A peak body representing Australian artists has called on councils to regulate the use of generative AI in public installations, after a new Brisbane mural attracted widespread condemnation.
asserted
mural → represent → condemnation
Upgrades at the Bulimba Library include a kids’ reading nook mocked up with nautical decorations and panels showing Brisbane’s CBD.
asserted
Upgrades → include → CBD
The images are riddled with unusual details, including a cockatoo with three wings, a seagull with a cockatoo’s beak, and illegible writing on a CityCat.
asserted
images → riddle → CityCat
The layout of the city does not reflect reality, with major landmarks on the wrong side of the river.
asserted
layout → reflect → river
Artist Sophie Beer called it “AI slop”.
asserted
Beer → call → it
Brisbane City Council later confirmed it had been produced with AI, but added it would be replaced once a local artist could be commissioned.
uncertain
artist → confirm → AI
Penelope Benton, the executive director at the National Association for the Visual Arts (NAVA), said on Wednesday human artists needed to be at the forefront of all public art projects, adding she was disappointed by the mural.
“Public art is work, and artists should be paid to do it – that shouldn’t change because AI can generate an image in seconds,” she told this masthead.
asserted
she → say → masthead
“If a council can’t afford to pay an artist, don’t install a mural.
asserted
council → afford → mural
You just don’t need to do that.”
asserted
You → need → that
Benton said she didn’t believe a mural being temporary justified not engaging professional artists, saying: “Temporary artworks can also be commissioned.”
asserted
artworks → say → artists
She said the use of AI in public art “absolutely” needed to be regulated, and she called for local governments to incorporate a NAVA framework still being drafted into their art-commissioning policies.
asserted
governments → say → policies
“None of us are anti-AI, but there has to be an approach to this technology … that considers human creativity and an artist’s right to earn a living from their work.
asserted
that → have → work
“I wouldn’t say that AI [should] be strictly forbidden … because artists are also experimenting.
asserted
artists → say → ?
“There are some good practices that we’d be encouraging … that is, that a real human artist is engaged to make the work, and not just an administrator plugging in a prompt … it would be an artist driving that process and feeding it in.
asserted
it → be → it
It would just be respecting artists’ copyright.”
asserted
It → respect → copyright
Doctor Simon Degroot, program director for the bachelor of visual arts at Griffith University’s Queensland College of Art and Design, said the installation was “bland” and reminded him of AI-generated restaurant photos.
asserted
installation → say → photos
“It doesn’t seem to be an artwork that would be a cultural addition to liven up a space, but rather a very one-dimensional prompt outcome,” he said.
asserted
he → seem → space
“There are things that are not quite right with the image, and that is, to me, a reminder of the omnipresence of AI …
asserted
that → be → AI
I think that’s made more problematic in … a children’s reading space, which is all about opening up creative minds and imagination.
asserted
which → think → minds
“It’s not a space where you want to be reminded all the time that AI is an increasingly ever-present part of our daily life, and I think for that reason, that probably is why it’s such a hard, high backlash.”
asserted
it → ’ → reason
The chair of the Brisbane City Council customer services committee, Jamboree Ward councillor Sarah Hutton, spoke of the Bulimba Library site’s long arts history at a meeting on November 3.
asserted
chair → speak → November
Hutton touted a mural in the courtyard by artist Ryan Barwick, inspired by the history of Bulimba.
asserted
Hutton → tout → Bulimba
She also posted online about a mural downstairs.
asserted
She → post → mural
Ironically, the Bulimba Library is on the former site of the Bulimba School of Arts, which was built in 1887.
asserted
which → build → 1887
The building was taken over by the council in the 1960s, and demolished in 1982.
asserted
building → take → 1982
In the council meeting, Hutton said the library “had outgrown” the building by the 1980s, and reopened in its current form in 1985.
asserted
library → say → 1985
In the same meeting, council’s Labor opposition leader, Jared Cassidy, criticised the sanctioning of AI use in council’s Brisbane Portrait Prize.
asserted
leader → criticise → Prize