Highways chiefs missed ten chances over the course of a year to identify and fix more than 150 faulty speed cameras which have made smart motorways even ‘more deadly.’
asserted
motorways → miss → cameras
A damning report found that despite being alerted by police in January 2025, roads agency National Highways repeatedly failed to act and didn’t alert the public until last December.
asserted
Highways → find → December
It meant potentially thousands more drivers were wrongly issued with speeding fines by defective cameras than should have been.
asserted
drivers → mean → cameras
And the issue still hasn’t been fixed, meaning the affected 154 cameras covering 440 miles of major roads – including smart motorways – in England have been out of action since December 2025.
asserted
cameras → fix → December
This is the equivalent of one in ten miles of the country’s Strategic Road Network, which includes all motorways and major A-roads.
asserted
which → include → motorways
Enforcement on smart motorways is particularly important because they have variable speed limits to help prevent deaths and injuries.
asserted
they → have → deaths
It comes after years of safety concerns over smart motorways, which a Mail campaign has drawn attention to by highlighting several arguably avoidable deaths on the roads.
asserted
campaign → come → roads
More than 150 speed cameras covering 440 miles of major roads – including smart motorways – in England have been out of action since December 2025
Tory shadow transport minister Greg Smith said the failures were 'beyond unacceptable'
Edmund King, AA president, said that today's report 'was not simply a technical fault, but a failure to respond with the urgency motorists deserved'
asserted
motorists → cover → urgency
Labour was accused of trying to bury the news by slipping the report out today while all eyes in Westminster were on the release of the Milburn report to tackle youth unemployment.
asserted
eyes → accuse → unemployment
Ministers have been sitting on it since July after Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander ordered it in January this year.
asserted
Alexander → sit → January
Today, the Home Office said it was ending its contract with American firm Verra Mobility, which operates the 154 affected cameras.
asserted
which → say → cameras
Tory shadow transport secretary Richard Holden said: ‘Thousands of drivers have been hit with fines when they have done nothing wrong, with Labour ministers asleep at the wheel throughout.
‘When errors were found they should have been dealt with immediately.
asserted
they → say → wheel
It should not have taken so many warnings to get action nor have taken so long to resolve.
asserted
It → take → action
‘We all know Labour is in an ideological war against drivers but presiding over the missing of ten points [in time] during which opportunities for action were missed is unbelievable.’
asserted
opportunities → know → action
Tory shadow transport minister Greg Smith added: ‘This is beyond unacceptable.
‘To sit on a report detailing highways failings is testament to how little this government cares about motorists, their safety and their journeys.
asserted
government → add → motorists
They are playing fast and loose with safety.’
asserted
They → play → safety
Edmund King, AA president, said: ‘This was not simply a technical fault, but a failure to respond with the urgency motorists deserved.
‘
asserted
motorists → say → urgency
Drivers must have confidence that motorway technology is accurate, reliable and properly tested, particularly on so-called “smart” motorways.
asserted
technology → have → motorways
‘This is about protecting lives and restoring public confidence.’
asserted
This → protect → confidence
Today's report said that faults in the way speed cameras interacted with variable speed signs on overhead gantries should have been identified by National Highways at ‘the specification and testing stage’ before 2025.
asserted
cameras → say → 2025
‘Many of the subsequent problems arose because this did not happen’, it added.
asserted
it → arise → problems
In January that year, Avon and Somerset Constabulary raised the alarm after a driver provided dashcam evidence proving that they’d wrongly been issued with a speeding ticket while driving on the M5.
asserted
they → raise → M5
Around 2,650 wrongly issued speeding tickets since 2021 have been identified so far as a result of the faulty speed cameras, but it is thought there could be thousands more
Tory shadow transport secretary Richard Holden blasted: ‘Thousands of drivers have been hit with fines when they have done nothing wrong.'
It showed that a 50mph speed limit had been displayed on an overhead gantry, despite the driver getting a ticket for exceeding a 40mph limit.
uncertain
driver → issue → limit
But National Highways failed to escalate the warning and launch a probe after concluding it was an ‘isolated incident’, which the report said was ‘not based on any demonstrable data analysis or other hard evidence’.
asserted
report → fail → analysis
In March that year, National Highways was warned by Road Safety Support, an expert not-for-profit company, that it was not an isolated incident and likely ‘needed to be escalated to the police and to National Highways’s legal services.’
But this didn’t happen.
asserted
this → warn → services
A formal team of investigators – which took ten weeks to assemble – wasn’t formed until August following other missed chances, the report said.
asserted
report → take → chances
But even then, despite the ‘emerging understanding of the overall impact in terms of the potential risk of wrongful prosecution [of drivers for speeding] and reputational risk’, National Highways failed to initiate its own Crisis Management Manual.
asserted
Highways → emerge → Manual
The report said this was another missed opportunity.
asserted
this → say → ?
Even by the end of September 2025, ‘the root cause was still not fully acknowledged’, but it became clear at this point it was a wider problem.
asserted
it → acknowledge → point
However, the National Police Chiefs’ Council should have been fully briefed on the issue earlier than happened and it wasn’t until November 2025 that National Highways ‘finally notified the relevant 22 police forces of the issue’, the report said.
asserted
report → brief → issue
The report detailed ten ‘missed opportunities’ in total, with the roads agency finally alerting the public in December last year.
asserted
agency → detail → December
Around 2,650 wrongly issued speeding tickets since 2021 have been identified so far, but it is thought there could be thousands more.
uncertain
it → issue → 2021
In a written statement today, roads minister Justin Madders said: ‘Safety remains our overriding priority and the additional steps we are taking to implement enforcement arrangements will ensure action can be taken against anyone who breaks the law.’
asserted
who → write → law
National Highways said Verra Mobility was scheduled to be replaced as the operator in 2028, but that this will now be ‘accelerated’.
asserted
this → say → 2028