Elected officials see angry voters cram into local meeting rooms and line streets to oppose data centers and feel an irresistible urge to cater to the populist anger.
asserted
voters → elect → anger
The next thing they do is hit the pause button.
asserted
they → do → button
However, leadership requires thinking through consequences.
asserted
leadership → require → consequences
Moratoria on new data center construction will arrest innovation, cede the future of artificial intelligence to Beijing, and threaten our national security.
asserted
Moratoria → arrest → security
Blanket opposition deprives hardworking Americans of hundreds of millions of dollars in future wages per year.
asserted
opposition → deprive → year
It shackles the most vibrant sector in commercial construction and eliminates a tax revenue lifeline that is currently funding local police departments, roads, and teacher salaries in counties across the nation.
asserted
that → shackle → nation
If Democrats want to regain the trust of the American people, we must have a defined vision for the future that brings prosperity to all – not just the ultra-rich – and we have to be for something not just saying, "No."
asserted
we → want → something
We need to offer a constructive solution that doesn't succumb to fearmongering, and prove that the party of the New Deal, the Great Society and the Apollo program is the party of solutions and sound policy, not demagoguery.
asserted
party → need → solutions
Today, our party’s message is controlled by a vocal minority who don’t understand – or perhaps care – about the facts.
asserted
who → control → facts
In New York State in July, for instance, Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul imposed a statewide moratorium on new data center construction.
asserted
Hochul → impose → construction
A growing number of local jurisdictions are taking similar action.
asserted
number → grow → action
In Congress, Independent Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders and New York Democratic Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez are proposing a national moratorium.
asserted
Sanders → propose → moratorium
Have they considered that without data centers, the internet, their path to fame and national stature, is essentially useless?
asserted
path → consider → fame
The tech industry would collapse and the economy would enter a tailspin.
asserted
economy → collapse → tailspin
In lieu of letting states lead the way with blunt-force moratoria, we should develop national- or state-level Centers of Excellence that would provide every county board and municipal zoning authority the knowledge to make informed, transparent decisions.
asserted
that → let → decisions
Those local governing bodies should absolutely listen to their constituents, be mindful of their many concerns, but above all, they need to give as much weight to facts as to emotions.
asserted
they → govern → emotions
It isn’t data centers driving up residential rates but a combination of issues with our aging power grid, President Donald Trump’s pointless war in Iran, and the ongoing war in Ukraine.
asserted
centers → drive → Ukraine
The data center industry has agreed to supply its own power or pay for grid upgrades.
asserted
industry → agree → upgrades
The White House’s Ratepayer Protection Pledge now has 200 signatories resolving to find policy solutions.
asserted
Pledge → have → solutions
If data center and technology companies want to pay for the grid upgrades, let them.
asserted
them → want → upgrades
Multiple studies show that under a well-designed rate policy, such as the new rate for Virginia’s Dominion Energy large-load customers, data centers pay as much or more in fees than the cost of the energy they consume, precluding the need for rate hikes while providing extra funds for grid upgrades and additional generation online, including nuclear and renewables.
asserted
they → show → nuclear
Americans alarmed about water used to cool servers should know data centers’ consumption is a drop in the bucket compared to residential lawn irrigation, household plumbing leaks and golf courses.
asserted
consumption → alarm → irrigation
Here in Virginia, a state legislative committee found "most data centers use about the same amount of water or less as an average large office building."
asserted
centers → find → building
Newer data centers use treated sewage or closed-loop systems recycling water over and over again.
asserted
centers → use → water
These are all decisions that localities should mandate, without giving up the construction jobs, the permanent jobs and the local tax revenue.
asserted
localities → mandate → jobs
Communities also worry data centers’ backup diesel generators are dirty and noisy.
asserted
generators → worry → ?
But these generators typically run only about 20 hours per year (or three minutes per day) for maintenance and testing.
asserted
generators → run → maintenance
According to the EPA, the air in Northern Virginia – a data center hub – is the cleanest in decades.
uncertain
air → accord → decades
In addition to facts, skeptics need to weigh the merits of prudent planning.
asserted
skeptics → need → planning
Well-conceived development must limit data centers to land properly zoned for their use.
asserted
development → conceive → use
Unfortunately, in Loudoun County, my home for the past 26 years, the Board of Supervisors made a poor decision to permit data centers in areas previously zoned for some office space within residential areas.
asserted
Board → make → areas
The data center developers and the union labor building the data centers follow the rules, even bad ones.
asserted
developers → build → rules
Ultimately, the debate over data centers comes down to one question: Are they net contributors to our communities?
asserted
they → come → communities
For an answer, don’t just look at the tax revenue – look at the high-paying union jobs that are creating a new middle class – employees who are able to buy a home at 28 instead of 41 – jobs that pay $45 to $60 per hour.
asserted
that → look → hour
A 2025 PwC study found the industry contributed $162.7 billion in federal, state, and local taxes in 2023 alone.
asserted
industry → find → 2023
Here in Virginia’s Loudoun County, data centers take up 2% of our land but yield 38% of tax revenue.
asserted
centers → take → revenue
In Mecklenburg County, local officials built the first new school in 75 years with data center proceeds.
asserted
officials → build → proceeds
Data centers’ role in providing jobs and funding public services put the tax incentive debate in a more realistic context than the false claim that the industry receives unmerited "handouts."
uncertain
industry → provide → handouts
In Virginia this year, for instance, Gov. Abigail Spanberger and Democrats in the legislature came under pressure to kill a data center tax exemption common to all industrial companies.
asserted
Spanberger → come → companies
Then, the unions came to Richmond in May to express their support for the exemption, because data center investments supported 113,000 highly skilled, well-paying jobs in Virginia alone.
uncertain
investments → come → Virginia
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
