Photo via Astral Codex Ten

Varieties Of Discourseposting

Read the original at Astral Codex Ten ↗
Cite

Alexander, S. (2026, November 18). Varieties Of Discourseposting. Astral Codex Ten. https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/varieties-of-discourseposting

Dated from the outlet's own feed. Check the original for its byline.

Astral Codex Ten · collected 2026-11-18 · by Scott Alexander commentary

Quick Summary

The author discusses their teaching experience at the Inkhaven blogging fellowship, where they presented poorly written sentences for analysis. They mention a fellow instructor, Naomi Kanakia, who taught a controversial course on “discourseposting.” The piece then shifts to a comparison between different types of sexual needs and applies a similar analysis to the dynamics between writers and their audiences in discourseposting. The author suggests understanding the psychological motivations behind writing and reading to better grasp why certain content is produced and consumed, particularly in the context of online discourse and ideological confirmation.
Written by AI on 2026-11-18, from this article's own text only.

AI analysis

Why this leaning score
This article does not take a side on a contested political question, so it has no leaning score. That is an answer rather than a gap: a match report or a rescue can be warmly or critically written without being left or right, and scoring it anyway is how approval of a subject gets recorded as a political position.
No political leaning scored for article 162948 · logged 2026-11-18

Compared with similar articles

Nothing to compare against. No article is close enough to this one for the pipeline to have linked or judged the pair.
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
62
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
2%
1 of 62 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
not measured
these signals count newsroom corrections; Commentary has none to count
Outlets on this story
unclustered
not grouped into a story yet
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-11-18 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Astral Codex Ten · 73 article(s) · 4 correction(s) detected
No corrections detected for this publisher. That may mean careful reporting, or simply that nothing has been checked.

Who wrote this

Scott Alexander
56 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
In an ideal world, writers would write to convince others, and audiences would read to learn something and change their minds.
2026-11-18 · assertive framing · Varieties Of Discourseposting
Voting will close end of day on Friday, November 20.
2026-11-14 · assertive framing · Vote In The 2026 Book Review Contest
You may remember stories of bitter unionization battles at places like Starbucks, but AI workers are likely to route around that.
2026-11-12 · mixed framing · AI Company Employees Should Unionize
One of the leading AI superforecaster companies, FutureSearch, is hiring.
2026-11-02 · assertive framing · Open Thread 458
A picaresque (broadly speaking) is about a lowlife wandering around having comical misadventures; Huckleberry Finn (1884) would be a notable American example.
2026-10-30 · assertive framing · Your Book Review: The History And Adventures Of An Atom
On average, commenters will end up spotting evidence that around two or three of the links in each links post are wrong or misleading.
2026-10-29 · assertive framing · Links For October 2026
California State Propositions Proposition 1: Authorizes $11.25 billion in bonds to build affordable housing Supporters claim it will build (or renovate) 40,000 homes; I asked an AI superforecaster1 to predict the true number, and it guessed that 22,000 would actually get built.
2026-10-28 · assertive framing · My California Ballot, 2026
I may have more of these in the upcoming week.
2026-10-19 · assertive framing · Open Thread 456
[This is one of the finalists in the 2026 book review contest, written by an ACX reader who will remain anonymous until after voting is done.
2026-10-17 · assertive framing · Your Book Review: Storm Of Steel
AI companies like Anthropic and OpenAI have long mentioned the possibility that their products could be existentially dangerous, but this has recently crescendoed into even more dire warnings, including suggestions that we have to pace the frontier, ie coordinate to slow AI progress.
2026-10-15 · assertive framing · AI Safety Is Not A Corporate Plot
Also by Scott Alexander
Open Thread 460
2026-11-17 · Astral Codex Ten
Vote In The 2026 Book Review Contest
2026-11-14 · Astral Codex Ten
AI Company Employees Should Unionize
2026-11-12 · Astral Codex Ten
Open Thread 458
2026-11-02 · Astral Codex Ten
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 56 articles by Scott Alexander →

Topics

Inkhaven Inkhaven Fight Club Voxsplainer

Subjects

Skub ORG · 3× America GPE · 1× Inkhaven ORG · 1× Inkhaven Fight Club ORG · 1× Naomi Kanakia PERSON · 1× Naomi Kanakia’s PERSON · 1× Voxsplainer ORG · 1×

Narrative

Common solutions include attacking an obsolete position on its way out (“Some people say that homosexuality is evil, but I think it should be tolerated!”) a position which is popular in communities far away from yours (“Some people say we should institute sharia law, but I’m against that!”), or a position which is technically true but has such terrible vibes that nobody wants to stand up for it (“Some people say that intelligence matters a lot in life, but I believe it’s creativity which is really important!”) Your audience is people with the same psychological need, who are less good at finding seemingly-controversial-but-actually-popular positions, and are happy to mooch off your work by agreeing that you are so, so brave. The Revenge Killing:
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-11-18
In an ideal world, writers would write to convince others, and audiences would read to learn something and change their minds.
2026-11-18 · Astral Codex Ten
Varieties Of Discourseposting · assertive framing

Claims (62 extracted, 1 hedged)

