country of Particular Concern.”
asserted
HfHR → join → Concern
These examples demonstrate recurring political cooperation.
asserted
examples → demonstrate → cooperation
ICNA is legally separate from Jamaat-e-Islami, and cooperation with ICNA does not prove control by Jamaat.
asserted
cooperation → prove → Jamaat
Historian and anthropologist Karen Leonard has written that ICNA was founded by Pakistani members of Jamaat-e-Islami.
asserted
ICNA → write → Islami
Contemporary American Religion describes ICNA as “deeply influenced” by the writings of Jamaat founder Abul A’la Maududi.
asserted
Religion → describe → Maududi
Brookings has called Jamaat-e-Islami Pakistan the country’s “Muslim Brotherhood analogue.”
asserted
Brookings → call → Pakistan
Savera’s network includes HfHR, the Indian American Muslim Council, and India Civil Watch International.
asserted
network → include → HfHR
HfHR lists them and Savera among its partners or coalitions.
asserted
HfHR → list → partners
Several groups within this network also supported the controversial 2021 Dismantling Global Hindutva conference, where Madhu Hebbar has argued that some speakers crossed from opposing nationalism into portraying Hinduism and its scriptures as inherently oppressive.
asserted
speakers → support → Hinduism
Here, Savera’s methodology deserves a mirror test.
asserted
methodology → deserve → test
HfHR’s collaboration with ICNA-CSJ and its organizational training, conducted by a former JVP leader, are documented connections.
asserted
collaboration → conduct → leader
They do not establish foreign direction.
asserted
They → establish → direction
The same distinction should guide scrutiny of Hindu American organizations: shared events, personnel, and ideas warrant questions, but claims of foreign control require evidence of that control
uncertain
claims → guide → control
ICNA states that ICNA-CSJ was established by ICNA.
asserted
CSJ → state → ICNA
This establishes an operational alliance with an American institution born from the Jamaat milieu — a stronger connection than the cultural affinity Savera invokes to portray Hindu-American organizations as components of a foreign-controlled network.
asserted
Savera → establish → network
Meanwhile, Hindu Swayamsevak Sangh USA (HSS USA) is a separately registered 501(c)(3) nonprofit group with public federal filings.
asserted
USA → register → filings
That status does not settle questions about its relationship with the RSS.
asserted
status → settle → RSS
Those questions should be examined through evidence of governance, funding, and operations, applying the same standards used for other advocacy organizations.
asserted
questions → examine → organizations
A database compiling IRS-derived grant records lists approximately $2.2 million in grants to HfHR between 2020 and 2024, including $1.3 million from the Tides Foundation, its largest identified funder.
asserted
database → compile → Foundation
Those figures warrant verification against the underlying filings, but the principle is straightforward: questions about institutional funding
asserted
questions → warrant → funding
The RSS, HSS, and Bhagwat’s American hosts should answer legitimate questions about their organizations and disclosures.
asserted
RSS → answer → organizations
Hindu Americans should not face a political litmus test under which attending a cultural gathering, donating to an organization, or participating in Raksha Bandhan outreach becomes evidence of foreign subversion.
asserted
attending → face → subversion
Adelle Nazarian is a journalist, entrepreneur, and commentator covering politics, culture, technology, and the ideas shaping America.
asserted
Nazarian → cover → America
The Aporia
