This week, Ukraine was rocked by a series of political scandals.
asserted
Ukraine → rock → scandals
A month after stepping down as defense minister, Mykhailo Fedorov addressed the Ukrainian people in a nine-minute speech posted on his YouTube channel.
asserted
Fedorov → step → channel
In his video message, he declares that Ukraine "cannot remain without a fully appointed minister of defense."
asserted
Ukraine → declare → defense
But, he continues, "the main problem goes much deeper than one position or one ministry."
asserted
problem → continue → position
He says Ukraine's greatest challenge is a "systemic crisis of governance," of which corruption is only a symptom.
asserted
corruption → say → which
Fedorov also criticized the fact that no national elections have been held in Ukraine since 2019.
asserted
elections → criticize → 2019
A few hours earlier, the Ukrainian president, Volodymyr Zelenskyy, had proposed Yevhenii Khmara to parliament as the new defense minister.
asserted
president → propose → minister
Khmara had been made acting minister of defense on July 20, and parliament confirmed him in the position on August 19.
asserted
parliament → make → August
Corruption scandal involving public authorities
When Fedorov spoke of corruption in government authorities, he may not have known about the scandal that would break the very day after he published his speech.
uncertain
he → involve → speech
On August 19, Ukrainian anti-corruption investigators searched the premises of several high-ranking officials, including a presidential deputy chief of staff, Iryna Mudra, and a member of parliament, Vadym Stolar.
asserted
investigators → search → parliament
Ukraine's National Anti-Corruption Bureau (NABU) stated that it was "conducting a special operation to expose a criminal organization" in conjunction with the Specialized Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office.
asserted
it → state → Office
According to the investigating authorities, this organization was led by a current and a former Ukrainian lawmaker, and involved senior officials from the president's office.
uncertain
organization → accord → office
Volodymyr Zelenskyy dismissed Mudra from her post as presidential deputy chief of staff the same day.
asserted
Zelenskyy → dismiss → staff
In his video, Mykhailo Fedorov warns that "it is especially dangerous when society feels that the main criterion for appointing a person is not their professionalism, results, or ability […] but their personal loyalty to the system."
asserted
criterion → warn → system
He says that a "legal, safe, and realistic mechanism" needs to be found to make it possible to hold elections, even if Russia's war against Ukraine continues for a long time.
asserted
war → say → time
Ukraine's constitution forbids elections in time of war
asserted
constitution → forbid → war
The president dismissed Fedorov from his post as defense minister on July 15.
asserted
president → dismiss → July
Protests calling for his reinstatement began the following day in Kyiv, Lviv, Dnipro, Kharkiv, Zaporizhzhia, and other cities.
asserted
Protests → call → Kyiv
According to polls conducted by the Rating opinion research institute on July 20 and 21, trust in the ex-minister rose from 35% to 65% in the first week of the protests.
uncertain
trust → accord → protests
Of the respondents, 72% thought Fedorov should not have been sacked.
asserted
Fedorov → think → respondents
A poll conducted on August 5 and 6 showed Fedorov in third place in the presidential ratings, on 12.5%.
asserted
poll → conduct → %
Volodymyr Zelenskyy led with 25.2%, followed by Valerii Zaluzhnyi, the former commander-in-chief of the Ukrainian army, on 16.7%.
asserted
Zelenskyy → lead → %
Ihor Chalenko, a political scientist from the Center for Analysis and Strategies in Kyiv, says Fedorov's address was an attempt to consolidate the political capital he won during the protests.
asserted
he → say → protests
Even though Fedorov does not present a full election program in his video, Chalenko thinks he is calculating on positioning himself as an independent political player who could stand against Volodymyr Zelenskyy.
uncertain
who → present → Zelenskyy
The demonstrations started with the demand that Fedorov be reinstated as minister of defense.
asserted
Fedorov → start → defense
But the fear is that the spotlight has moved on from Fedorov, because the protest campaign became increasingly focussed on the fight against corruption and protecting the anti-corruption authorities.
asserted
campaign → move → authorities
So the former minister has decided to position himself politically and secure the status he attained," Chalenko said in an interview with DW.
asserted
Chalenko → decide → DW
However, Chalenko doesn't believe that Fedorov has shifted to "irreconcilable opposition" to Zelenskyy.
asserted
Fedorov → believe → Zelenskyy
While there is clearly a conflict between Fedorov and the president's inner circle, Chalenko doesn't see this as a permanent rift with the government, and he doesn't rule out a return for Fedorov were he to be offered a position.
Oleksiy Haran, a professor of political science at the Kyiv Mohyla Academy, thinks Fedorov's remarks about elections and a renewal of the power of state send an important signal.
asserted
remarks → be → signal
However, he too says he sees no decisive change in opposition to the president.
asserted
he → say → president
"We haven't heard any criticism at all of Zelenskyy," he told DW.
asserted
he → hear → DW
Demand for elections and change
Haran says Fedorov's speech expresses what the people want.
asserted
people → say → what
Polls show that Ukrainians do indeed want a change of government.
asserted
Ukrainians → show → government
However, the political scientist emphasizes that there is a problem: "We agree that Russia cannot dictate to us when and how we should hold elections.
asserted
we → emphasize → elections
But the question is: how should we hold elections if Russia continues the war?"
asserted
Russia → hold → war
He believes that in order to hold full elections a stable ceasefire is needed, at the very least, and this is precisely what Fedorov does not mention in his remarks.
asserted
Fedorov → believe → remarks
Vadym Denysenko, a political analyst at the Ukrainian thinktank Business Capital, believes Fedorov's speech is not an election campaign by one former minister but the start of a bigger political game.
asserted
speech → believe → game
In a Facebook post, Denysenko describes two developments he is observing one month after Fedorov's dismissal.
asserted
he → describe → dismissal
First, the social milieu he refers to as "Self-Help 3.0", which includes the anti-corruption movement, has found a political leader in Fedorov.
asserted
which → refer → Fedorov
Secondly, some of Zelenskyy's former followers have switched allegiance to Fedorov, and these, the analyst says, are now his strongest supporters.
asserted
analyst → switch → Fedorov
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