I’m teaching at the Inkhaven blogging fellowship again this month. asserted
I → teach → fellowship
In my first class, I showed off terribly-written sentences and made the fellows analyze and improve them. asserted
fellows → show → them
Some were my own miscreations, some were Lyttle Lytton winners, and some came from the darkest abysses of the Internet. asserted
some → come → Internet
The audience’s favorite was overwrought description of women’s breasts from erotica (one person pointed out that my PDF reader’s Recent History tab helpfully displayed porn story titles while I presented on screen - why does a PDF reader even have a Recent History tab? - so I hope my humiliation helped educate you). asserted
humiliation → point → you
But I hear that Naomi Kanakia’s class was even spicier. asserted
class → hear → ?
She taught a course on “discourseposting”, which naturally descended into fiery discourse (Naomi Kanakia, you are WRONG about Discourseposting!!!, Inkhaven Fight Club). asserted
you → teach → Discourseposting
I didn’t get a chance to listen, so in the grand tradition of discourseposting, I’ll argue about it without having seen the source material. asserted
I → get → material
Sticking to our porn theme, and in the spirit of The Last Psychiatrist: one way to classify sex is through its external manifestations: positions, toys, fetishes. asserted
way → stick → manifestations
But another is through which psychological need it fulfills. asserted
it → fulfill → need
The need to reenact a traumatic childhood, only this time, the Other really loves you. asserted
Other → reenact → you
In the same way, we can supplement our superficial categorizations of discourseposting with the types of writer-audience dynamic that make each post exist. asserted
post → supplement → dynamic
In an ideal world, writers would write to convince others, and audiences would read to learn something and change their minds. asserted
audiences → write → minds
But few people enjoy trying to convince others, and even fewer enjoy reading with an open mind and letting themselves be convinced. asserted
themselves → enjoy → mind
The conjunction of the two is like that murder case where the guy with the getting-eaten-by-cannibals fetish was dating the guy with the cannibalism fetish and they both, uh, achieved gains from trade. asserted
they → eat → trade
It just requires the conjunction of two rare types of people. asserted
It → require → people
Sometimes you get this in the blogosphere, and it’s great. asserted
it → get → blogosphere
But you wouldn’t want to sustain a national publication off of it. asserted
you → want → it
I usually support taking things at face value - better underpsychologize than overpsychologize - but some of the norms and genre conventions divide more naturally by guilty motive than innocent appearance, so we can go over these in more depth. asserted
we → support → depth
Your best bet will be to keep track of who the intended audience is (rarely the person it’s addressed to!) and what it’s doing for them. asserted
it → keep → them
Your audience is people who already agree with you, or who are overdetermined to agree with you once they know that the issue exists (e.g. anti-corporate leftists, being informed that some new corporation is also bad). asserted
corporation → agree → you
Their psychological need is for a smart-sounding person to validate their opinion and tell them that it is factually based. asserted
it → sound → them
You’ll know you fulfilled it because they’ll say something like “I always knew something like this was true, but you put it into words so eloquently.” asserted
you → know → words
A smart-sounding person reassures their audience that their hatred is completely valid. asserted
hatred → reassure → audience
“You thought Skub supporters were slimy, but you don’t know the half of it! asserted
you → think → it
The latest news shows that they’re death cultists who want you to undergo constant humiliation rituals as the price of living in America.” asserted
you → show → America
The Brutal Takedown combines the comfort of black-and-white certainty, with the group bonding of sharing a common enemy, with the frisson that maybe some Skub supporter is reading along, feeling angry and triggered and ashamed. asserted
supporter → combine → frisson
It carries an apocalyptic promise that it’s just a couple of days before the preference cascade starts, and all right-thinking people band together to exile Skub supporters from society forever and accord you high status for being so right about this. The Marching Orders: Your audience is people who are less cool than you. asserted
who → carry → you
Their psychological need is to learn what position the cool and powerful people support, so that they can be sure to hold it, and not end up in the scary position of taking the opposite side from cool powerful people. asserted
they → learn → people
They wouldn’t put it in these terms, exactly. asserted
They → put → terms
But they forgot to develop the brain lobe that distinguishes “cool, powerful position” from “correct position”, so they need a little help figuring out what position is coolrect. asserted
position → forget → help
The Virtue Signal: Your psychological need is to signal that you’re a good person. asserted
you → signal → Signal
You can’t take a genuinely controversial position wouldn’t help, because then the people who disagreed with you wouldn’t know you were good. asserted
you → take → you
But you can’t take an obviously popular position either, because nobody will applaud you for saying “People shouldn’t be murdered” or some similar pablum. asserted
People → take → you
So you need to find a position which feels controversial, but in fact is popular. asserted
which → need → fact
Common solutions include attacking an obsolete position on its way out (“Some people say that homosexuality is evil, but I think it should be tolerated!”) a position which is popular in communities far away from yours (“Some people say we should institute sharia law, but I’m against that!”), or a position which is technically true but has such terrible vibes that nobody wants to stand up for it (“Some people say that intelligence matters a lot in life, but I believe it’s creativity which is really important!”) Your audience is people with the same psychological need, who are less good at finding seemingly-controversial-but-actually-popular positions, and are happy to mooch off your work by agreeing that you are so, so brave. The Revenge Killing: asserted
you → include → Killing
Your psychological need is that somebody else has insulted you, probably incidentally while trying one of the maneuvers above. asserted
somebody → insult → maneuvers
Your goal is to retaliate by proving they are more wrong than anyone has ever been before. asserted
anyone → retaliate → ?
Your audience’s psychological need is to get vicarious pleasure out of your victory, same as they would if their hometown sports team beat their bitter rival. asserted
team → get → rival
Some people claim to be anti-Skub. uncertain
people → claim → ?
Little do they know that anti-Skubness, as it currently exists, is itself a form of Skub, a loyal opposition created to distract people from the true points at issue. asserted
it → know → issue
…and 22 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support