A federal judge has ordered Donald Trump’s administration to give at least 30 days’ notice before moving to demolish the John F Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts after the US president warned that it could be “ripped down”.
uncertain
it → order → Arts
US district judge Christopher Cooper issued the order on Thursday after lawyers for Democratic congresswoman Joyce Beatty submitted evidence of Trump’s comments and sought clarification over whether the building could be closed or bulldozed.
uncertain
building → issue → clarification
Trump said on Wednesday that his administration deserved recognition for its efforts to renovate the Kennedy Center, including by putting his name on the national arts complex in Washington.
asserted
administration → say → Washington
“I think that the Trump administration should certainly have recognition because, frankly, if we don’t do that, it’s going to close,” he told reporters in Charlotte, North Carolina.
asserted
he → think → Charlotte
“It’ll end up being ripped down.”
asserted
It → end → ?
The Kennedy Center was established by Congress as a living memorial to slain president John F Kennedy and opened in 1971.
asserted
Center → establish → 1971
It has hosted many of the world’s leading performers and run numerous educational programmes.
asserted
It → host → programmes
But the centre shut down this week following claims of serious structural deterioration and its board has voted to close it for up to two years for a $257m renovation.
uncertain
board → shut → renovation
Matt Floca, the centre’s executive director and chief operating officer, said in a court filing that the building had been closed for at least seven days to assess “acute risks to public safety resulting from continued structural deterioration”.
asserted
building → operate → deterioration
He said the temporary closure followed an inspection of the roof terrace canopy and a partial ceiling collapse earlier this month, and was separate from the longer-term renovation plans.
asserted
closure → say → plans
The administration has said the seven-day closure does not breach an earlier court order restricting its ability to shut the centre.
asserted
closure → say → centre
Beatty, an ex-officio member of the Kennedy Center board, has challenged Trump’s takeover of the institution and his attempts to put his name on the building.
asserted
Beatty → challenge → building
Her lawyers argued that the temporary closure could become a permanent shutdown lasting two years, which they said would violate the court’s previous orders.
uncertain
they → argue → orders
They also submitted an Agence France-Presse (AFP) photograph showing Trump onboard Air Force One apparently looking at a placard bearing the words “Kennedy Center DEMOLISHED”.
asserted
Trump → submit → words
The final letters were obscured by the aircraft’s window frame and the image does not establish that demolition was being planned.
asserted
demolition → obscure → frame
The photo, taken by the AFP photographer Brendan Smialowski as Trump returned to Washington from North Carolina, was widely circulated on social media and included in Beatty’s court filing.
asserted
Trump → take → filing
Cooper rejected Beatty’s request for an emergency hearing but ordered the administration to provide at least 30 days’ notice before taking any steps towards demolition.
asserted
Cooper → reject → demolition
The administration is expected to ask the judge to dissolve an earlier order so it can proceed with what it describes as necessary restoration and renovation work.
asserted
it → expect → work
Cooper ruled on Tuesday that the Kennedy Center could not put Trump’s name on its exterior without congressional approval.
uncertain
Center → rule → approval
Trump’s name had previously been added to the facade by the board but was removed in June following an earlier ruling by the judge.
asserted
name → add → judge
The board had proposed wording describing the building as the “John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts Restored and Renovated By President Donald J. Trump”, as well as renaming the plaza and adding further recognition if a Trump Kennedy Center fund reached $100m.
Those proposals were rejected by Cooper, who said changes to the institution’s name required Congress’s approval.
asserted
changes → propose → approval
Trump has argued that the centre has been badly maintained and would require substantial government subsidy to remain open.
asserted
centre → argue → subsidy
“It’s in very, very bad shape, very dangerous shape,” he said.
asserted
he → ’ → shape
“You see steel falling down.
asserted
steel → see → ?
You see plaster falling off ceilings.
asserted
plaster → see → ceilings
You see a lot of dangers.”
asserted
You → see → dangers
Beatty has accused Trump and his board of using the closure to circumvent the court’s orders.
asserted
Beatty → accuse → orders
In a statement, she said the Kennedy Center was “a sacred, living memorial to President Kennedy” and said she would continue efforts to prevent it being “shuttered, or demolished”.
asserted
it → say → efforts
Hakeem Jeffries, the House Democratic leader, also criticised the plans, saying Democrats would find a way to “stop the president from another vanity project and waste of taxpayer resources”.
asserted
Democrats → criticise → resources
Trump installed himself as the chair of the Kennedy Center last year after removing its previous leadership and replacing board members with his own appointees.
asserted
Trump → instal → appointees
It has since become one of several Washington institutions and landmarks at the centre of his efforts to reshape the capital and attach his name to major projects.
asserted
It → become → projects
On Thursday Barbra Streisand, a Kennedy Center honoree in 2008, questioned the closing of the center for repairs and called the controversy surrounding its operation “galling and painful to witness”.
asserted
Streisand → question → operation
Of Trump’s attempts to add his name to the centre, she said in a statement to the Associated Press: “You can easily imagine my indignation at seeing this revered institution become the subject of such a bitter struggle over one man’s name and unchecked ego.”
asserted
institution → add → name
The Aporia
