Action must be taken to tackle Scotland’s NEETs crisis, SNP ministers have been warned after a long-awaited review demanded a UK-wide overhaul.
asserted
review → take → overhaul
Nearly one in six young Scots aged between 16 and 24 are NEET in Scotland, and the rate is higher than other parts of the UK.
asserted
rate → age → UK
In his review, Alan Milburn made clear that he believed the underlying principles of his recommendations ‘should be applied across the UK’.
asserted
principles → make → UK
His report triggered a plea from the UK Government for SNP ministers to work with them to tackle the problem in Scotland.
asserted
ministers → trigger → Scotland
But a senior SNP minister repeatedly refused to say if she even believed there is a NEETs crisis in Scotland – and said she doesn’t like using the term NEET because it is a ‘label’.
asserted
it → refuse → NEET
Scottish Secretary Douglas Alexander said: ‘Right now, far too many young people are missing out, with around one in six young Scots currently not in work, education or training.
asserted
people → say → work
SNP Education Secretary Mairi McAllan refused to say whether she believed there was a ‘NEETs crisis’ in Scotland
Alan Milburn made clear that he believed the underlying principles of his recommendations ‘should be applied across the UK’
‘The Prime Minister has been clear that it would be an economic catastrophe and a moral failure to stand by and watch a generation of young people be left behind.
asserted
generation → refuse → people
Tackling this crisis is a top priority for the UK Government.
asserted
Tackling → tackle → Government
Alan Milburn’s review has today set out how we can tackle this - earlier support and real opportunities, with a clear expectation that young people take them up.
asserted
people → set → them
I very much welcome his report.
asserted
I → welcome → report
‘We want to ensure young people in every part of Scotland can benefit from this approach and reach their full potential, whether that’s through a training course, an apprenticeship or a first job.
asserted
that → want → course
‘This work will go hand in hand with the Prime Minister’s commitment to deepening devolution across Scotland, working in partnership with the Scottish Government to push power out of the centre and into the hands of our cities and regions.’
asserted
work → go → cities
The Milburn review makes a series of recommendations across education, health and welfare.
asserted
review → make → education
While some of the measures, such as a guaranteed job for eligible young people who have been out of work for 18 months, can apply across the UK, some measures on the benefits system do not automatically apply in Scotland because powers have been devolved.
asserted
powers → guarantee → Scotland
One of the key proposals which won’t apply in Scotland is a new Additional Cost Allowance to replace the health element of Personal Independence Payment, as this benefit has been devolved to Holyrood and replaced with the adult disability payment.
asserted
benefit → apply → payment
But Mr Milburn’s review said: ‘The diagnosis is UK-wide, but the institutional answer will differ because education, skills, health and local government are devolved in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.
asserted
education → say → Scotland
‘Each devolved government should consider how those principles fit its own institutions and existing youth, careers and employment services.’
asserted
principles → devolve → institutions
A Youth Employment Index by accountancy firm PWC found that Scotland’s NEET rate was 16 per cent, which was higher than any other UK region, while Labour highlighted that the figure indicates that 90,000 young people in Scotland are NEET.
asserted
people → find → Scotland
Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra said: ‘One in six young people not in work, education or training in Scotland is a moral failing from a political system which has for too long looked the other way.
asserted
which → say → system
That ends today.
asserted
That → end → ?
‘While everyone needs time to consider the report in full, the Milburn Review proposes a totally new settlement for young people, wherever they live in the UK.
asserted
they → need → UK
This includes subsidised jobs and support which ever part of the country they live in, and new legal rights to opportunity and support.
asserted
they → include → opportunity
It outlines that getting young people into work is not solely about the benefit system.
asserted
getting → outline → system
It’s about education, the health service and local economic development.
asserted
It → ’ → education
‘The UK and Scottish government have shared responsibilities to these young people.
asserted
government → share → people
This new deal for young people will require new ways of working from their two governments.
asserted
deal → require → governments
To move away from the politics of point scoring and finger pointing and towards one that delivers results for people.
asserted
that → move → people
Anything less would be failing a generation of young people who have been ignored by politicians for far too long.’
asserted
who → fail → politicians
The Scottish Conservatives highlighted that the review found too little welfare spending went to supporting young people into employment.
asserted
spending → highlight → employment
Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay said: ‘Labour has finally woken up to the failings of a welfare system that is too focused on paying people benefits rather than helping them find work.
‘
asserted
them → say → work
John Swinney must take note ahead of his Budget.
asserted
Swinney → take → Budget
Scotland cannot afford another year of soaring welfare spending, punishing taxes and an SNP government that refuses to get to grips with the problem.’
asserted
that → afford → problem
Sandy Begbie, chief executive of Scottish Financial Enterprise, said: ‘While the legislative landscape is undoubtedly complex between reserved and devolved policy areas, the Scottish government should adopt a constructive approach to these recommendations that prioritise the young people who have – across the whole of the UK – missed out on opportunities in recent years.
asserted
who → say → years
‘Scotland already has a Young Person’s Guarantee – which previously had cross-party backing in Holyrood - and Scottish ministers should revisit this to match the ambition set out in the Milburn report.’
asserted
ministers → have → report
SNP Education Secretary Mairi McAllan refused to say whether she believed there was a ‘NEETs crisis’ in Scotland when asked five times by journalists, although she said there is ‘real difficulty in the economy’ across the UK which has left some young people struggling to gain entry-level jobs.
asserted
which → refuse → jobs
She said: ‘That is a reflection on the underlying economic conditions of the UK as much as it is on anything to do with education or social security and the recommendations that have been made in the report.’
asserted
that → say → report
Ms McAllan also challenged the use of the term NEET, saying: ‘I don’t particularly like the term NEETs, it is something that the Scottish Government hasn’t necessarily pursued as a label.
asserted
Government → challenge → label
I think it encourages us not to look at the individuals behind it.’
asserted
it → think → it
She said that for 16-24-year-olds the employment rate is higher in Scotland than in England, and added: ‘Where there is opportunity to collaborate with the UK Government and others for the benefit of young people in Scotland, we will take it.’
asserted
we → say → it
First Minister John Swinney said: ‘There is a great deal in the Milburn review that the Government will consider, and I think it is a substantial contribution to the debate.’
asserted
it → say → debate
…and 2 more, not listed.