Dr. Anthony Fauci invokes 5th Amendment, declining to answer questions at Senate hearing
Fauci, 85, had made several previous congressional appearances clashing with Sen. Rand Paul
Dr. Anthony Fauci on Wednesday invoked the Fifth Amendment and declined to answer questions from senators in a Republican-led committee hearing about his handling of the COVID-19 pandemic.
asserted
Fauci → invoke → pandemic
Fauci said it pained him to do so, but that he was acting on the advice of his counsel.
asserted
he → say → counsel
The move injects new drama into the lingering tensions between Fauci and Republican lawmakers over his handling of the coronavirus pandemic and accusations he lied about the origins of COVID-19, which he denies.
asserted
he → inject → which
Fauci was subpoenaed by the Senate's homeland security committee led by Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky, who has long had a fraught relationship with the now-retired infectious-disease expert.
asserted
who → subpoena → expert
Fauci, 85, was making at least his 20th appearance before a congressional committee since the emergence of the coronavirus.
asserted
Fauci → make → coronavirus
In his opening statement, Fauci said Paul has an "obvious obsession with calling for my prosecution."
asserted
Paul → say → prosecution
"The only conclusion I can reach is that the sole reason he is calling me before this committee is to prompt me to say something, anything, that could vindicate his repeated public pledges that I end up, in his words, 'behind bars.'
uncertain
I → reach → bars
"
Debate over presidential pardon
Fauci's decision to invoke the Fifth, at least for now, sidesteps calls for his prosecution.
asserted
decision → invoke → prosecution
Paul told Fauci that he may still face repercussions for obstructing a congressional investigation by refusing to testify.
uncertain
he → tell → investigation
That could include a contempt of Congress citation, which would be referred to the Justice Department for consideration.
uncertain
which → include → consideration
Fauci received what was viewed as a somewhat unprecedented pardon from then-president Joe Biden, covering the immunologist's activities in government between 2014 and Biden's last day in office in January 2025.
asserted
what → receive → January
Republicans contended that the pardon wouldn't apply to Wednesday's hearing.
asserted
pardon → contend → hearing
The U.S., despite a reputation for public health and medical research excellence, suffered many more COVID-19 deaths overall and on a per capita basis — more than 1.2 million people at last comprehensive count — than other G7 countries.
asserted
U.S. → suffer → countries
The U.S. has also seen more intense partisan divides over the years about the origins and handling of the pandemic, which was declared by the World Health Organization in March 2020.
asserted
which → see → March
Fauci warned by Republicans not to perjure himself in Congress appearance
asserted
Fauci → warn → appearance
Former Fauci adviser indicted for allegedly concealing communications related to COVID-19 research
Fauci, who helped lead the nation's COVID-19 response as medical adviser to U.S. President Donald Trump in his first administration, has become a target of Republican frustrations.
uncertain
who → indict → frustrations
Ahead of the hearing, Trump wrote on social media that he stopped relying on Fauci over the course of the pandemic because he felt Fauci made bad decisions on masks, shutdowns and other issues.
asserted
Fauci → write → masks
He received the Presidential Medal of Freedom from President George W. Bush for his work on HIV/AIDS research from its earliest days of discovery in the 1980s to helping implement the President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, considered one of the most impactful U.S. global health initiatives of all time.
asserted
He → receive → time
Leading up to the hearing, Paul released more than 1,000 pages of Fauci's personal diary covering the pandemic years, discovered on government computers by the Health and Human Services department and provided by Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
Some of the diary entries — including Fauci's uncertainty in the pandemic's earliest days as scientists around the world raced to understand the new virus and how best to curb it before vaccines could be created — already were reflected in a 2024 memoir and in interviews at the time.
uncertain
vaccines → lead → time
Other diary entries appeared designed to embarrass Fauci, as he appeared bemused in his writings by his sudden fame and sometimes awed by encounters with celebrities after the coronavirus emerged.
asserted
coronavirus → design → celebrities
"I think today's hearing does real damage," said Sen. Gary Peters of Michigan, the top Democrat on the panel.
asserted
Peters → think → panel
"It's attempting to turn one person into the scapegoat for a crisis that hundreds of officials across both the Trump and the Biden administration were responsible for handling.
asserted
hundreds → attempt → Trump
"
"This is only going to, unfortunately, deter other scientific experts from public service," Peters added, alluding to threats Fauci has received that have required him to have security protection for his family.
asserted
that → go → family
Paul in his opening statement sought to build the case that Fauci helped produce the COVID-19 pandemic by approving funding of research on virus mutations and then covered up his complicity.
asserted
Fauci → open → complicity
"Instead of an apology, you have for years avoided responsibility," Paul said.
asserted
Paul → avoid → responsibility
Paul later had one of Fauci's lawyers, David Schertler, ejected from the hearing.
asserted
one → have → hearing
In a statement, Schertler said Paul's accusations are "false and disgraceful, and we will examine all options to hold him accountable."
asserted
him → say → options
In a public letter, more than 150 infectious-disease experts and other scientists wrote that "no credible evidence has been produced to support these absurd charges" and that they are "urging our elected representatives in Congress stop these witch-hunts."
asserted
representatives → write → hunts
Angela Rasmussen, the U.S.-born virologist who works at the University of Saskatchewan, referred to it in a social media post as a "show trial" and a waste of taxpayer money.
asserted
who → work → money
Many scientists believe the COVID-19 virus most likely emerged in nature and jumped from animals to people, but Paul and many Republicans contend the virus might instead have leaked from a laboratory.
uncertain
virus → believe → laboratory
Origins of COVID-19 still unclear, according to final report from WHO expert group
We may never know where COVID originated.
uncertain
COVID → accord → group
Here's why
Fauci has long said publicly that he was open to both theories but that there's more evidence supporting COVID-19's natural origins.
The National Institutes of Health for years gave grants to a New York non-profit called EcoHealth Alliance, which used some of the funds to work with a Chinese lab studying coronaviruses commonly carried by bats.
asserted
which → say → bats
Fauci has previously stressed, including in a CBC interview, that it was "molecularly impossible" for those bat virus experiments to have turned into the pandemic virus.
asserted
experiments → stress → virus
The Aporia
