Parliament’s budget watchdog is shedding new light on potential weak spots in Prime Minister Mark Carney’s heavy-spending fiscal plan — including hundreds of billions of dollars in shadowy government borrowing that goes beyond the $62.3-billion deficit.
asserted
that → shed → deficit
In a quartet of reports published Tuesday, Parliamentary Budget Officer Annette Ryan said government spending "would be deemed sustainable" over the long term, but that lower-than-projected economic growth or new spending on top of the $331.6 billion that has been booked since Carney took office could knock Ottawa off that track.
uncertain
Carney → publish → track
She also raised questions about how the government’s “fiscal anchors” don’t restrain overall spending, and suggested Ottawa might have abandoned its promise from 2025 to build 500,000 new homes each year.
uncertain
Ottawa → raise → homes
It was fuel for the opposition Conservatives, who pounced on the findings as proof the Carney government is irresponsible with the public purse.
asserted
government → pounce → purse
The government pushed back, claiming its fiscal plan will drive hundreds of billions of dollars in investments to jump-start G7-leading economic growth.
asserted
plan → push → growth
Here’s a look at the main points — and points of debate — from Ryan’s reports:
asserted
look → ’ → reports
‘Borrowing more to invest more’
Since he rode to the Liberal leadership and became prime minister last year, Carney and his government have made a core promise over and over again — to “spend less so Canada can invest more.”
asserted
Canada → borrow → more
In her reports Tuesday, Ryan poked holes in that pledge, describing how the government is actually "borrowing more to invest more."
asserted
government → poke → more
Part of that is a spike in government spending since Carney took office.
asserted
Carney → take → office
Through the 2025 budget, this year’s spring economic update and last week’s 2026 budget, the government has earmarked $331.6 billion in new spending — more than the $284.6 billion in new spending over seven spending plans unveiled between the fiscal update in 2021 and the 2024 update before Carney’s first budget last year.
asserted
government → earmark → budget
A large chunk of that new spending was detailed in last week’s budget, when the government earmarked $151.5 billion in new measures over the next five years on policies including the $36-billion “mega deduction” to drive business investment, and $11.2 billion to “end” homelessness.
asserted
government → detail → homelessness
The spending gobbled up 96 per cent of the $158 billion in new funding on the federal books, which Ryan attributed largely to revenues from higher oil prices.
asserted
Ryan → gobble → prices
Had the government used that windfall to pay down the annual deficit, this year’s shortfall would have clocked in at roughly $20 billion lower than the $62.3 billion forecast, Ryan found.
asserted
Ryan → use → forecast
The deficit doesn’t tell the whole story
asserted
deficit → tell → story
Ryan described how loans to Crown corporations and investments through the planned $25-billion “Canada Strong Fund” come from borrowing that doesn’t get booked with the annual deficit.
asserted
that → describe → deficit
Appearing at the House of Commons’ finance committee Tuesday, Ryan said the budget doesn’t provide precise details about this borrowing, and her reports suggested MPs could ask for more details, such as which Crown corporations are borrowing.
uncertain
corporations → appear → details
Overall, this spending will amplify the accumulated debt from the deficit by $476 billion over the next five years.
asserted
spending → amplify → years
That leads to a total of $764.7 billion in borrowed money by 2030-31 — the most “in peacetime” ever for a federal government, Ryan suggested Tuesday.
uncertain
Ryan → lead → government
The government is betting that Canada will maintain the lower interest rates that come with the country’s top credit rating, and that its borrowing will be paid for by the future economic growth it creates.
asserted
it → bet → growth
But, Ryan pointed out Tuesday, if that doesn’t pan out, the money still needs to get paid back.
asserted
money → point → ?
‘Fiscal anchors’ don’t mean less borrowing
Ryan also raised questions about the government’s “fiscal anchors” — targets it pledged to maintain to show it is prudent with public money.
asserted
it → mean → money
She noted that the IMF has urged Canada to use a declining debt-to-GDP ratio as one of its anchors, instead of a declining deficit-to-GDP ratio, since it would “strengthen discipline, transparency and credibility.”
asserted
it → note → discipline
She also highlighted that federal spending on day-to-day operations will go up by $34.6 billion over the next five years, even as the government says it is “balancing” operational spending by next year.
asserted
it → highlight → year
Ryan agreed with Conservative MP Sandra Cobena that if the government used “internationally recognized definitions” for operational spending, this part of the budget would not be balanced as promised for another five years.
asserted
part → agree → years
Neither anchor applies to hundreds of billions of dollars in borrowing that doesn’t get counted in the deficit, Ryan’s report added.
asserted
report → apply → deficit
“Federal borrowing can therefore keep growing even while both anchors are met.”
asserted
anchors → keep → ?
Housing plan stalled?
asserted
plan → stall → ?
Another question raised in the report is whether the government is still striving to double the annual pace of housing construction to almost 500,000 new homes per year.
asserted
government → raise → year
Ryan’s report noted that new homes under construction have dropped four per cent year over year in 2026 so far, meaning that the government is “not on track” to meet its goal.
asserted
government → note → goal
In a statement Tuesday, Ryan said the government “seems to have stepped away” from that commitment.
asserted
government → say → commitment
Under fire from the opposition, Housing Minister Gregor Robertson said the government is putting “unprecedented” focus on housing affordability, with billions of dollars earmarked to remove sales tax and reduce red tape and development charges to get more units built.
asserted
units → say → tape
He did not say whether the government would still double the pace of homebuilding.
asserted
government → say → homebuilding