This story was originally published by Inside Climate News and is reproduced here as part of the Climate Desk collaboration.
asserted
story → publish → collaboration
In the Western Pacific, protections for endangered leatherback turtles face elimination.
asserted
protections → face → elimination
In Alaskan waters, Steller sea lion sanctuaries could soon shrink.
uncertain
sanctuaries → shrink → waters
And in the North Atlantic, gear designed to save right whales from fatal entanglements might be permanently scrapped.
uncertain
gear → design → entanglements
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) sent letters to the nation’s regional fisheries councils last month, directing all of them to dismantle restrictions in favor of more permissive, economically advantageous fishing procedures.
asserted
Oceanic → send → procedures
The “regional priorities” are an effort by the Department of Commerce to fulfill President Donald Trump’s “Restoring American Seafood Competitiveness” executive order, signed in April 2025.
asserted
priorities → fulfill → April
At stake are reassessments of marine protected areas (MPAs), the removal of species from conservation lists, changes to gear types and a wide array of expansions to commercial fishing operations.
asserted
reassessments → protect → operations
“These letters reflect the administration’s view that fish are just commodities, science doesn’t matter, and short-term economic gains (and political points) matter more than sustaining ocean ecosystems,” said Andrea Treece, the senior attorney in the Oceans Program at Earthjustice, in an email to Inside Climate News.
asserted
Treece → reflect → News
“They’re totally missing any sense of stewardship toward the ocean that supports all of us and belongs to all of us.
asserted
that → miss → us
The nine letters—sent to the eight fisheries management councils and one division for migratory species—were produced following consultation with hundreds of industry insiders and the management bodies themselves.
asserted
letters → send → insiders
Slashing decades of key environmental protections, they function like a deregulation wish list.
asserted
they → slash → list
Indeed, according to a press release from Eugenio Piñeiro Soler—who was appointed to oversee NOAA Fisheries just three days before Trump’s executive order—the new priorities are designed to “reduce burdens on domestic fishing, increase production, stabilize markets, improve access, and enhance economic profitability.”
uncertain
priorities → accord → profitability
All nine letters call for councils to reassess their fisheries management plans and “consider removing species that no longer require conservation and management.”
asserted
that → call → conservation
There was no clarity on what scientific determinations would be used to decide whether a species retained or lost its protections.
asserted
species → be → protections
Commercial stocks identified for management reform included: revising sardine stock definitions to “increase production” in the Pacific; moving management of spiny lobsters and queen conches in the Caribbean from the federal to the state level to “maximize yield”; and amending gear types and rules to allow fishermen to keep migratory bluefin tuna measuring less than 73 inches.
asserted
fishermen → identify → inches
“If the goal is seafood competitiveness, we need healthy fisheries,” said Elizabeth Cerny-Chipman, Ocean Conservancy’s policy manager for US fisheries and a former policy fellow at NOAA’s Office for Coastal Management.
asserted
Chipman → need → Management
“The focus is generally on shorter-term hot-button priorities when we know the focus really should be on long-term and science-based management.
asserted
focus → know → management
Three of the councils were also explicitly directed to remove or reduce marine protected areas.
asserted
Three → direct → areas
In the blue-jeweled waters west of Puerto Rico, NOAA is pressuring councils to expand fishing access into Tourmaline Bank and Abrir La Sierra—seasonal no-take zones that protect red hind spawning grounds and provide habitat for large snappers and groupers.
asserted
that → pressure → snappers
In New England, NOAA is now pushing the regional council to open “traditional fishing grounds” for the scallop fleet—the nation’s highest-value commercial fishery—in the northern part of Georges Bank, a productive fishing ground between Cape Cod and Nova Scotia.
asserted
NOAA → push → Cod
The agency is also recommending unleashing the clam dredge fleet—a highly destructive gear type that heavily disturbs the ocean bottom— into the Great South Channel, a habitat management area east of Nantucket.
asserted
that → recommend → Nantucket
“I think it’s stupid to think about opening the areas,” said Andrew Rosenberg, former deputy director of NOAA’s National Marine Fisheries Service who personally closed the scallop grounds his second week on the job as regional administrator in 1994.
asserted
who → think → 1994
“Those big areas have an abundance of scallops but that’s what’s keeping the whole fishery alive,” adding that these are complaints from an already profitable industry seeking more wealth.
asserted
these → have → wealth
Conservationists warn that removing species from conservation lists and reducing protected areas is short-sighted.
asserted
removing → warn → areas
“Protecting spawning grounds is Fisheries 101: If you want more big fish to catch, you have to let them make little fish, and scooping up the breeding adults while they’re trying to make the little fish is a great way to crash a fish population,” said Treece, explaining that regardless of stock recovery, MPAs remain essential to continually grow populations and support a healthy fishery.
asserted
MPAs → protect → fishery
Currently, the Hawaiʻi shallow-set longline fishery is closed for the year if 16 interactions are recorded between endangered leatherback turtles and industrial fishing operations.
asserted
interactions → close → turtles
NOAA is now moving to abolish that cap.
asserted
NOAA → move → cap
Off Alaska, populations of Steller sea lions declined by more than 80 percent prior to their listing as endangered in 1990 and the subsequent introduction of fishing closures around their rookeries—areas where they raise their pups.
asserted
they → decline → pups
While the Eastern population has steadily recovered, the Western population remains endangered and highly vulnerable to marine heat waves that impact reproductive rates.
asserted
that → recover → rates
Despite another Super El Niño highly likely this fall, NOAA is now calling to “modify and shrink closures” off Alaska to “improve access to fishing grounds.”
asserted
NOAA → call → grounds
Experts warn this could rob a struggling population of a safe refuge and, critically, undermine prey availability.
uncertain
this → warn → availability
Over 300,000 whales, dolphins and porpoises die every year from fishing gear entanglements.
asserted
whales → die → entanglements
And for decades, NOAA has been working to develop lobster traps that can rise to the surface without the need for permanent mooring lines—an attempt to better protect the last 350 North Atlantic right whales from getting caught in a maze of webbed water columns.
asserted
that → work → columns
While NOAA has claimed it will continue to promote and research such gear inventions, it is pushing to make implementation optional for fishermen or even halt the program altogether.
“Instead of blaming these creatures for trying to survive in their own habitat, we should be working towards more sustainable fishing practices, and figuring out how to support healthier fish populations so that humans and marine predators don’t have to compete for dwindling numbers of fish,” Treece said.
asserted
Treece → claim → fish
For the policy experts that Inside Climate News spoke with, the imposition of a top-down ordering of fisheries councils to enact policy change doesn’t just subvert standard procedure, it also defies NOAA’s purpose.
asserted
it → speak → purpose
Under the Magnuson-Stevens Act, regional councils retain the right to develop their own fishery management plans, while the agency’s role is to ensure adherence to legal requirements like preventing overfishing, minimizing bycatch and protecting habitats.
asserted
role → retain → habitats
“It’s a series of incoherent measures that don’t fit together in any policy,” said Rosenberg, who spent almost four decades navigating the council system.
asserted
who → ’ → system
“None of these measures do anything to improve sustainability.
asserted
None → do → sustainability
I didn’t see a single one that would improve sustainability.
asserted
that → see → sustainability
Some will make it worse.”
asserted
it → make → ?
…and 9 more, not listed.
The Aporia
