The top academic official at UCLA is being lambasted by his own community for standing up to a 9/11 event that featured the lawyer of terrorist ‘mastermind’ Khalid Sheikh Mohammed.
asserted
that → lambast → mastermind
UCLA chancellor Julio Frenk is facing heat from dozens of UCLA School of Law faculty who have demanded a retraction of the statement condemning the event and claimed it is “not befitting of a leader.”
asserted
it → face → leader
Frenk first told The California Post that he objected to the law school symposium, and backed UCLA professor Judea Pearl, father of terrorism victim Daniel Pearl, who had first condemned the occasion.
asserted
who → tell → occasion
“Speaking at UCLA should never be mistaken for the university’s approval, endorsement, or acceptance of an individual’s viewpoints, or our institution’s indifference to the pain their presence may cause members of our community,” he said.
uncertain
he → speak → community
“In this case, I understand why Professor Pearl and others are deeply hurt.
asserted
Pearl → understand → case
Judea’s voice, and the history behind it, deserve to be heard with the seriousness and humanity they demand.”
asserted
they → deserve → seriousness
A letter signed by 59 faculty members so far, including an assistant dean, defended the law school’s hosting of Mohammed’s lawyer, Melanie T. Partow.
asserted
letter → sign → lawyer
“The Chancellor’s statement also implicitly accepted the critique that the Symposium supported terrorism because it included as a panelist a government lawyer employed by the Trump Administration’s Department of Defense who was assigned to defend Mohammed,” they wrote.
asserted
they → accept → Mohammed
“Again, the Chancellor had no knowledge of what she actually contributed to the discussion.
asserted
she → have → discussion
In point of fact, her comments made no reference to any particular client.
asserted
comments → make → client
They focused entirely on the unique processes and ever-evolving adjudicatory structure that the military has set for trying these cases,” the letter added.
asserted
letter → focus → cases
“For the Chancellor to affiliate himself with these disparaging attacks against the Symposium instead of verifying what it was actually about is not befitting of a leader.”
asserted
it → affiliate → leader
Frenk recently doubled down on his criticism in a response to the school’s Academic Senate, which also expressed concern about his rebuke.
asserted
which → double → rebuke
But he sought to soften suggestions that he slammed the law school.
asserted
he → seek → school
“I chose the words of my statement carefully and deliberately,” he said.
asserted
he → choose → statement
“Some subsequent accounts have characterized it as a condemnation, rebuke or repudiation of the symposium.
asserted
accounts → characterize → symposium
A careful read of my statement will fail to find any of those words.
asserted
read → fail → words
Furthermore, the statement did not criticize the School of Law or question the validity of legal representation, including for individuals accused of horrific acts.”
asserted
statement → criticize → acts
A rep for Frenk told The California Post that the chancellor’s statement was “absolutely a condemnation” of the 9/11 event when asked if the academic leader’s statement was in fact a condemnation.
asserted
statement → tell → fact
“The key point of my statement is that we can uphold academic freedom while also expressing support for members of our community who are hurting.
asserted
who → uphold → community
It is a community, and community carries with it obligations of reciprocity,” Frenk concluded.
asserted
Frenk → carry → reciprocity
A wider open letter featuring more than 200 signatories, including professors from Stanford and Harvard, also pushed Frenk for a retraction.
“The implication in the Chancellor’s statement that the conference may have endorsed antisemitism and terrorism is not only inaccurate, but it also compounds the risks faced by lawyers and scholars engaged in work that is key to the functioning of legal institutions,” the letter says.
uncertain
letter → feature → institutions
The elite institution’s law school hosted the “25 Years After 9/11: Reimagining Freedom, Justice, and Security” event on Sept. 10 and 11 featuring Partow and other left-wing minds, including a Yale professor who once referred to counterterrorism as a “racist gravy train.”
asserted
who → host → train
The tone-deaf event came as UCLA has faced lawsuits from the Trump administration over allegedly failing to address antisemitism on campus or protect Jewish students and Israeli employees.
uncertain
UCLA → come → students
Victims decried the event.
asserted
Victims → decry → event
“It’s absolutely absurd,” Jim McCaffrey, an FDNY lieutenant at the time of the attacks who responded to the Twin Towers, told the California Post.
asserted
who → ’ → Post
“They’re pointing fingers at the victims.
asserted
They → point → victims
We’re the bad guys for being attacked.
asserted
We → ’re → ?
It’s mind-boggling.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
What’s going on in academia?”
asserted
What → go → academia
Judea Pearl, 90, said the appearance of Partow made him “ashamed of my university,” as he accused it of “weaponizing” the 25th anniversary of the terror attacks.
asserted
he → say → attacks
Daniel Pearl, a Wall Street Journal reporter, was decapitated by 9/11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed in Pakistan in 2002 after being lured there for a supposed interview with an Islamic scholar.
asserted
Pearl → decapitate → scholar
Frenk became UCLA’s seventh chancellor in January 2025.
asserted
Frenk → become → January
The Aporia
