Late on Tuesday afternoon, the body of Melbourne Cup racehorse So You Are was found in a skip bin at a rubbish tip in Sydney.
asserted
body → find → Sydney
This story contains content that may be distressing to some readers.
uncertain
that → contain → readers
The five-year-old gelding had been rushed to an equine specialist with severe colic (a gastro-intestinal illness), and was euthanised when the issue could not be resolved.
uncertain
issue → rush → colic
A builder at the tip filmed the body and posted the video.
asserted
builder → film → video
The vet hospital said its contracted provider took the horse to the landfill where it should have been buried promptly.
asserted
it → say → landfill
It has apologised.
asserted
It → apologise → ?
Racing NSW, which is conducting an investigation, stated So You Are was awaiting burial when the video was recorded.
asserted
video → conduct → burial
What normally happens when horses die or are euthanised?
asserted
horses → happen → ?
An adult horse weighs around 500 kilograms, and a burial pit needs at least two metres of soil over the carcass.
asserted
pit → weigh → carcass
Many horse owners cannot bury a dead horse at home — they may not own a property or may lack the space or distance from water bodies to do it safely.
uncertain
they → bury → it
It is common practice for vets to dispose of dead horses at licensed landfills, and NSW Department of Primary Industries guidance lists licensed landfill as the preferred disposal option in most instances.
asserted
guidance → dispose → instances
The standard procedure is for carcasses to be placed in designated areas and covered without delay.
asserted
carcasses → place → delay
Some horses killed by captive bolt tools (where compressed gas or a specialised cartridge delivers high-velocity impacts) or firearms may be accepted by knackeries for rendering or use in pet food.
uncertain
gas → kill → food
However this option is not available if drugs have been used to euthanise the horse.
Why the euthanasia drugs matter
Vets usually euthanise horses with an overdose of a barbiturate, given intravenously.
The drug will depress breathing, brain activity and, ultimately, the heart.
asserted
drug → use → breathing
During the euthanasia process it will be carried by the blood stream throughout the body, leading to high concentrations in organs such as the kidneys, lungs and liver.
asserted
it → carry → kidneys
Because it is slow to break down, the drug will remain in tissue long after death.
asserted
drug → break → death
This can poison animals that consume the carcass.
asserted
that → poison → carcass
In one reported case, dogs were poisoned after scavenging a partly buried horse that had been euthanised two years earlier.
asserted
that → report → horse
Studies of composted horse carcasses have found the drug still present in compost and liquids leaching from the soil.
asserted
drug → compost → soil
A review of reported cases found most poisoned wild animals were scavenging birds, and 86 per cent of those were eagles or their relatives.
asserted
cent → report → those
Dogs are the most often reported domestic victims.
asserted
Dogs → report → ?
Why a skip bin is a problem
Prompt and deep burial removes this risk.
asserted
burial → remove → risk
A carcass in an open skip, even for a short time, is within reach of birds and may be moved on with general waste rather than deeply buried.
uncertain
carcass → move → waste
If left in the bin for an extended period, the decomposition process can lead to unpleasant odours and carcasses can be a breeding ground for flies, which can transmit disease.
asserted
which → leave → disease
The risks of secondary poisoning are well understood by the veterinary profession, which is why vet practices establish relationships with local landfills.
asserted
practices → understand → landfills
How So You Are came to be in the bin instead of buried, and for how long, is for the investigation to establish.
asserted
investigation → come → bin
Why a horse in a skip bin shocks us
asserted
horse → shock → us
Much of the reaction to the video has nothing to do with how So You Are was euthanised under veterinary care.
asserted
You → have → care
Many are reacting to the sight of a specific horse, a Melbourne Cup runner with a brand on his shoulder, lying among building waste as if he were household rubbish.
asserted
he → react → waste
Such treatment seems a callous contradiction to industry narratives of how much care horses receive and how well they are loved.
asserted
they → seem → care
It contravenes our expectations of how the body of a deceased equine "athlete" should be treated.
asserted
body → contravene → athlete
The reverent burial of champions such as Makybe Diva appear to honour the service given by horses to racing.
asserted
burial → appear → racing
Tuesday's video makes visible something that is usually hidden.
asserted
that → make → ?
Even after the best veterinary care, dead horses end up in local tips.
asserted
horses → end → tips
Landfill burial may appear more respectful than a skip bin, but its purpose is sanitary and to protect wildlife: it is still burial in a rubbish dump.
uncertain
it → appear → dump
A dead horse has no welfare
For So You Are, the dumping of his body in the bin is not an animal welfare issue.
asserted
dumping → have → bin
Welfare concerns what an animal experiences: pain, fear, comfort, pleasure.
asserted
animal → concern → what
A dead horse experiences nothing and has no interest in what happens to its body.
asserted
what → experience → body
The distress belongs to the people who cared for him, and the real risk is to the animals that might eat from the carcass.
uncertain
that → belong → carcass
For the horse, what mattered was how he lived and how he died.
asserted
he → matter → horse
…and 3 more, not listed.