South African President Cyril Ramaphosa brought a large delegation to Silicon Valley this week, seeking investment.
asserted
Ramaphosa → bring → investment
But he stepped on his message by attacking Elon Musk, the biggest player in tech.
asserted
he → step → tech
Musk, born (like me) in South Africa, emigrated to Canada as a teenager and made his way to the US, making his fortune as one of the founders of PayPal in the early days of e-commerce.
asserted
Musk → bear → commerce
He went on to buy Tesla, a pioneer in electric vehicle technology, and now the world’s most valuable car company.
asserted
He → go → technology
He also launched SpaceX, which is breaking new boundaries in rocket technology.
asserted
which → launch → technology
Later, he bought Twitter, renaming it “X,” and restoring free speech to the platform.
asserted
he → buy → platform
He came to the US with nothing, and nearly lost his fortune several times, before becoming the world’s first trillionaire.
asserted
He → come → fortune
He has also become increasingly outspoken against “woke” politics, and led a controversial effort in the second Trump administration to trim government waste.
asserted
He → become → waste
Ramaphosa told ABC News’ Jonathan Karl on Monday that he wanted to talk to Musk — who became a U.S. citizen in 2002 — about “remembering his country,” meaning South Africa.
asserted
who → tell → Africa
He added that “you should still be loyal to your old country” after leaving.
asserted
you → add → country
Set aside the fact that the US oath of citizenship requires that new Americans “absolutely and entirely renounce” any loyalty to their former countries.
asserted
Americans → set → countries
What Ramaphosa really wants is for Musk to invest in South Africa out of a sense of moral obligation.
asserted
Musk → want → obligation
Advertisement
Ramaphosa said that Musk should proclaim: “I would like to contribute to the development of South Africa and give back to this country that made me who I am today.”
asserted
I → say → country
The irony is that Musk has been trying to do just that.
asserted
Musk → try → that
He has been trying to bring Starlink’s satellite Internet to South Africa for years.
asserted
He → try → years
The reason Musk has pulled back is due to South Africa’s policy of racial redistribution of ownership.
asserted
Musk → pull → ownership
The policy is called “Black Economic Empowerment,” and it requires large companies to sell a significant proportion of their equity to “historically disadvantaged individuals” — i.e., black South Africans who suffered under apartheid.
asserted
who → call → apartheid
Advertisement
Apartheid, which ended with the first multiracial democratic elections in 1994, restricted black ownership, barred black people from certain jobs, and imposed an inferior curriculum on segregated black schools.
asserted
which → end → schools
It unfairly excluded black South Africans from their country’s prosperity.
asserted
It → exclude → prosperity
The problem is that attempting to achieve a sudden equality of outcomes, through forced racial redistribution, destroys wealth, rewards corruption, and limits investment.
asserted
attempting → attempt → investment
The people who suffer most are black South Africans, who might find employment and opportunity in an economy whose growth (-0.3%) wasn’t being strangled by racial policy.
uncertain
growth → suffer → policy
In practice, Black Economic Empowerment tends to reward a few black people who are already rich.
asserted
who → tend → people
That is partly because companies can’t find enough black investors with the wealth to buy major stakes.
asserted
companies → find → stakes
It is also because the ruling party steers companies toward taking on loyal party members as investors.
asserted
party → rule → investors
Moeletsi Mbeki, the brother of former president Thabo Mbeki, has called Black Economic Empowerment “legalized corruption.”
asserted
Mbeki → call → Empowerment
He has pointed out that because many of the new black shareholders cannot, in fact, afford to buy them, they have to borrow money — often from the other shareholders.
asserted
they → point → shareholders
That takes capital out of the market, where it could be doing something more productive, and devotes it to a redistribution project that adds little of economic value.
uncertain
that → take → value
Then there is the problem that Black Economic Empowerment reinforces racial divisions — in a country that once hoped to overcome them.
asserted
that → be → them
Ramaphosa, visiting Silicon Valley, claimed that Musk has “difficulty in understanding” the policy.
asserted
Musk → visit → policy
“All countries have policies in terms of how they admit companies to operate,” he said.
asserted
he → have → terms
“You’ve got to subscribe to the policies of the country.”
asserted
You → get → country
True — but investors are also free to walk away.
asserted
investors → walk → ?
Musk’s response to Ramaphosa, posted on his X platform, was blunt: “South Africa is now super racist against Whites and Asians.”
asserted
Africa → post → Whites
Later, another X user explained: “South African law literally requires Elon Musk & Starlink to give 30% ownership to some random black person just to be allowed to get in the country & compete …
asserted
law → explain → country
% of a company Elon built brick by brick.
asserted
Elon → build → brick
It’s the definition of racism.”
asserted
It → ’ → racism
Another chimed in, saying that “Mr. Musk wanted to invest in SA.
asserted
Musk → chime → SA
SA told him to give 30% of his company away.”
asserted
SA → tell → company
Musk answered, simply, “True.”
asserted
Musk → answer → True
Advertisement
Ramaphosa should have brought a compromise to Silicon Valley — an exemption from Black Economic Empowerment for foreign investors, for example.
asserted
Ramaphosa → bring → example
…and 2 more, not listed.