Having broken Canada’s immigration system, the Liberal government intends to “fix” it by granting another 662,000 new permanent resident permits for 2027.
asserted
government → break → 2027
RBC Economics says next year’s target will represent “the highest annual intake on record,” despite overall low wage growth and persistently high unemployment among young Canadians.
asserted
target → say → Canadians
The C.D. Howe Institute’s assessment was blunt: “Rather than addressing past mistakes,” Ottawa has introduced “yet another one-time measure” with uncertain economic benefits.
asserted
Ottawa → address → benefits
With 2.9 million temporary resident visas expiring or set to expire between 2025 and 2026, plus up to 500,000 people already living here illegally, it might no longer be possible to take “back control of immigration” — despite Prime Minister Mark Carney’s 18 months’ worth of promises to the contrary.
uncertain
it → expire → contrary
And it’s not as though Carney is responding to popular support for jumbo immigration numbers.
asserted
Carney → ’ → numbers
According to a recent Nanos Research survey, a majority of Canadians want the government to accept fewer — not more — immigrants and temporary residents next year.
uncertain
government → accord → immigrants
(Could the prime minister’s interest in the Century Initiative, which aims to increase Canada’s population to 100 million by 2100, have more bearing on Liberal policy than we knew?)
uncertain
we → aim → policy
In its annual review of public opinion on immigration and refugees, Environics (whose survey found Canadians are split on the question of whether to accept more immigrants) found that among those who oppose increasing immigration, key concerns include higher unemployment, higher housing prices and the risk “that immigrants are a drain on public finances” or a “threat to Canadian identity.”
asserted
immigrants → find → identity
A majority of Canadians surveyed, 57 per cent, agreed “too many immigrants are not adopting Canadian values.”
asserted
immigrants → survey → values
And this view was widespread irrespective of racial identity or immigration status: 60 per cent of racialized Canadians and a majority of first-, second- and third-generation immigrants agreed with the statement in the Environics survey.
asserted
cent → agree → survey
Ottawa will work with provinces to decide how to divvy up the extra 100,000 permanent resident spots set aside in 2027 for temporary foreign w…
asserted
Ottawa → work → w
Ottawa will work with provinces to decide how to divvy up the extra 100,000 permanent resident spots set aside in 2027 for temporary foreign w…
asserted
Ottawa → work → w
Second-generation immigrants were the most strident in their views — which makes sense, given what was expected of their parents when they arrived in Canada in, say, the early 1950s.
asserted
they → make → 1950s
If you wanted your brother or sister to come to Canada in that era, you needed to sign a formal “Affidavit of Sponsorship and Financial Undertaking” outlining your employment, housing situation and financial capacity.
asserted
you → want → employment
With no taxpayer-funded social safety net to rely upon, you were legally bound to feed and clothe your sibling in the event they lost their job following their arrival to Canada.
asserted
they → fund → Canada
And there was little chance of bringing an aging parent, given the potential financial burden they would pose to the state.
asserted
they → be → state
CPP, GIS, and universal health care eventually arrived, and later free dental care and $10 daycare, but it came at a price
asserted
it → arrive → price
: successful second-generation immigrants have seen the top marginal income tax rate rise, from 46 per cent to almost 55 per cent, over the past 15 years, for example.
asserted
rate → see → example
These parents know their kids are taking home less of what they’ve earned, all in the name of a just society.
asserted
they → know → society
I’m confident that Canadians support immigration as they once knew it, which is why the government should resist normalizing the immigration status of a bunch of low-skilled twentysomething men.
asserted
government → ’m → men
While that might be good for Toronto’s Uber Eats customers, such moves won’t alleviate Ontario’s shortage of 25,000 registered nurses.
uncertain
moves → alleviate → nurses
A partial solution to restoring broad support for our immigration system would be to return to first principles and reform the very foundation of the permanent resident program.
asserted
solution → restore → program
What’s the point of handing out a million new PR permits over the next 24 months if these lucky individuals are required to spend only 146 days per year in Canada over the next five years, as is currently the case?
asserted
individuals → ’ → years
Let’s change that back to at least 181 days per year in Canada (as was the law for decades) and ensure they’re taxed as residents.
asserted
they → let → residents
How can we benefit from their “needed skills” if they’re spending 60 per cent of the calendar year working or travelling abroad?
asserted
they → benefit → year
Unlike in the United States, where the Green Card permanent residency program expires after 10 years, PR in Canada is for life.
asserted
PR → expire → life
When the new targets were announced, Carney said temporary residents have been working for the same employers and living in the same communities for years, making them permanent residents “in all respects.”
asserted
them → announce → respects
One key step toward restoring confidence in the immigration system would be to require “permanent residents” to spend at least 181 days per year in Canada (as was the case for decades) and to be taxed as residents.
asserted
step → restore → residents
If these workers are truly essential to “Build Canada Strong,” then prove it.
asserted
workers → build → it
Surely it’s not too much to require our new peers to actually live and pay tax in Canada?
asserted
it → ’ → Canada