The Donald Trump-shaped hole at the heart of the Quad has finally been filled.
asserted
hole → shape → Quad
A grouping that had looked to be limping along aimlessly is showing signs of a renewed sense of purpose and direction.
asserted
that → look → purpose
Since it emerged from efforts to respond to the Indian Ocean tsunami of 2004, the four-nation partnership of India, the United States, Japan and Australia has been bursting with possibility: four maritime democracies working together to get important things done in the Indo-Pacific.
asserted
things → emerge → Pacific
The first Trump administration elevated its importance and Joe Biden went further by introducing annual leaders-level meetings.
asserted
Biden → elevate → meetings
Truth be told, the Quad has usually delivered worthy-but-unremarkable initiatives rather than blockbuster outcomes.
asserted
Quad → tell → outcomes
It is not a military alliance like NATO, and it lacks the formal structure of more established groupings like ASEAN or the Pacific Islands Forum.
asserted
it → lack → ASEAN
But its symbolism is powerful and its potential to become a meaningful military partnership is profound.
asserted
potential → become → ?
That’s why China has long despised the Quad, branding it an exclusive clique reminiscent of the Cold War era.
asserted
China → ’ → era
Since returning to office last year, Donald Trump has shown no personal interest in the Quad, reflecting his lack of focus on geostrategic competition with Beijing.
asserted
Trump → return → Beijing
Secretary of State Marco Rubio, by contrast, has made the grouping a priority and has accelerated the Quad’s activities at the foreign minister level.
asserted
grouping → make → level
But the lack of leader-level attention has lowered the Quad’s profile and provided ammunition to its critics.
asserted
lack → lower → critics
Given the low status Trump has accorded the grouping, the fact he agreed to participate in his first Quad leaders’ summit in Manila on Tuesday night was an achievement in itself.
asserted
he → give → itself
Crucially, there was substance as well as showmanship: the leaders confirmed that next year their nations’ patrol aircraft will fly together in a maritime exercise for the first time in a Quad context.
asserted
aircraft → be → context
Lavina Lee, the director of the United States Studies Centre’s Foreign Policy and Defence Program at the University of Sydney, was pleasantly surprised by the first Quad summit of the second Trump administration.
asserted
Lee → surprise → administration
“For a few years, the Quad was drifting: there were too many working groups and seemingly no real progress,” she said.
asserted
she → drift → years
“I’m quite reassured that the Quad is becoming more strategic than it was before.”
asserted
it → ’m → ?
The four nations have participated in annual joint naval drills since 2020, but they have not been formally badged as Quad exercises.
asserted
they → participate → exercises
While the distinction may sound semantic, Lee thinks it matters.
uncertain
it → sound → ?
“This is the first explicit military exercise of the Quad,” she says.
asserted
she → say → Quad
“That crosses an operational and symbolic threshold.
asserted
That → cross → threshold
This is the Quad coming out and saying ‘we are actively working on deterrence’.”
asserted
we → come → deterrence
The possibility of substantial military co-operation among the Quad nations is precisely why China has bristled at the group’s existence.
asserted
China → bristle → existence
The Chinese navy’s circumnavigation of Australia last year and firing of a nuclear-capable missile into the Pacific this year shows its desire to expand its influence far from its shores with as little meddling as possible.
asserted
circumnavigation → show → meddling
Beijing “won’t be happy, they would be troubled by this”, Lee says of the Quad’s maritime surveillance activities.
asserted
Lee → trouble → activities
Similarly, the Quad’s focus on co-operation on critical minerals has the potential to dent China’s dominance of supply chains.
asserted
focus → have → chains
To be sure, Trump is still disturbingly cosy with dictators such as Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, with whom he is sitting down for a rare trilateral summit on the sidelines of the APEC forum in China.
asserted
he → sit → China
Given Trump’s predilection for hobnobbing with strongmen, it’s a win for Australia that his administration remains committed to groupings such as the Quad.
asserted
administration → give → Quad
“Trump has placed little personal emphasis on the Quad,” says the Centre for Strategic and International Studies’ Australia chair Charles Edel, “yet the grouping has persisted and grown more focused on security-related outcomes.”
asserted
grouping → place → outcomes
For all Trump’s flaws, Michael Green, a former senior official in the George W Bush administration, welcomes the Quad’s focus on harder-edged security co-operation rather than the delivery of public goods (like COVID-19 vaccines) under Biden.
“The thing that keeps the Quad alive is China and its aggressive activities in the Indo-Pacific,” says Green, the head of the US Studies Centre.
asserted
Green → welcome → Centre
“Rumours of the Quad’s demise have been very much exaggerated – the Quad is not dead.”
asserted
Quad → exaggerate → demise
While still more of a fragile work in progress than a fearsome military alliance, the Quad is here to stay and has scope to grow into something more profound.
Cut through the noise of federal politics with news, views and expert analysis.
asserted
Quad → stay → news
Subscribers can sign up to our weekly Inside Politics newsletter.
asserted
Subscribers → sign → newsletter