In an industry where time has always been money, AI is forcing firms to rethink the value of both, writes Maria Ward-Brennan.
asserted
Brennan → force → both
The billable hour has long been the traditional charging system used by professional services firms, especially law firms.
asserted
hour → use → firms
Partners and associates have long been glued to their timesheets, logging every second spent on a client so their firms can issue bills as soon as a matter is completed.
asserted
matter → glue → bills
The system is also used internally across the consultancy sector, helping with ‘account recovery’ rates and the deployment of resources.
asserted
system → use → resources
But it’s long been at the forefront of a debate over how to price work in an industry where time is money.
asserted
time → price → industry
This open conversation has intensified in recent years with the rise of AI, as clients have been asking how their work is changing when AI is involved at various stages of it and in new, different ways.
asserted
AI → intensify → ways
Over the last couple of years, firms have embedded sophisticated AI models into their systems, speeding up previously time-intensive tasks.
asserted
firms → embed → tasks
As a result, speculation has grown about the future of the traditional billable-hour system.
asserted
speculation → grow → system
But when it comes to whether the billable-hour system will stay in place, or another model will be used, the sector has remained very quiet.
asserted
sector → come → place
AI offers ‘huge opportunity for innovation’
asserted
AI → offer → innovation
However, the silence seems to be breaking after a rare comment on how law firms are approaching the issue.
asserted
firms → seem → issue
Baker McKenzie’s global chair, Sunny Mann, told the Wall Street Journal that the firm is shifting away from billing clients by the hour by default to a value-based billing model.
asserted
firm → tell → model
Baker McKenzie’s London office confirmed Mann’s comments reflect a global approach.
asserted
comments → confirm → approach
A spokesperson for the firm told City AM: “We see the evolving market as an opportunity to engage innovatively with our clients.”
asserted
We → tell → clients
“Alternative fee arrangements are very much part of the mix we want to offer.
asserted
we → want → mix
Hourly billing remains applicable where clients prefer it or where it is the most appropriate model for the work.
asserted
it → remain → work
Our focus as a firm is on being responsive to what our clients want,” they added.
asserted
they → want → what
Lots of unanswered requests
When City AM reached out to a number of law firms across the City to ask whether Baker McKenzie’s comment had made them rethink their strategy, or reflected their own changes, we were met with many ‘no-comments’ or just an outright (and unusual) ignoring of the request.
asserted
we → reach → request
But the chief executive of Hogan Lovells Cadwalader did respond to City AM.
asserted
executive → respond → AM
The boss of the City-headquartered global firm said AI is driving the sector away from the traditional system and toward a value-based pricing model.
asserted
AI → headquarter → model
Miguel Zaldivar said: “AI is going to completely transform our delivery model over the next two or three years.
asserted
AI → say → years
We are deploying significant investment into AI, building on the investments we have been making year after year in our technology and our own capabilities.
asserted
we → deploy → technology
The billable hour has defined this industry for decades.
asserted
hour → define → decades
AI is a game-changer because it fundamentally changes the relationship between time, value, and price,” he added.
asserted
he → change → price
Zaldivar explained: “If AI enables us to deliver a piece of work in 30 hours that historically took 50, the discussion cannot simply be about how many hours we recorded.
asserted
we → explain → hours
Increasingly, it will be: this is the work you need, this is the value we can deliver, and this is the price.
asserted
this → need → ?
“We are entering a transition that will reshape the economics of the legal industry, and by 2030 the market as we know it today will look very different,” the boss added.
asserted
boss → enter → it
While in the accountancy space, private equity-backed tax specialist Ryan broke with the billable-hour tradition.
asserted
Ryan → back → tradition
Speaking to City AM in June, Tom Shave, president of Europe and Asia Pacific at Ryan, said: “I believe that we have a commercial model that will be successful in the age of AI and technology…
asserted
that → speak → AI
our approach is that we effectively charge our clients on a value-based route, so we don’t have hundreds of people doing timesheets.
asserted
hundreds → charge → timesheets
”
But whatever billing system emerges, don’t expect law firms to lose interest in how much work their lawyers are doing.
asserted
lawyers → emerge → work